Unlocking the Cultural Secrets of Sperm Whales

Whale researcher Shane Gero has spent years studying sperm whales in an effort to better understand their daily lives, methods of communication, and cultures. He’s discovered how fundamentally similar their lives are to our own and how closely their relationships are tied to their identities. 

In the following piece, Shane explores the influence of culture in shaping individuals and societies, highlighting the role of language and cultural norms in both human and animal interactions. He advocates for a shift in wildlife conservation, urging humans to include cultural diversity as an essential component of biodiversity and to learn from the whales’ powerful sense of community.

Following is an edited transcript of a presentation that took place at Bioneers 2023.


Twenty-four years before I was even born, in 1956, as the sun was setting, a man stood in uniform at the border between the countries of Hungary and Austria. The iconography on his shirt and his arm told you of his national allegiances, his rank, his position in life, literally the dividing line between some on one side, and others on the other. 

This night, one commonality between people who lived on both sides of the line was cigarettes. For him, this cigarette was no big deal. It was just another break from his job, another butt on the floor of the guardhouse. But for me, this cigarette would secure the safe passage of a woman. This cigarette would change my native language, the color of my passport, and my identity. 

This woman is my grandmother. She grew up in a small town in Hungary, and like many others at the time, emigrated to Canada. I only knew her as “Granny,” but in a life lived before my own, she was a pioneer of women in science working toward her Ph.D. in biochemistry.

So much of who I am came from my Grann. Little things, like cutting the butter straight, not scooping it off the top. But also very foundational parts of who I am, like how important family is, and to not forget where you come from. Other than one trip where I spent a little bit of time visiting distant family in Hungary, I still feel like Hungary is somehow a part of who I am, because who you learn from in your life defines so much of who you’ll become and what you do. We’re all human, but culture is how we learn to be one. 

Human cultures have played a huge part in deciding where people live and how they behave across civilization. As early humans evolved, language served as a cheat sheet for doing things the same way as one another. Even today, you’re far more likely to help someone who yells for help in your native language than in any other. Culture can be a unifying force but also a very divisive one, and it’s structured all of human civilization.

We know that humans aren’t the only cultural animal out there. Animal culture pervades all facets of their lives. In an amazing study in chimpanzee communities across Africa, primatologists documented the different ways that chimpanzees have figured out how to live. Because of the destruction of their habitat, mostly caused by humans, chimpanzee communities are very isolated.

In the world’s oceans, there iss a nomad that lives in this boundless blue. In that giant area, they are succeeding together at building multicultural societies. Sperm whales have been sperm whales for longer than humans have even been walking upright, so their stories are deeper than our stories. Stories like the one about a mother, who we call Can Opener, swimming through a deep, dark, and often dangerous ocean, working with her community to raise and defend their calves, like her tiny little one named Hope. 

Since 2005, I’ve had the immense privilege of spending thousands of hours in the company of Hope and Can Opener’s family, and now about 30 to 40 other families off the Caribbean island called Dominica. It’s one of the first times that anyone’s come to know these biblical Leviathans as individuals, as brothers and sisters, or as mothers and daughters.

When I think about spending half of my life learning from and listening to someone who is fundamentally different from me, I’ve taken away a lot of universal lessons.

One of the novel things that we were able to do with so much time in the company of whale families is follow the lives of the young males as they grow up and leave their families. If you’re a male sperm whale, the first 15 years of your life is spent in a hyper social community of families where you’re born. When you’re a teenager, you sound like your mom, you behave like your mom. Then all of a sudden, you start this incredible voyage around the world to live a mostly solitary life until you grow to be the size of about two school buses, and really become Moby Dick.

There’s a big shift, which isn’t so unlike our late teenage years, where you leave behind your family and go out on your own. But for the families that stay in Dominica, they learn from generations of strong female leaders – grandmothers, mothers, and daughters, who live together for life. They’ve learned the fundamental truth that both they and we know, which is that family is critical to our survival. 

When Fingers, an elder in Hope’s family, makes a deep dive, she’s diving so long that she’s holding her breath for over an hour, and she’s going three times deeper than modern nuclear attack submarines. Her unique nose houses the most powerful natural sonar system, and it means that she can explore parts of the oceans that we find difficult to even get to, which makes sperm whales a critically important part of the oceanic ecosystem.

When they talk to each other, they talk in distinct patterned sequences of clicks with stereotyped rhythms and tempos, called codas. The norm for conversation is to overlap one another and to match each other’s calls. It sounds very exciting, and it has an elegant complexity to what, at least initially, seemed like a very simple system of clicks and pauses.

I’ve recently launched a much larger project working with international researchers, called Project CETI. Our mission is to try and decode what sperm whales are saying, to answer that fundamental question of “What is so important to whales that they need to talk about it?”

What we’ve learned from our work in Dominica and around the globe is that whales mark these cultural differences with different dialects and sets of codas. All families that speak the same dialect are part of a clan. Hope and Can Opener’s clan is the Eastern Caribbean clan, and they all learn a very special coda called the 1+1+3. 

This call is unique to them. It’s only ever been recorded in the Caribbean. Calves take about two years to learn to make it right, and they really need to, because when two families meet at sea, they need to make a decision about whether or not they’re going to spend time together and collaborate. As it turns out, if they speak the same dialect, they’ll spend time together, and if they don’t, they won’t. Because behavior is what you do, but culture is how you’ve learned to do it.

Sperm whales are all sperm whales across the globe, but how they’ve learned to live their lives is very different. In the same way that some of us use chopsticks and some of us use forks, the sperm whales differ in what they eat and how they eat, where they roam, how fast they move around, their habitat preferences, their social behavior, and probably myriad ways that we don’t even understand yet. These cultures are fundamental to their identities. 

Sperm whales use acoustic markers to label where they belong, which makes sperm whale clans the largest culturally defined cooperative groups outside of humanity. 

Right now, I’m running a large project with international researchers from around the world, across three different oceans, in which we’re mapping the boundaries of these sperm whale clans. Whales have been traditionally managed based on arbitrary lines that were defined by the whalers that were killing them. More recently, through international conservation policy, they are based on broad genetic patterns that are mostly driven by the solitary males that swim from one ocean to another, from one clan to the other, moving the genes around. However, the genetic patterns can’t capture the diversity of a whale’s life in the same way that we can’t imagine that what’s encoded in human genetics can teach us everything that it is to be a human.

This is why we need to focus our conservation on the patterns of cultural diversity that we see in these female-led clans that they’re self-identifying into. We need to ignore the systems that we’ve used before and shift to a new system. This is what the global Coda Dialect Project was about: to drive home that there’s a new scientific understanding that can serve as a foundation to totally restructure international conservation policy.

We’re going to do things differently because we listen to and learn from those to whom it matters most. And we need to do that now, because sadly, we’ve been killing whales for hundreds of years, and we do so now mostly out of ignorance rather than intent. We hit them with our ships from the ever-growing shipping fleet that brings us the economy from around the world. We entangle them in our omnipresent leftover fishing gear, like Digit, who’s in Hope’s family.

Every calf counts. When you have small families that desperately need females to perpetuate themselves, if they don’t survive, you lose the family. When we lose a family, we lose generations of traditional knowledge of how to succeed as a Caribbean whale. And that can’t be replaced, even if the global population could swim into the Caribbean again, because these would be different whales from elsewhere who do things differently, who’ve learned from different grandmothers and are missing the solutions for how to succeed there.

These cultures aren’t just animals who’ve learned to do things differently because they never meet. These are really the link between the ocean that they live in and the animals that live there. It’s a bond between where and who. 

That’s why we can’t just do wildlife conservation based on total numbers or genetic stocks. We need to have the definition of biodiversity include cultural diversity. These secrets are the secrets that are allowing these species to survive. They’re the viable solutions to species survival, and we need to model our framework for conservation around that.

In the era of a climate crisis, in the shadow of a global pandemic, on a day where millions of humans are facing imminent threat from war, it’s totally academic to talk about animal communication and whale culture — but it’s a bigger message than that. If you can take one message from the culture of whales, it’s the power of community — that in the face of these unimaginable obstacles, the solution is to come together.

Painting for Peace, Interview with Laurie Marshall, Singing Tree Project Founder

Artist, Author, Educator Laurie Marshall
Interviewed by Bioneers’ Polina Smith

Laurie Marshall, an author and artist, founder of the Unity Through Creativity Foundation and the Singing Tree Project, is a certified K-12 Art and Social Studies teacher. She has worked for four decades to empower youth and adults through creative collaboration in her Peace Building through Art Inspired by Nature programs. An Arts Integration and Project-Based Learning specialist, she joins in creativity, a love of learning and a collaborative spirit with youth, adults and elders. Making use of visual art and storytelling, she has developed a wide range of consensus building, leadership training and conflict prevention initiatives with clients that have included NASA, FEMA, the Army Corps of Engineers, the Department of Interior, the U.S. Botanical Gardens, as well as public schools, hospitals and prisons around the United States.

Polina Smith (PS): Laurie, how did you initially get involved in art, activism and teaching?

Laurie Marshall (LM): I grew up in Pennsylvania, and I got involved in peace activism very young. My parents, though my mother was raised Lutheran and my father a secular Jew, had become Quakers after they met during WWII. They resonated with the non-hierarchical Quaker belief that everyone has a divine light within them, with the silent meetings to listen for guidance from the Creator, and with the emphasis on good deeds in the world.

At nine years-old in 1958, I went to a Quaker conference in Cape May, New Jersey, with my family. Inside a long narrow hall, I felt the resonance of an electric voice that filled the crowded, creaky building. Waves of the Atlantic Ocean crashed below us. I couldn’t see the man who was speaking. I only saw the belt buckles and bellies of the grown-ups around me, but I experienced a contagious excitement. The man’s voice was a deep song. I remember his words, “People of all colors will live together like sisters and brothers.” The man was Martin Luther King, Jr. My soul was imprinted with this message. And at age 11 I dreamed I was sitting between Nikita Khrushchev and President Kennedy negotiating an end to nuclear war. I wanted there to be peace.

My path as an artist also began around that time, at the age of ten, but it got nipped in the bud. I wanted to draw trees. My family went on camping trips every summer, where we are all together—a rare treat with my father’s long work hours and my out-of-reach sisters in higher grades at school. I felt happy and excited on these adventures close to the Earth, the stars, and the mountains. On these camping trips and our suburban streets, trees captured my imagination. I found their smells, textures, changes, variety, blossoming, fruiting, falling, rooting and reaching endlessly fascinating, and trees house birds, which I also love. To express my love for trees, I set out to draw leaf after leaf after leaf. I tried to draw each leaf, but I was overwhelmed, daunted, and frustrated. After months of failure, I gave up—not only drawing trees but drawing altogether. My confidence was dashed. No one told me I could draw the big simple shape of the tree. Getting lost in the details had prevented me from seeing the whole. I stopped making any effort to capture what I saw and express what I loved.

But my path as an artist got resuscitated when I was 23 after a heartbreaking divorce. I was left with a gift from my failed marriage, the rediscovery of my love of drawing. As an extreme extrovert, I do not have easy access to my inner experience. During my childhood, I was often in a state of frozen numbness. But when I began to draw again, images appeared on the paper as if from an unknown source. Despair, sadness, anger, frustration, fear, terror, as well as joy, showed up. As the pictures appeared, the unconscious hold of the feelings dwindled. Drawing and painting allowed me to experience my Inner Light, giving me an endless abundance of ideas and a way to share my feelings with others.

I was also blessed to have a clear calling from a young age of wanting to be a teacher. I found pure joy in being with children and playing with them imaginatively. I majored in Education and History at the hands-on institution of Antioch College, getting certified to teach 7th-12th grade social studies. I was inspired by the work of visionary educators such as Paolo Freire, Sylvia Ashton-Warner and Jonathan Kozol. So, as art became more important to my own healing and self-awareness, it naturally evolved that I would combine those two passions of teaching and art.

I completed a self-directed Master’s Degree in Community Art, a title that did not fit into academics at the time, from Beacon College, now the Union Institute. I crafted a two-year program making art with elders, incarcerated youth, mentally-disabled teenagers and elementary school students. I also increased my artistic skills at the Art Students’ League in New York City and with local artists in Rappahannock County, VA, where I lived.

PS: Were there any among your many projects over the years that felt especially significant to you, that strongly affected your trajectory?

LM: In 1999, after I painted a 24’ x 4’ mural with all 130 students at Hillsboro Elementary School in rural Virginia, an eight-year-old girl, Meredith Miller, said, “I wish the whole world could see our painting, and then the whole world would be happy.” Then she asked, “What if the whole world made a painting together?”
Bam! My soul’s longing for peace, harmony and unity was met in this vision. What an impossible task—to invite the whole world to create together, but if all of humanity could consciously work together on a painting, it would demonstrate that we could work together to make a peaceful world.

I was excited and inspired but had no idea how to even conceive of trying to engage on such a project; then the model of individual trees joining forces to create whole forests sprung into my mind, and a structure for a series of murals began to grow in my imagination. I attended a conflict resolution conference with my father in San Sebastian, Spain, when a young teacher from Northern Ireland was puzzling about how she could bring the Catholic and Protestant children there together. I suggested making a painting of a tree, with children from both sides making leaves. The very subject that had made me give up drawing as a child became the key to my life’s work.

The universe also reinforced the importance of trees in the “how” of inviting the whole world to make a painting together. Someone handed me the Hungarian writer Kate Seredy’s book The Singing Tree. It tells the story of her father, who was a soldier in World War I: “One night, his battalion crawled all night long on their bellies to escape the enemy. Everything had been destroyed by war. When the dawn came, one tree was still alive. Birds from hundreds of miles away, who aren’t normally together, filled the tree, singing a song that had never been heard before.”

I saw the Earth as the Singing Tree of the solar system. All the things that divide us are not as important as the fact that we are unified in life on Earth, floating in space. We can choose to destroy each other and our Earth or create something beautiful that has never been seen before, like the new song of the birds in The Singing Tree. We can choose to generate unity through creativity—not through coercion, bombs, and bullets.

So, in 2002, I founded the Unity Through Creativity Foundation, a 501 C-3 non-profit that uses the arts as a peace-building tool, with the goal of transforming pain into purpose, trauma into beauty, and division into connection. I developed the visual structure of a tree on the Earth in space as a way for people to come together to let their visions and voices be known, to strengthen community and to be connected to those who believe in a world that works for all beings. Since then, 116 collaborative Singing Tree™ murals have been created by over 21,000 people from 52 countries, each one envisioning a positive future.

And since 2010 I’ve been coming to the Bioneers Conference and sharing this process with participants, often around the theme of the conferences. The Fig Singing Tree™ of the Child was the first mural I brought to Bioneers, made with youth from Palestine, Thailand, Laos, Cambodia, and Oakland and Santa Rosa, CA (https://www.unitythroughcreativity.org/singing-tree-murals/fig-singing-tree-of-the-child). Bioneers has been a touchstone for the Singing Tree mural project throughout the years. The themes, the speakers, the fellowship, the inspiration of “all our relatives” have strengthened and informed the invitation for the whole world to make a painting together. Another especially memorable episode was when Jane Goodall came to Bioneers, and the mural that year, The Jane Goodall Singing Tree of Love, was dedicated to her.

At Bioneers last year, 33 youth and adults designed and painted The Magical Window Singing Tree during the three days of the conference. Again, using the theme of the conference was the organizing principle of the collaborative mural (For a video of that process click here.

And the most recent, 116th, mural was facilitated by certified Singing Tree Facilitator Dr. Sweta Rein at Albany Middle School, in Albany, CA. It’s called The Ka-Sky-da-Scope Singing Tree™ of Strength and Happiness, and it will be on display at Bioneers 2023.

PS: Are there any new projects or directions on the horizon that you are especially excited by?

LM: I’m now certifying Singing Tree Facilitators to take this restorative, visionary and fun practice to communities around the world – teaching peace literacy skills in the process of inviting the whole world to make a painting together. So far, ten people have been certified from England to Uganda to the U.S.

I’m particularly excited about the Kyangwali Singing Tree to Heal the Trauma of War, envisioned by 27-year-old Kanizius Nsabimana from the Congo who has lived in a refugee camp in northern Uganda since he was nine. He is partnering with Ugandan artist Emma Kavuma. With the UN predicting that over 180 million people will be refugees in the next ten years, this project honors those who have lived the experience of being displaced for decades. Please watch the video we made to help raise funds: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-3TAjg5l9wE

I am also currently inspired and supported by Shiloh Sophia, founder of the Red Thread Café and IMusea – a community of 10,000 women who use Intentional Creativity as a tool for healing and exploration.

PS: Could you tell us a little bit more about the role you hope your art will play in the world. Do you really think it can help build bridges between divided communities?

LM: It is my hope that the image of a tree on the Earth in space will become a widespread symbol of peace and unity, not through force, but through imagination and through modeling nature. Each Singing Tree™ builds the “Beloved Community” one mural at a time. Having a common creative goal makes use of differences and can bring splintered and conflicted communities together. The achievement of a small goal helps people have hope that larger goals are possible. One high school student said: “Seeing that a bunch of us can work together in harmony and make a mural in such a short time gives me hope that we can turn around global warming.”

PS: When things feel challenging and seemingly insurmountable, what keeps you going?

LM: When things feel challenging, I go to art, which helps me get the pain out of my body so it won’t debilitate me, and I can learn from it. When I create, I get in touch with the Creator within me. Because Creator is Abundance, I see endless ideas and unforeseen possibilities. That fights depression. Art is empowering, because I can make a decision and take action with the paper, canvas, clay, paints or pencil. There is so much I can’t control about the cruel and needless suffering of humans and of other beings on our beautiful planet, but at least I can have power over what values I express in my art. I can point a big arrow to what I think is important, like children and trees. I can write out my gratitude, grace, grief and gusto.

I try to surround myself with people whom I feel safe with and who share my heart, my passion for justice, and my belief that creativity and community are unstoppable. I am constantly nurturing my soul and heart and mind with trainings, books, classes, films, projects and people dedicated to self-reflection, engaged scholarship, creating art, developing and recording meaningful stories, being in community, and learning from those who are dedicating their lives to a world that works for all. I nurture the “forest” of relationships I have developed over seven decades. I stay close to children, because they are close to Creator. I stay close to my grandchildren.

I also go outside. I go to Nature and feel the drama that is larger than human stories. I feel the connection to the wonder of soil, trees, oxygen, birds, bugs, bacteria, animals, water. I feel the ecosystem that supports me and all life, and I experience gratitude.

PS: Are there any final words you’d like to share with young folks who may be feeling overwhelmed with the challenges they are facing?

LM: We were born for this time. We belong to the time and place where we are. I am an elder now. You are a young person. Each of us has a unique gift to give to Life, to the Village, to the challenges of our time, to each other. I am here to partner with your genius in building the world we know is possible – an ecologically sane, multi-racial, multi-cultural democracy. Creativity and Community are unstoppable.

Fight against food apartheid requires creating spaces for Black food & farming to thrive

This article is part of Dreaming Out Loud, a media series written as part of the Bioneers Young Leaders Fellowship Program. To learn more, visit bioneers.org/dreaming-out-loud.


The sun sets over the raised garden beds and the arches of tunneled greenhouses that line the 80 acres of mountainside land. An array of fruits, vegetables, herbs and medicines stem from rich soils, their roots intermingling with wriggling earthworms that aerate the soil. Sheep roam freely in luscious, green pastures.    

Twenty-four miles northeast, on the outskirts of Albany, New York, Leah Penniman cultivates Soul Fire Farm with the intention of feeding her neighbors living under food apartheid – a system of segregation that intentionally divides folks with access to a nutritious food landscape and those who have been denied that access due to discriminatory policies and practices.

“There’s nothing that has the simple elegance and the enduring joy compared with tending the soil, planting the seed, pulling out food, feeding the community,” co-director and program manager of Soul Fire Farm Leah Penniman said. “Everyone needs to eat. Gotta get in that garden and grow that food. It feels good to be part of something so solid and clear and true for me.”

Soul Fire Farm is an Afro-Indigenous-centered community farm that seeks to dismantle anti-Black racism – the dehumanization and systemic marginalization of Black people – bolster Black sovereignty and uplift Black wisdom in the food system. Penniman and her farming crew have leaned on ancestral land wisdom to reclaim Black agency in land ownership, provide fresh and free foods to the community and train the next generation of Black farmers.  

Through numerous food sovereignty programs, Soul Fire Farm brings over 50,000 folks from diverse communities together each year to share resources and ancestral traditions and practices on natural building, spiritual activism, health and environmental justice and sustainable agriculture.   

“We saw, time and again, this liberatory experience that folks had doing, in some ways, the most mundane things — mixing compost, harvesting kale, cooking, growing flowers — but there was something really profound and healing about that,” Penniman said. “I think that having that resource base then makes possible the psycho-spiritual liberation.”

Healing circles are hosted at Soul Fire Farm where Black, femme folks gather to indulge in collective healing practices.

Penniman hopes to not only heal the souls of Black folks, but also the land that has been ravaged by capitalistic exploitation and the resultant impacts of climate change. Soul Fire Farm employs Afro-Indigenous agroforestry practices that are rooted in the long-term vitality of the land and its people to regenerate the land. 

Mounding and mulching soils like the Ovambo people, churning dark earth compost like the peoples of Ghana and seeding the land with an intermingling of dozens of native crops like those found in Nigeria, Soul Fire Farm farms and raises livestock in a culturally indulgent way that nourishes people, their communities and the land that divinely supports and sustains them.

“We’ve done our best to catch up to our ancestors and implement and innovate on these practices of things like semi-permanent raised beds, perennial polycultures, heavy mulching systems, crop rotation, cover cropping and green manures, planting on terraces,” Penniman said. “So many of these practices — like composting — that our ancestors used are incredible at pulling carbon out of the atmosphere and putting it back into the soil where it belongs.”

Many of the sustainable farming practices employed in Black food spaces today are based on Black regenerative agricultural techniques that have allowed Black folks to amplify biodiversity, draw down carbon into rich soils, conserve water and replenish waterways, reduce synthetic inputs into the Earth, provide economic stability for people in their communities and shift power in the food system back to our communities.

“We didn’t take away. We didn’t destroy, but we actually contributed,” Penniman said. “There’s something so unbelievably profound about that because human beings, in many cases, are sort of a blight on the Earth, just taking and taking and taking and stripping and mining and washing away. To see evidence in the soil core, this whole layer of our contribution, of our community, [is] super poetic and beautiful.” 

Soul Fire Farm seeks to end racism in the food system and reclaim an ancestral connection to land through growing food and community.

Black farmers have always been innovators and pioneers of organic and sustainable farming and community-supported agriculture. Their methods and systems ask us to think holistically about food, beyond the fetishization of a food system as a linear supply chain. Black food spaces and Black ways of living in opulent harmony with the land expose food as a system connected through myriad intimate relationships between people and land who grow with, exchange with and nurture with one another.

According to Penniman, Black relationships with the land are crucial to our literacy in the languages of the Earth. The way in which we knew it was time to plant corn by the size of the leaves on an oak tree. The way we knew the age of a tree based on wrapping our arms around the trunk. The way we were alerted of danger by the song of birds. We knew that if we listened to the needs, wants and desires of the Earth, that mother nature would reveal to us how to nourish the land and our people.   

“We used to all know which way was north just by looking at the stars, and what the weather was going to be tomorrow based on the color of the sunset,” Penniman said. “That literacy has slipped through our fingers, and until we can relearn to read and understand the languages of the Earth, we’re missing very important instructions for which way to go. 

“The Earth is deity, the Earth is grandmother, the Earth is kin, the Earth is teacher.”

A legacy of Black food and farming

Farming and tending to land are often mistaken as slave work. And while the trauma of almost 500 years of racialized violence and being shackled on plantations is poignant and visceral, it has also severed a sacred bond between Black folks and the land that has sustained our communities for countless generations. It has pitted the land as the oppressor.

“The land was the scene of the crime. It’s been almost 500 years of attempted genocide, dispossession, child slavery, of sharecropping, forced migration, and heir property, a lot of stuff,” Penniman said. “It makes sense to have this association with land as criminal, but of course land is not criminal, if anything, land is the source of sustenance and foundation.”

Although the U.S. has an egregious history of Black labor exploitation and Black land theft, Black food spaces have a long legacy in the global and national food systems. Food production has not always been an almost exclusively white endeavor in the United States, starting from the very moment African folks were forced into the bowels of slave ships.

African women boarded the ships of the Transatlantic slave trade with nothing but prayers to the ancestors, fear of the unknown in their hearts and seeds, intricately woven into the tresses of their braids. Stolen from their ancestral lands, they found ways to maintain Black food spaces on the shores of different, foreign soils. They stashed seeds of rice, okra, cotton, black-eyed peas, herbal medicines and so much more, as a means of survival of their people and the culture of their homeland. 

“Our ancestral grandmothers had the audacious courage to take the seed that they had saved for generations and to braid it into their hair as insurance for an uncertain future,” Penniman said. “We use [this] as an inspiring story for all that we do, thinking of ourselves as carrying on the legacy of the seed, and trying to have even a fraction of the courage and foresight that they had in the face of just unimaginable terror.”

These African women weaved hopes that their grandchildren would experience the same intimate connection to the Earth that had guided them with a wisdom only obtained through a relationship with the soil and the plants it can produce.

And it was for this connection to Earth, this knowledge of being in relation to land, that was a driving force in the theft of Black folks and the violent fields that stained the plantations of the antebellum South. Millions of farmers were kidnapped from their communities across Africa and shackled in chains to build the very foundations of this country. 

“Slavers weren’t just capturing random people,” Penniman said. “They were actually targeting skilled agriculturalists because it’s cold in Europe, and they didn’t know how to farm Brazil and Cuba and the Southeast of the United States. They didn’t know how to grow rice or sugar cane, and so they stole people who did.”

Although our relationship with land had become associated with the harsh and violent conditions faced on plantations, it was in those same fields that community, relationships and experiences were being built despite the shackles of anti-Black racism. Drawing on both African musical heritage and western European sources, enslaved Africans developed a rich tradition of singing spirituals while they worked the fields. These songs would set an atmosphere of melancholy and mourning while simultaneously resisting the constraints of chattel slavery that sought to strip Black folks of love, joy and prosperity. They embodied a critique of the treatment of Black folks and envisioned a liberatory future for their people.

After emancipation and the egregiousness of chattel slavery, anti-Black violence would find new forms of erasure and oppression through flagrant and heinous laws and institutions intended on suppressing the agency of Black folks. Southerners implemented the “Black codes,” which criminalized unemployment and loitering. Black communities were systemically pushed to the margins of society through separate but equal policing that stamped the Jim Crow Era. Black folks would be packed into prisons and rented back to plantations through mass incarceration. 

Those who evaded the prison industrial complex were often trapped in endless cycles of debt and disenfranchisement through sharecropping labor. 

Through the continued suppression of Black liberation, Black folks continued to desire to be culturally reconnected to the land, to grow culturally nutritious foods and own property as a means to build wealth and uplift their communities.

“When our ancestors at the end of chattel slavery in 1865 had a meeting to plan out what their desires were for reconstruction in Virginia, they said, ‘What we need are homes and the grounds beneath them so we can plant fruit trees and tell our children, these are yours.’ This yearning for secure land tenure has been number one since the beginning.” 

Leah Penniman

In 1881, Tuskegee Institute — now known as Tuskegee University — was developed by Lewis Adams, a former slave, in an effort to assist Black folks in this pursuit of racial advancement, economic liberation and self-determination. Positioned on the grounds of a vacant plantation, Tuskegee would become a Black food space. 

The institute was headed by Booker T. Washington, who believed that agricultural education and skills would provide a foundation for Black folks to survive in racially hostile and economically oppressive spaces. Washington modeled Tuskegee and its curriculum to foster collective community development and bolster Black agency in food spaces. Students learned how to craft bricks to construct buildings, nurture livestock on the plantation’s pastures and grow foods that would nourish their bodies and those of their communities.

Washington made sure that Tuskegee employed an all-Black faculty, bringing in rich agricultural knowledge like that of agricultural scientist and inventor George Washington Carver. Carver used human connection to land and careful nurturing of the ground to provide his students an education for their very survival. 

Over the years, Tuskegee would prove itself as a vehicle through which nature and the natural bounty of the land could be better heard and tended to through innovations such as Carver’s farming methods to prevent soil depletion, promotion of alternative crops to cotton that were soil-enhancing and protein-rich and development of hundreds of products using peanuts, sweet potatoes and soybeans.

In the 1960s, Black horticulturist and Tuskegee University professor, Booker T. Whatley, introduced the concept of community-supported agriculture (CSA) as a solution for struggling Black farmers. Today, CSAs provide farmers with capital to start the growing season.

Despite the failed promise of reparations in the form of 40 acres and a mule, by 1910, 16 million acres, or about 14% of all U.S. land, was owned by Black folks. 

“Despite the broken promise of 40 acres and a mule, where reparations were actually given to the former so-called slave owners but not to enslaved emancipated people themselves, like people saved up,” Penniman said. “Our ancestors saved their own money over generations to purchase these hard-scrabble like, two-to-three acre, five-acre lots in less desirable condition.”

This land was developed into Black food spaces — into farms that established Black agency in the American food system.

“I think when we have that direct contact in a safe and consensual way, there’s an opportunity for the earth to compost that trauma and give us back belonging,” Penniman said. “We’ve seen it so many times over and over again. I can’t imagine that anything else is happening there except that reunion that the earth is longing for.”

However, anti-Black racism ran deep regarding Black land ownership. Murder and lynchings by white supremacist groups like the Ku Klux Klan (KKK) and the white caps ravaged Black communities, killing over 4,000 Black landowners and destroying their farms and properties. 

Nationally, Black farmers have lost more than 12 million acres of farmland over the past century, according to a report from the Washington Post. A massive loss that is the product of biased government policies and discriminatory business practices.

Today, 95% of agricultural land in the U.S. is white-owned.

The shift in land ownership went beyond the fear and anger of white planters, as several factors have contributed to the decline of Black-owned farms. 

“We’ve seen time and again, the delays, the denial, the betrayals by the government,” Penniman said. “USDA programs, for example, have been a leading culprit in Black land loss because of delays and denial of lending, and also foreclosure on land that was used to collateralize loans that were given. So there’s a very sensical distrust of USDA programs which have failed us.”

U.S. federal programs utilized discriminatory policies to exlcude Black folks from land purchases and limited access to capital through the denial of farm loans, crop insurance and allotments. No legal protections existed to facilitate transfer of property to the next generation. Black farmers were routinely discouraged from registering to vote and joining the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP), otherwise running the risk of their grant and subsidy application being destroyed or denied. 

The long-documented racial discrimination of this USDA policing ultimately led to the largest civil rights class action lawsuit in U.S. history — the Pigford case of 1999. 

During the same time, a new Black food space was taking root in community and emerging through the gaps of the American food system. In 1966, Huey Newton and Bobby Seale established the Black Panther Party for Self Defense to address and decry police oppression of Black folks and the violence imposed on their community in Oakland, California. 

“We’re in many ways inspired by the work of the Black Panther Party, who had an unapologetic political platform but really saw the foundation of their work in their survival programs — that they’d be completely irrelevant if not addressing some of these foundational basic needs around medical care, transportation, food,” Penniman said.

Three years after its conception, the party began to build community self-determination by addressing the needs of their community around medical care, transportation and food. The Panters’ first and most successful community program was the Free Breakfast for Children Program. 

By 1968, most poor children attended school hungry, suppressing the pangs of hunger throughout the day. The national school lunch program offered reduced-price, but not free lunches for children living in poverty. Furthermore, the national school breakfast program was a limited program that hadn’t fully taken hold in most schools. 

The Breakfast Program quickly spread throughout the country and was hosted in 36 cities by 1971. The Panthers had fed more than 20,000 children by the end of the program’s first year. In a 1969 U.S. Senate hearing, it would be admitted that the Panthers fed more poor school children than did the State of California. 

The Black Panther Party focused national attention on several issues faced by the Black community, including the urgent need to provide poor children meals while they attend school. Their program put a spotlight on the limited scope of federal food programs and ultimately applied the pressure needed for Congress to authorize the expansion of what is now our modern-day food programs in public schools. 

“It should be around every turn that there are these liberated spaces where folks can have access to food, clean air, clean water, the dancing, the drumming, the ceremony, the natural resources that allow us to experience and tap into that feeling of freedom and liberation, which really is a birthright for all people.”

Leah Penniman

A history of food injustice in Black communities

The racialized violence that has continuously devastated Black communities is egregious and spurred by anti-Black racism and white fear of Black liberation. Anti-Black racism and land injustice have been profoundly dangerous in the ways they show up through our nation’s exploitative food system. It is anti-Black racism that has continuously disenfranchised Black communities from their relationships with the land and with food. 

In 1920, more than 925,000 Black farmers in the U.S. comprised about 14% of the farmer population. Today, fewer than 49,000 — slightly more than 1% — of farmers in the U.S. are Black. 

“There are trillions of dollars owed, there are many acres of land owed,” Penniman said. “These need to be given back.”

But farms today are overwhelmingly owned by white people, while approximately 85%  are tended to by people of color. Most of these farm workers aren’t provided adequate protections by basic labor laws, leaving them without paid time off, overtime pay or collective bargaining. 

“When folks come to this country to work, their life expectancy drops by over 10 years from what it would be in their counterparts,” Penniman said. “It’s an incredibly dangerous, deadly occupation — heat stroke, COVID exposure, sexual assault. The foundation of this country was to kidnap millions of our ancestors and bring them in the bowels of slave ships to be skilled, unpaid, forced laborers on the land. So we have not been able to divest ourselves from this idea that agriculture needs to rely on the exploitation of human beings and the exploitation of the land.”

This exploitation of Black farmers and the dispossession of Black land has resulted in a lack of access to healthy, affordable and culturally nutritious foods. The experiences of many Black communities today include food apartheid. 

According to the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA), 1 in 10 households in the U.S. is food insecure, lacking close access to foods that are culturally relevant and that meet their dietary needs. Black and Hispanic/Latinx adults experience food insecurity rates of 29.2% and 32.3%, respectively. In contrast, 17.3% of white adults experience food insecurity. 

The USDA uses the term “food desert” to describe the geographically linked disparities in food access, defining the phenomenon as a low-income census tract where a substantial portion of residents has minimal access to a grocery store or supermarket. 

Although about 23.5 million people live in food deserts — nearly half of which are poverty-afflicted and have a greater concentration of Black folks — this framework fails to address the dominant food system as a product of intentional policy decisions, such as redlining, that are the root causes of inadequate healthy and affordable food. 

Karen Washington has spent decades amplifying urban farming as a way to increase access to healthy, locally-grown food.

“You’re just using an outsider’s term of people who’ve never been in our neighborhood, and you’re not talking about the critical things we need to talk about around food,” said Karen Washington, Black food advocate and co-owner of Rise & Root Farm. “How it impacts people of color, where they live, how much money they have.”

Making these practices invisible prevents us from having conversations about food system agency and from mobilizing transformative solutions beyond attracting more grocery stores.

Although common, living in an area with minimal access to nourishing food does not necessarily mean that a person is food insecure. In fact, these areas are often flooded with food choices—just not ones that are healthy, affordable and culturally meaningful.

Without easy access to nourishing food, people — largely low-income and Black folks — are forced to turn to more convenient and affordable options, namely fast food. 

A study by the University of Connecticut’s Rudd Center for Food Policy and Obesity found that these barred communities are likely to have four unhealthy eating options for every one healthy option. These areas also suffer from higher rates of diet-related diseases, such as Type 2 diabetes and heart disease, which are the leading cause of death and disability today.

According to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services’ Office of Minority Health, Black people are 30% more likely to die from heart disease than whites, and twice as likely to die from diabetes.

“You’re told to eat healthy food but yet you don’t have healthy food options,” Washington said. “Then when you’re asked to eat healthy food, it’s expensive.”

These health inequities are the result of barred access that prevents Black folks from fully participating in the food landscape and a barbaric history of unjust policies and practices that have left neighborhoods without access to affordable homes, good jobs, well-funded schools and un-policed streets.

To fully understand access to culturally nutritious foods, we must look at all systems that create inequitable facets of society. Most people who experience food apartheid live in low-income communities. The reality is, food security is a social justice issue built on the foundation of the suppression of Black prosperity and leaves many communities engulfed by hunger and poverty.

Most of these poverty-afflicted areas are a product of disinvestment and unjust federal programs that led to segregation, not only in geography but also in economics. 

In the 1930s, while federal intervention and community investment helped expand homeownership and affordable housing for countless white families, it also segregated the country and undermined wealth-building in Black communities. This state-sponsored system of segregation — this institutionalized anti-Black racism — pushed Black folks out of the new suburban homes and instead into urban housing projects and areas of immense disinvestment.

Redlining – segregating communities through racially discriminatory real estate tactics – was used as a tool to deny Black folks mortgage insurance, mortgage refinancing and federal underwriting opportunities. Entire Black communities were classified as financially risky and a threat to local property values.

This process of redlining not only barred Black folks from home ownership, but it forced communities into economic decline and the perils of community disinvestment. What is left today is millions of Black communities that lack access to basic resources like healthcare, banking, job opportunities, public transportation and culturally nutritious foods to put on the table. 

Rise & Root Farm is a five-acre farm in New York, and is run cooperatively by four owners who are women, intergenerational, multi-racial and LGBTQIA+.

“If you are hungry, your body, there is this instinct of survival. And so you would let go of the rent so that you can buy food,” Washington said. “And yet you need the rent because you need shelter. And so you can’t talk about one without the other. So you’re asking people to eat healthy, but if they don’t have a roof over their head, if they don’t have living-wage jobs, all of those impact the ability of people to purchase ‘healthy’ food.”

At its core, the term “food apartheid” is a way for us to visualize the manifestations of structural oppression and systemic, anti-Black racism that are inextricably linked to the food system. This framework puts clearly into focus the deliberate violence, policy choices and chronic community disinvestment that have resulted in racial inequities in access to healthy and affordable food. 

“I’m trying to use a term that strips away that sort of artificial, sanitized word and starts getting people to say, ‘Wait a second, we need to look closer at this food system that’s racially charged, that really has impacted so many people of color,’” Washington said. 

Furthermore, “food apartheid” identifies white supremacy as the foundational catalyst in the policymaking process and calls attention to the aftermath of decades of systemic racism that led to the erasure of community sovereignty by means of segregation and the deniability of social and economic mobility. 

“When people say the food system is broken and needs to be fixed, and I say no, no, no, it’s doing exactly what it’s supposed to be doing,” Washington said. “It is a shift, and that needs to be the power in the hands of the community. The communities have to come together and start to understand and own their power.”

Washington believes that change is going to come — that Black and brown communities will once again find themselves in the position to feed their communities, be self-sufficient and self-reliant and to take care of our own.

“You cannot continue to put people down, that they have no food to eat, no clothes on their back, no roof over their head. You cannot continue to do that because the masses are going to come together, and they are going to uprise.”

Karen Washington

For Black farmers across the country, an uprising has already begun. Black folks are again turning to their ancestral farming practices to reclaim and mobilize Black food spaces — settings and experiences created in Black solidarity and in opposition to the dominant food system — in an effort to uproot food apartheid in their communities. 

Black food is an act of resistance

A ray of sunlight cascades over the raised beds of Black Joy Farm. Its light intimately weaves through rows of broccoli, eggplants, tomatoes and corn — its warmth gently embracing every fruit and vegetable it touches. Its shimmer illuminates the rich reds, greens, purples and yellows of the plants that find root in the dark soil humus. 

The sweet and sour aroma of a red bell pepper envelopes the crisp morning air. The cluck of hens erases any other noise throughout the 5400 square foot, urban farm. 

Justin Mashia co-founded Bronx Sole, a running group, to address poor health in his neighborhood.

“You can be in that space and not even know you’re in the city, especially when you’re around the chickens and they’re making so much noise,” said Justin Mashia, manager of Black Joy Farm. “They kind of drown out all of the city noise. It’s a beautiful thing.” 

Nestled behind a shopping center in the Longwood neighborhood in the Bronx, Mashia works with others at the Black Feminist Project to tend the land, sow the seeds and reap the crops of Black Joy Farm. Much of the fresh produce, herbs, eggs and other foods grown at the farm are provided to families across the Bronx at low to no cost. Over the seven years that Black Joy Farm has been in operation, hundreds of pounds of fresh food has been given away to Black and brown folks residing in the poorest congressional district in the nation.

“I can’t help everyone at the same time, but we can do our part,” Mashia said. “Just imagine if we had more of these spaces and how we could truly feed the community. We need the access to the land, because if we have access to land, we have access to food, and access to food is how we can build, in ways, wealth in our communities.” 

The effects of food apartheid are felt throughout the borough. Despite a rich history of community organizing and advocacy, large disparities continue to bar communities from equitable access to food. Although it houses the world’s largest food distribution center, The Bronx has ranked last in all of New York State’s 62 counties in health outcomes since 2009. 

“Food justice is so important because we’re disconnected,” Mashia said. “Being Black in America, all we know is fast food. We know fast foods, but most of us don’t know growing food.”

Black food spaces such as Black Joy Farm provide nourishment to communities who have continually been involuntarily deemed undeserving of foods that holistically tend to and nurture our entire being — foods that connect us to community and root us in the Earth. Black folks need, deserve and are owed spaces in which we can relish in our ancestral ways of knowing and tending to the land and surround ourselves with the beauty of fresh, ripe foods to eat. 

Black food spaces have the power to liberate us from hunger and the power to heal our minds and souls as we work to reclaim the very intimate parts of ourselves that have consistently and violently been stolen from us. When we are able to regain our divine connection to the land, we are also able to find sanctuary from the abuses of anti-Black racism and patterns of white dominance.

Students get to plant greens of their own during the summer youth programs at Black Joy Farm.

“Sometimes I have a blanket and just lay out there, just put my hands out and just lay and look at the sky, and just watch the clouds go by,” Mashia said. “It’s a healing space more than just a community farm. It’s an oasis from the harsh and crazy city life that we live.”

In a society where the police conceive of themselves as soldiers at war with communities, where politicians blatantly craft oppressive and dehumanizing policies and where Black folks are still hunted for the fear of their liberation — fear of their very existence — spaces must exist for Black folks to catch a breath. It is for our survival that we carve our spaces for ourselves where we may find rest, peace and a reprieve from the violence and oppression of anti-Black racism.

“Our space is a safe space for anyone in the community,” Mashia said. “You don’t have to come in there to grow something or want to learn about anything agriculturally. You can just come in there. Some women just come in there and they just want to sit in the space and read a book.”

According to Mashia, it can be easy to forget that the kids that attend the Black Joy Farm summer programs are dealing with so much more than the food injustice that plagues the Bronx. While Black Joy Farm relishes in the beautiful depths of Blackness, the environment outside is harsh. 

“They’re dealing with domestic issues, drugs and alcohol, and all these crazy things — gangs and things like that,” Mashia said. “Being able to come here, they’re using the space to release and feel like they can be themselves and let their guard down, and they’re in a happy environment.”

Black farmers like Mashia are returning to their agricultural roots with the intention of feeding and healing their people who have always been systemically denied access to healthy, affordable and culturally meaningful food and spaces to exist unencumbered by the white gaze.

“That’s what we’re always fighting for: access to these spaces,” Mashia said. “If we had these spaces, just imagine what we could do.”

Black reproductive justice: Black birthing spaces and support could be the key to maternal health

This article is part of Dreaming Out Loud, a media series written as part of the Bioneers Young Leaders Fellowship Program. To learn more, visit bioneers.org/dreaming-out-loud.


Shaquyla Baker didn’t expect to have a cesarean birth. At the age of 19, she hadn’t planned to become pregnant at all. She was nervous, but she was also excited to become a mother.

During her second trimester, Baker began experiencing daily excruciating headaches, but she dismissed them at first. Between her cravings for salty pickles, a contentious relationship with her boyfriend and the general anxiety of pregnancy, she assumed a poor diet and stress were to blame for her headaches. 

“I was definitely feeling in my prime, and really wasn’t too focused on medical issues,” Baker said. “I was just having a baby at [a young] age.”

Baker’s son, Marlon, Jr., was born on October 3, 2022.

Soon after the headaches began, Baker began having fits of dizziness and imbalance, unable to move. Her mother pleaded with her to see a doctor, and after several clinical tests, Baker discovered she had preeclampsia — a dangerous pregnancy complication characterized by high blood pressure that can result in death. 

Baker’s OBGYN, who was also a Black woman, was responsive to her condition and able to coach Baker through her pregnancy to lessen her symptoms and ensure a healthy pregnancy for her and her baby. 

“It’s very beneficial when you have a doctor that knows a lot about your race; she knows the circumstances and things that can go on just within the culture of your body, things that could happen,” Baker said. “When you have someone who knows your culture and knows things that we as Black women go through, it makes me feel a little better.”

While Baker had originally wanted to deliver her baby girl naturally, the risk of complications from her preeclampsia caused her and her doctor to settle on a cesarean-section. Baker’s daughter, Dakota, was a healthy baby girl, and still today, Baker thanks God for her Black doctor and the wellbeing of her and her daughter. 

As a Black woman whose serious health condition was not overlooked by her healthcare provider, Baker’s story is somewhat unusual. According to recent statistics regarding maternal health, it could be the reason why she and Dakota are alive today. 

Black birthing parents are dying at an alarming rate

In the United States, Black women and birthing people are consistently at the mercy of a system of care dominated by white, male medical practitioners and wrought with sinister and life-threatening failures. The result is a public health crisis plaguing the lives of Black birthing people, who suffer staggeringly worse maternal health outcomes. 

Hospitals in the U.S. that serve Black communities — where 75% of U.S. Black women give birth — have been found to provide lower-quality maternal care and have higher rates of maternal complications in their patients. Moreover, when surveyed, both Black and Hispanic women reported receiving poor treatment from hospital staff because of race, ethnicity, cultural background or language.

The U.S. spends more on healthcare than any other developed nation, yet it ranks second to last in healthcare coverage and records the highest maternal mortality rate. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), more than 800 new and expectant mothers died in the U.S. in 2020, with 1 in 3 pregnancy-related deaths occurring due to life-threatening postpartum complications 1 week to 1 year after giving birth. More than 80% of those deaths were preventable, and a disproportionate number of the birthing parents suffering were Black.

Non-Hispanic Black women in the U.S. are 2 to 3 times more likely to die from pregnancy-related causes than non-Hispanic white women. For Black women over the age of 30, this figure increases to 4 to 5 times more likely than white women. 

“This is intentional. By no accident are people who are the descendants of stolen people, on stolen land, having the most severe outcomes. This is the outcome of 400 years of chattel slavery, of trauma passed down, and untreated trauma for 400 years of slavery. We live in a society [in which just] because Black people have access to a hospital doesn’t mean that there’s equity or equality.”

Angel Walton, Austin, Texas-based birth companion

Most research that seeks to explain this disparity in maternal health outcomes focuses on a Black birthing person’s exposure to risk factors during pregnancy, including poverty and low socioeconomic status. However, the same disparity holds true across education levels and socioeconomic statuses. One could easily suggest that in the United States, nothing — not wealth, education or status — is enough to prevent Black birthing people from dying during and after pregnancy.  

“It is literally being a Black person — a Black woman — in this world that has fatal outcomes,” Walton said.

Chronic stress is worsening Black birth outcomes

To fully understand these maternal health disparities, we must be willing to acknowledge the deeply entrenched anti-Black racism in our society that continues to violently devalue and dehumanize the health of Black folks as well as the exposure to stress that comes with being systemically marginalized in this country. 

Given the United States’ climate of racial inequity, Black birthing people are far more likely to be chronically exposed to stress. As a result, they produce about 15% more of the stress hormone cortisol than white women, according to the National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute. High cortisol levels raise the risk of pregnancy complications — including conditions such as hypertension and preeclampsia — that can result in preterm births and low birth weights in infants. Preeclampsia is 60% more common in Black birthing people than white birthing people.

These conditions are far more common in U.S.-born Black women than their African-born counterparts. 

“We are in the belly of the beast, and Black women who have had babies outside of the United States have high maternal and fetal outcomes. When they come to the United States, their [health outcomes] decline and become the same statistic as Black women in the United States. So there’s something about giving birth in this country that poses a severe risk for Black birthing bodies when they’re having babies. It’s because we live in a white man’s world, and the exact opposite of that is something that is female and something that is Black.”

Angel Walton

Black women in the U.S. have yet to experience a reality in which their quality of care fosters better birth outcomes.

Dakota and her newborn brother, Marlon, Jr.

“There’s never been a moment in which Black women are having equal birth outcomes to our white counterparts because we’ve always been put under excessive stress, we’ve always had lower access to nutrition, and lower access to prenatal care or whatever the case may be,” said Niria White, Interim Birth and Postpartum Director for Mama Sana Vibrant Woman – a non-profit organization providing culturally resonant and quality prenatal and postnatal care to people of color in Travis County, Texas. “There’s never been a moment where we’ve had everything we need for a majority of us to have positive birth experiences.”

While the solution to ending these maternal health disparities for Black birthing people is a dismantling of the racist medical institution, Black birthing people like Shaquyla Baker are turning to Black birthing spaces — maternal care settings and experiences that provide a refuge from the daily violences of anti-Black racism in the healthcare system — and ancestral birthing practices to make their pregnancy and birthing experiences safer and healthier.

When Baker became pregnant with her second child, Marlon Jr., she worried about the potential of a pregnancy with similar or worse complications than those she experienced when she was 19. She was more mature now, more health conscious and in a loving relationship, but with family unable to attend her son’s birth, her pregnancy had become a lonely experience. 

“I definitely wanted somebody to be there that’s in our corner, to emotionally support us during the experience,” Baker said. “That’s really why I wanted to go the doula route. I didn’t have my mom, but I did want somebody who could kind of take her place during that experience in the hospital.”

Black maternal health necessitates Black spaces

Doulas — often referred to as “birth workers” or “companions” due to the term’s association with slavery — have always been a part of many communities of color, taking up a role that allows them to support and advocate for a birthing parent at their most vulnerable. Birth workers are non-clinical health professionals who provide emotional, physical, and educational support for birthing people and families during and after pregnancy and birth. 

“[Having a doula] made a complete difference,” Baker said. “It made situations a lot smoother just talking to somebody outside of family, outside of friends, somebody who actually just wants to help you, not because they have to, they just want to help you. It was definitely an experience I think I needed.”

It is undeniable that Black birthing people need their own spaces to be afforded maternal experiences that are self-determining, healthy and that holistically tend to the wellness of the birthing parent and their family. Birth workers offer this much-needed space, providing a buffer between Black folks and the anti-Black racism that has infested the traditionally white-centered healthcare system. 

“I definitely felt 10 feet tall going to every appointment knowing I was important, knowing this is my baby,” Baker said. “It felt great.”

When they are involved in a birthing experience, doulas are associated with improved maternal health outcomes for Black birthing parents and their babies.

A 2021 study of Medicaid beneficiaries receiving birth-work support revealed lower rates of cesarean and preterm births when compared with other pregnant individuals enrolled in the program. Furthermore, birthing persons in communities that are most vulnerable to adverse maternal health outcomes were two times less likely to experience a birth complication, four times less likely to have a low-birth-weight baby, were more likely to breastfeed and were more likely to be satisfied with their care.

Birth work and birthing companionship has also been linked to reduced rates of postpartum depression and anxiety, and increased positive feelings about birthing experiences and the ability to influence one’s own pregnancy outcomes. 

“It’s just somebody to care for you, especially in this country or just generally, Black women are not privileged to have someone caring for them. Birth work is a way that we can show up and care for each other in deeply intimate ways. Watching each other care for each other, and love on each other in a world that doesn’t love on us is so bright and healing. It’s like it feels like sunshine in the most corny way.”

Niria White

Before her pregnancies, Baker had always assumed doula care was for the bourgeois. Doula care and support is often seen as a luxury reserved for wealthier white women, stemming from the hefty price tag that accompanies many doula services on top of the already overwhelming expense of pregnancy and childbirth. 

However, organizations such as Mama Sana Vibrant Woman (MSVW) and Giving Austin Labor Support (GALS) are leading in providing access to culturally responsive prenatal, birth and postpartum care for communities that have been systemically barred from their ancestral birthing spaces. These organizations provide Black and brown birthing parents and their families with access to pregnancy and birthing care, community resources and healing practices at no cost. They offer spaces to receive culturally responsive care and to build community through educational classes, support circles and in-home childcare aid. GALS has even worked in partnership with the local county sheriff’s office to offer doula support and educational programming to pregnant and postpartum incarcerated individuals. 

These types of community-based doula programs build on the strong relationship doulas establish with mothers throughout pregnancy, birth and the postpartum period to promote ongoing care and support.

It was through the GALS doula program that Baker was able to find the support she was longing for, with her new doula, Angel Walton. 

“Angel, she was so touching. She was so concerned about my feelings,” Baker said. “Just the experience of Angel being my doula — I can’t just say she was my doula, she was my family’s doula.”

Birth work and the ancestral embodiment of holding Black space 

Tall cypress trees line the riverbank. Their green, yellow and red leaves sway in the breeze,  reflected in the clear water below. It’s not unusual to see steam rise from the surface of the San Marcos River on a brisk morning, or to catch swimmers weaving their way through Texas Wild Rice that is rooted in the riverbed.

Angel Walton, 38, has been a birth companion in the Austin, Texas area for six years.

The San Marcos River in San Marcos, Texas holds sacred water; the springs that feed the river are a spiritual site for Indigenous Peoples and a guide for sacred pilgrimages. For Angel Walton, the river provides a conduit for connection with her ancestors and her gods, who she calls to and often prays to, before each birth she attends. 

When called on to assist in the birth of a client, Walton lights a candle on her ancestral altar welcoming the new soul, and she heads to the river.

“I’m usually called to the water,” Walton said. “Babies are living in water, and they’re transitioning. I think all water is connected. I end up being at the river just calming my spirit and washing away what needs to be washed away so that I can be clear, clean and present for that person and that baby and that family, in particular, for the ceremony of birth.”

Just as she is drawn to the river, Walton feels called by her ancestors to be a doula and create Black birthing spaces in which Black birthing people are able to dream up a pregnancy and birthing experience that tends to the mind, body and spirit — an experience that is difficult to achieve in an otherwise anti-Black, racist society.

Walton describes her work as a birthing companion as energy work and work that embodies her ancestral practices of connection and creating genuine relationships that are nurturing and based in community. To Walton, creating and holding Black birthing spaces is a focal point in her work as a doula and is critical in saving the lives of Black women and birthing people.

“Doulas, particularly the way that I’ve learned to doula, hold that space and ensure that when a pregnant person comes up with a birth plan that is their idea, their dream of how they want to give birth, how they want this birthing experience to feel — I’m there to make sure that those things are happening. Holding that space as a whole human being for this person who is bringing in another whole human being, of course it saves lives. Our bodies — in this country, on this stolen land and as stolen folks, as descendants of stolen people — we were never intended to be looked at as whole human beings. To be chosen to be a facilitator and space holder in this sacred ceremony is an honor.”

Angel Walton

These spaces are particularly profound for births that happen inside of a hospital, Walton said.

“Human beings, mammals, go into places where it’s dark, they go into a place where they feel safe [during birth],” Walton said. “They go into a place that feels so quiet and relaxing, and hospitals are pretty much the opposite of that, especially for Black and brown bodies.”

An ancestral history of community-based support

Doula practices existed for centuries prior to the earliest recorded practices in the U.S., with a history and legacy deeply rooted in African ancestry.  

When a birthing parent in West Africa gives birth, they are surrounded by community and embraced by the love of female relatives, who build altars to protect the spirit of new life and create drumming circles to commemorate the new arrival. The sacred ceremony of birth is attended by a midwife — a health professional who cares for mothers and their newborns during childbirth — and a doula, who supports the birthing parent through their experience of labor and childbirth. 

African birthing parents continue to be cared for by midwives and doulas.

“Birth was a community event as much as it was private and sacred and secret,” Niria White, the Interim Birth and Postpartum Director for Mama Sana Vibrant Woman, said. “It was a secret thing that happened, but for women, particularly women who had given birth, this was a moment to come together and care for each other.”

African midwives and doulas were more than just baby catchers, traditionally performing roles as spiritual healers, nutritionists, breastfeeding consultants, postpartum doulas, family planning counselors and advocates who provided resources, care and Black birthing spaces for their birthing communities. 

“When you move away from the medical way of understanding birth and lean more into the natural, the holistic, the physiological — the body’s response to birth — that’s what our ancestors did. They focused on that,” White said. “How was your mind, your body and your spirit moving throughout this portal of birth?” 

Experienced midwives and doulas were among the many enslaved persons who survived the middle passage of the Trans-Atlantic slave trade. They were exploited as medical practitioners who could ensure the health of reproducing enslaved women and their newborn babies to expand their labor force, and to care for the pregnant and birthing wives of African slave owners. It’s from these African traditions, born out of African ritual, that the roots of African American midwifery and doulaship in the U.S. grew. 

Black midwives and their accompanying doulas were crucial figures in their communities, particularly among enslaved persons. By the mid-to-late 1600s in the U.S., while these birth workers were still subjected to the brutality of slavery, Black midwives, doulas and their birthing traditions became the primary sources of prenatal, birth and postpartum care for all birthing people in the country and were instrumental in the preservation of Black maternal and infant health.

According to a 2003 study published by the American College of Nurse-Midwives, between the 1600s and early 1900s, nearly half of all babies born in the U.S. were born into the hands of midwives and the birthing companions that studied under them. 

Even after Emancipation, Black midwives, affectionately known as “granny midwives,” continued their vital, sacred and ancestral work with both Black and white birthing people in the U.S. South, particularly in rural communities, where access to maternal care and resources for birthing people were minimal. Granny midwives traveled throughout the South, ensuring that Black birthing spaces were available to Black families regardless of their geographic location or ability to pay, mitigating the disparities experienced by Black birthing parents in the health care system.

Despite the racist institutions of slavery, Reconstruction and Jim Crow, granny midwives and doulas held onto and passed down African birthing traditions that included rituals and herbal remedies and served as connectors to the spiritual and cultural legacies of African birthing practices, birthing Black babies during life in a Diaspora. 

Racism has erased Black birth work in the U.S.

The practices of midwifery and doulaship create Black birthing spaces that challenge the racialization and overmedicalization of birth with an emphasis on community-based care, intimate relationship building, prenatal and postpartum wellness and avoiding unnecessary interventions that can, and often do, spiral into dangerous birthing complications. 

Yet today in the U.S., only 6% of midwives are Black and 16% of doulas are women of color. 

These statistics are largely due to racist beliefs that eroded the cultural practices of doulaship and midwifery in Black communities. By the early 20th century, a reformation campaign was launched by physicians, nurses and public health departments to shift control of birth from community-based and traditionally trained Black women to the power of the white and male-dominated medical profession. 

“We’re getting eradicated because of these changes in the healthcare system, and it just happens so fast,” White said. “I think in the span of 20 years, like 30 to 50% of midwives who are primarily birthing in the South were eradicated, are just non-existent.”

Medical and health professionals began spreading false and racist claims that Black midwives and birthing companions were at fault for the high maternal mortality rate due to a lack of education, skill and cleanliness, demoting the traditional practices to barbarism and superstition. 

“Trying to reduce maternal mortality in the context that they were was a matter of control: wanting to control women’s bodies, wanting to control how labor was being created. It’s never been about women. It’s never been about our health. It’s never been about our body. It’s been about control. They just don’t care enough or even think we deserve the beauty and sacredness of birth.”

Niria White

The annihilation of ancestral birthing practices was further accelerated by the signing of the Sheppard-Towner Act of 1921 into law. The Act created regulatory barriers for education and licensure that effectively outlawed out-of-hospital birthing practices and workers without institutionalized training. This law was accompanied by a push from the American Medical Association in 1948 to standardize medicine and eliminate out-of-hospital healers.

According to the Journal of Midwifery and Women’s Health, physicians made up the vast majority of primary care providers by the 1940s, and home births were essentially replaced by hospital births. The move to hospital births accompanied a reliance on intervention methods such as cesarean deliveries, artificially rupturing membranes and epidurals, which may not have been medically necessary in low-risk pregnancies.

“It was never about actually prioritizing women’s health, women’s bodies, maternal health or anything like that,” White said. “White women have always had better birth outcomes than we have, but their birth experiences aren’t necessarily better. They weren’t necessarily having beautiful, magical births in the early 20th century. They were being drugged and put to sleep in weird, violent ways. Weird things are still happening, it’s just that Black women are getting the worst of this already weird world.”

Racism continues to harm Black birthing bodies

The U.S. has a long history of the erasure and theft of ancestral practices that have proven to save Black lives. With anti-Black racism being intimately intertwined in the foundation of gynecology, the profession itself was built on non-consensual medical experimentation and the exploitation of enslaved Black women. 

In the 1840s, James Marion Sims, a white gynecologist in Montgomery, Alabama, performed excruciatingly painful experiments without anesthesia on enslaved Black women, often while other doctors observed. While he eventually achieved the title of “Father of Gynecology,” he did so only through this life-threatening experimentation.

Many of Sims’ experiments were unsuccessful, but he continued to perform procedures on enslaved Black women from 1845 to 1849, needing only the permission of the enslaved women’s “owners.” Often drugged and unable to refuse treatment, Sims’ patients were powerless to protect themselves from the racist medical exploitation that he performed.

“They wanted to create a system to ensure that white people were going to have their babies and be healthy. Black people were just the tester, the sample. We’ve always been products for them. If we’re going to put [childbirth] in the hands of men, it was never going to be the beauty of when it was just women in that space.”

Niria White

It’s evident that current medicine was built on the backs of Black women and birthing people — a practice that has altered how doctors and medical professionals have treated Black patients throughout the course of U.S. history. 

The 19th century saw the emergence of eugenics: the inherently racist and ableist ideology that labeled certain people, particularly Black people, unfit to have children due to possessing “undesirable” traits. The idea behind eugenics was that the human race could be bettered through selectively breeding people with specific traits thought to be genetic, like intelligence, work ethic and cleanliness. 

This belief became widely popular with upper-class white Americans who sought to control the populations of people deemed inferior and with undesirable traits — immigrants, people of color, poor people, unmarried mothers, the disabled, the mentally ill. Numerous powerful actors chose to adopt eugenics, including Theodore Roosevelt, Andrew Carnegie and, most notably, Margaret Sanger — the founder of Planned Parenthood. 

Sanger is renowned for founding the American birth control movement. She spoke at numerous eugenics conferences, including the women’s auxiliary of the Ku Klux Klan, to generate support for the use of birth control. When she spoke, she often referred to birth control being used to facilitate a process of weeding out those unfit to bear children and to prevent birth defects.  

Though it is claimed that Sanger eventually distanced herself from eugenics, she endorsed the Supreme Court’s 1927 decision in Buck v. Bell, which allowed states to sterilize people considered mentally “unfit” without their consent and sometimes without their knowledge — a ruling that would take eugenics to its horrifying extreme with the forced sterilization of tens of thousands of people of color in the 20th century.

California had the nation’s largest forced sterilization program, sterilizing about 20,000 people beginning in 1909. More recently, California prisons were exposed for falsely diagnosing incarcerated women with cervical cancer and coercing the women to remove their reproductive organs — with doctors sometimes performing non-consensual hysterectomies after they gave birth. The Center for Investigative Reporting also found that the state paid doctors nearly $150,000 to perform tubal ligations on almost 150 women, a procedure the women say was done under coercion.

Between 1997 and 2014, nearly 1,500 women were forcibly sterilized in California prisons, most of them Black.  

“What we’re seeing now is a reflection of how we’ve always been treated, and I think we’re just now able to see the data,” White said.

Black futures require Black birthing spaces

Black women’s bodily autonomy and health have been consistently attacked throughout the course of U.S. history. This violence has only been exacerbated by the recent U.S. Supreme Court decision to overturn Roe v. Wade, which further complicates pregnancy and childbirth by denying millions of birthing bodies their constitutional right to abortion and abortion care. 

According to a 2021 study conducted by University of Colorado sociologist Amanda Stevenson, banning abortion nationwide will lead to a 21% increase in pregnancy-related deaths for all birthing people and a 33% increase for Black birthing people specifically. 

At the state level, research has concluded that the most restrictive abortion laws tend to be associated with the poorest maternal health outcomes. A recent study published in the journal of American Public Health Association revealed that states with higher abortion restrictions had a 7% increase in total maternal mortality rates. 

“They want people to be having children so that we have a working class,” White said. “Eradicating abortion is a way to reduce the amount of agency for women, and to have more babies.” 

It is imperative that Black birthing people have access to birthing spaces in which they are valued and humanized while they endure one of the most vulnerable — and sacred — experiences of their lives. Community-based care, like birthing work, is key. However, according to White, more birth workers alone won’t bring the U.S. out of the depths of the Black maternal mortality crisis.  

And, birth workers can’t be expected to singlehandedly mitigate the anti-Black racism deeply embedded within the medical landscape. The healthcare system is responsible for the deaths of hundreds of Black mothers every year, and the creators and enforcers behind that same deadly system should be held accountable for their role in the current state of maternal health outcomes. 

Today, the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists agrees that reproductive justice — agency over one’s body and access to quality care — and equitable maternal health outcomes cannot be achieved without addressing racial bias in the medical field. 

“We should start there, bringing it back to listening to the individual, listening to our bodies, and we should stop trying to navigate the medical world as a Band-aid and really focus on real healing. Then we would actually be able to find some reproductive justice,” White said. “That would be so nice.”

Real, lasting change will require us to examine every part of our societal processes that are steeped in anti-Black racism — that are permeated with racial violence — and to deconstruct our sexist and dehumanizing understandings of Black women’s bodies. In doing so, we can ensure there is a focus on providing Black birthing people with greater access to healthy foods, quality mental health care, a balance of home and work environments, spaces to care for ourselves and others and quality maternal care that is conducive to safe and healthy pregnancies. 

“I have faith that we can get back to a place where at least we’ll be able to create pockets of safety for women to be able to have this beautiful experience, at least a little bit stress-free, just for that moment of time,” White said. 

How Black Creative Spaces Can Be Havens for Resistance

This article is part of Dreaming Out Loud, a media series written as part of the Bioneers Young Leaders Fellowship Program. To learn more, visit bioneers.org/dreaming-out-loud.


Art has always been a pillar of the life and culture of Blackness in America. From hiding Yoruba religious symbols in Christian iconography to singing of a liberated future in the so-called “negro-spirituals,” Black folks have used creativity to carve spaces that are gentle, loving and humanizing against the backdrop of a society that does not love on them. Black creativity has been a way for Black minds and bodies to heal from a seemingly never-ending struggle for freedom.  

Born from a unified struggle, the art and creativity of Black folks has shaped and shifted American culture. It has called out the ills of a country that continues to marginalize its people. It has sparked movements for Black joy. It has shown us how to change the world into one that allows Black bodies to rest instead of fight. 

Creating spaces where Black creativity and Black art are allowed to flourish can be daunting, but it is a key act of resistance. These Black creative spaces are settings and experiences that embody Black expressions and imaginations. They offer Black folks support to dream their wildest dreams out loud, unencumbered by the white gaze. They allow both artists and the beholder to relish in the rich depths of their Blackness.

This “Black Creativity” collection will explore transformative figures in Black art and creative culture. The following creatives know what it’s like to challenge the status quo, dream up possibility and tell the stories of the beauty of their Blackness.


Ebby, Chibi Magical Girl and Chrissy, Chrissy Plays Dressup

Ebby enjoys putting her art on display at cosplay competitions. She won first place at the 2022 Savannah Comic Convention as Princess Sailor Moon from the live-action series “Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon.” Photo: @ThePicWitch

Ebby has always loved anime. “Tokyo Mew Mew,” “Winx Club” and “Princess Tutu” were just some of the series that frequented her television set when she was younger. It was the magical girl animes — anime centering concepts of girls coming of age and possessing power through their femininity – that she loved the most. These were characters that brought her so much joy. 

Ebby was swept away to the furthest reaches of her imagination when in the midst of magical girls. Anthy Himemiya from the “Revolutionary Girl Utena” series was particularly inspirational for Ebby. She was a woman of color. 

“I never saw people of color, dark-skinned characters, that were magical girls or a Shōjo at that time,” Ebby said. “That was like, wow. I told myself, eventually when I get better at sewing, let me actually make this particular character.”

Countless hours and yards of fabric later, Ebby had completed her first cosplay – a costume resembling the red gown and short purple bob worn by Anthy. And, over 13 years later, Ebby – known to fans as Chibi Magical Girl – still indulges in the depths of her creativeness, dressing up as the magical girls that continue to bring her joy.

Ebby’s art has taken her far and wide. She’s donned stubbed, white horns and a beaded white wig while transporting herself to the realm of “Miss Kobayashi’s Dragon Maid” as the magical girl Kanna Kamui. She’s metamorphosed into Madoka Kaname from “Puella Magi Madoka Magica,” complete with a bow and arrow. She’s even been seen dressed as a Black fae, adorned with pointed ears. 

For Ebby, cosplay has been an opportunity to break out of her shell and to learn new skills as she builds her craftsmanship. She has learned to visualize, prep fabrics and stitch together her own garments. She taught herself how to tease and style wigs and to apply makeup. 

“When you start to actually see every little bit, those parts of the cosplay come together, you’re like, wow, I actually did this!” Ebby said. “This looks pretty good! It’s actually becoming something from nothing!”

Cosplay, a term derived from the words “costume” and “play,” is a common art form in fandom communities in which folks dress as their favorite characters from anime series, TV shows, comics or video games. Many cosplayers like Ebby make their own cosplays, spending countless hours sewing clothes, sculpting foam armor and weapons and styling wigs – oftentimes spending hundreds of dollars on a single cosplay. Some cosplayers will go as far as to mimic the mannerisms and personalities of the characters they impersonate.

Cosplay is also a staple at many fandom gatherings, such as anime and comic conventions – providing a space for cosplayer art to be on full display. Not long ago, engaging in geek culture was considered uncool in popular culture. Today, tens of thousands of cosplayers attend conventions every year, across the nation. 

The beauty of cosplay is that it is an art form that allows fans to dream out loud by embodying characters they resonate with and who bring them joy. It offers them an escape from reality. The craft itself is a combination of ingenuity and fandom passion that opens portals to new and magical worlds. Cosplay has become an outlet for geeky folks – a medium through which folks are afforded the creative space to openly express themselves and display their unconventional art. It’s an exciting world, and for many, a personally fulfilling one. But for Black folks, namely Black femme-presenting folks, it can also serve as a reminder that we are seen as outsiders.

“You just come to cosplay; you just come to dress up as a character, or you come to socialize with people who share the same interests as you,” Ebby said. “You come to bring more people in and share your stories, but for a lot of people, they’re not in the cosplay community long enough for their story to be heard because of all the negativity.”

There is a dangerous misconception in the cosplay community that seeks to exile Black folks from fully participating in the depths of their art forms. While white folks have always been free to emulate characters from various cultural backgrounds, at times even donning blackface,  Black cosplayers have continuously been persecuted for dressing up as characters who do not share their skin color or facial features. The concept of accuracy and authenticity in the cosplay community has set a damaging expectation: that the physical traits of Black cosplayers are enough to bar them from experiences in the art of cosplay.

Black cosplayers are tired of being told who they can and can’t portray in their very own art form. And, as geek culture gains notoriety under a mainstream lens, harmful behavior that is guided by white supremacy is becoming more visible. Body shaming, racial slurs and other forms of discrimination persistently cast a menacing, dark cloud on the cosplay experience – morphing an escape from reality into a visceral reality of racism and sexism. 

“There are going to be people that will tell you other things about your cosplay or the color of your skin,” Ebby said. “It’s so hard to ignore that, but the thing is, as long as you love cosplay and you find some type of joy in it, all that negativity, all those harsh things people say, all those racist comments don’t even matter anymore.”

This anti-Black racism — the dehumanization and marginalization of Black folks — in the cosplay community stems from members who see themselves as the gatekeepers of geek culture. Racialized and sexualized discrimination in the cosplay experience has been fueled by those who have sought to dominate fandom — a group of people, particularly white men, who feel that different elements of geek culture belong to them.

“You don’t have to look a thing like them,” Chrissy said, another cosplayer. “I definitely enjoy cosplay more since I figured that out. We are all just little creative nerds together. We are all just out here trying to make our favorite characters into a reality.”

Chrissy — affectionately known by the cosplay community as Chrissy Plays Dressup — has been cosplaying for over 15 years. Their journey began after attending their first anime convention at the age of 14. The costumes emulating characters from popular animated series such as “Inuyasha,” “Naruto” and “Bleach,” were vibrant, whimsical and sensational. They were self-expressions of the folks who wore them.

Chrissy had always been a big nerd with a passion for anime. It wasn’t a question of could they cosplay, but rather an excitement to get started. They even learned how to craft models through 3-dimensional artistry to build their own props. 

Through their art, Chrissy has transformed themself into a number of magical girls. In one costume, they are metamorphosed into Amulet Angel from “Shugo Chara!,” complete with white, feathered angel wings. In another, they put on their sailor suit, large blue bow included, to be transformed into the Sailor Guardian, Sailor Venus. Their latest costume transported them to the realm of “Cardcaptor Sakura” as the magical girl Sakura Kinomoto

“I want to make something that has never existed in this world before,” Chrissy said. “That is the most exciting part of cosplay for me.”

To address the harmful behavior within the community, Ebby and Chrissy have begun adding elements to their costume designs that weren’t necessarily accurate to the character, but that represented them, their art and their culture. For Chrissy, they often imagine an alternate reality where these characters are all Black — where the softness and sweetness of Blackness is fully on display — for inspiration. 

“I’m actually working on a Rapunzel costume, and I’m using a much curlier texture for her long braid. I’m putting box braids in as some accents,” Chrissy said. “It makes it feel a little bit more like this is me. I am this character.”

Black cosplayers like Ebby and Chrissy remain undeterred in their self-expression, using their cosplay to refute the discriminatory behavior that has infested the cosplay community. In a collective stand against these white supremacist tactics, Black cosplayers have used their skin tones and hair textures to embrace and embody the deep beauty of their Blackness. Black cosplayers continue to create creative spaces where Black art can flourish and be celebrated. These Black creative spaces invite other Black folks to relish in their Blackness in a cosplay community that is safe and loving.

Black cosplays are stunning works of art and a key act of resistance.

As the granddaughter of notable Civil Rights activists Wyatt Tee Walker and Theresa Ann Walker, it was natural for Chrissy to weave social justice into their art of cosplay. And, in the spirit of their ancestors, Chrissy has found a community — a Black creative space — with the power to further expose a sensational narrative of how Black folks show up and find joy in the United States.  

“I didn’t set out trying to change the world with costumes, but I’m so happy that I’m able to,” Chrissy said. “Not like it’s a huge platform, but I have a platform, and it’s giving people the chance to see themselves in ways that they never really thought they could before.”

Chrissy hopes to be able to hold space for folks who don’t have the capacity to attend Anime conventions by cultivating new creative spaces online. They envision a space where Black folks of all abilities, gender expressions and cultures can gather and relish in the geekiest parts of themselves. 

“I want everyone to have a space; I want everyone to have a voice; I want everyone to feel like they belong, especially in something as silly and fun as a hobby,” Chrissy said. “I just want everyone else to feel a little less burdened from the expectations that society puts on us, so I hope my little corner of the Internet can be a refuge for you.” 

For Ebby, in spite of the racist scrutiny, she hopes to join more cosplay competitions, to show off her craftsmanship and to let other Black folks know that there are creative spaces just for them. 

“We’re here in this space and we want to be acknowledged,” Ebby said. “No matter the comments that I might get or the looks I might get at a convention, despite all that, I’m still able to cosplay these characters, no matter how serious it may get, because these characters bring me joy, and that’s all that matters.”


Evan Narcisse

When the original “Black Panther” movie hit box offices in 2018, T’Challa became a household name for millions of moviegoers. But for Evan Narcisse, T’Challa is a name that lives deep within his earliest memories. 

Narcisse grew up reading comic books and graphic novels, becoming engrossed in the worlds of superheroes like Superman and Batman. He was particularly fond of the Black superhero the Black Panther.

“I’ve always been a pop culture junkie when it comes to comics,” Narcisse said. “I learned to read off of comics. Most people my age, they have this arc where they read comics as a kid, then they grow up and have other interests, and they fall away from it. That part never happened for me. I was always a fan of the medium.”

A young Narcisse found escape from the often-harsh outside world, immersing himself in the worlds and stories of superheroes. These worlds, which allowed him to imagine different and electrifying ways of showing up in the tangible realm, would prove to be an early influence for his future writing career.

Although continuously told that writing would not be a viable career, Narcisse decided to charter his own path, eventually obtaining a degree with a journalism minor from New York University (NYU). After graduation, Narcisse landed his first gig as a fact checker. But his passion for writing remained. 

“I still wanted to write about the media I loved – comic books, video games, science fiction,” Narcisse said. 

Over the next decade, Narcisse  was published in media outlets that embraced and celebrated geek culture, writing reviews and articles for Gawker, Kotau and io9. While at io9, he mostly wrote about the Black Panther universe. Narcisse’s expertise in the enchanting realm of Wakanda did not go unseen. 

In 2018, the “Black Panther” movie was nearing its release, and Narcisse was preparing to release his own story of Black Panther. He was nervous. He had never written a comic book before. Yet, in a pairing with esteemed illustrator Brian Stelfreeze, acclaimed writer Ta-Nehisi Coates and penciler Paul Renaud, Narcisse ushered in a new era for Marvel’s Black Panther. His story, “Rise of the Black Panther,” follows T’Challa on his rise to Wakanda’s throne and to the Black Panther legacy that made him an Avenger. 

“Comics are a unique medium with regard to how they let you play with time and pacing,” Narcisse said. “It’s very different from writing animation or video games. Each one of these media that I work in has different requirements and needs, and that stuff has been challenging but fun. But comics were really, really hard because my first chance to enter the media professionally was with my favorite character, who, little did we all know, was about to become a whole phenomenon.” 

Narcisse has written other comic books and graphic novels, publishing a mini-series titled “Wakanda,” the graphic novel “Batman: Gotham Knights – Gilded City” and a series of other comic projects that have created a multicultural superhero universe. Today, Narcisse is a senior writer with Brassline Entertainment and provides narrative design consulting for several popular video games — recently “Spiderman: Miles Morales,” and “Black Panther: The War for Wakanda.”

“I never thought I’d be writing Black Panther comics when I was a kid,” Narcisse said. “And to be perfectly blunt, I didn’t know that there was room for me as a Black person within the medium.”

Narcisse has found great success in embracing his passion. But, to his point, it can be hard for Black folks to see themselves represented in these types of creative spaces.

“It wasn’t until someone like my writing heroes Christopher Priest and Dwayne McDuffie, it wasn’t until I found out that they were Black that I realized, oh, there might be a little space for me,” Narcisse said. “We’re still underrepresented in that medium, video games more especially, but things are changing slowly but surely.”

Narcisse’s art form is a growing one: comics by Black artists written for Black folks that weave sensational tales of African ancestry before slavery. He is part of a blossoming hive of Black creatives who have intentionally carved space where Black folks can revel and indulge in their Blackness in an otherwise racist and harsh world. He is part of a collective whose niche seeks to tell the stories of Black folks and their African ancestries.  

Genres like Afrofuturism — which entangles African culture with science fiction — reflect worlds dreamed up by Black artists. The imagination of Black creatives has created worlds in which existing, often oppressive power structures are dismantled and Black folks thrive. Black creatives have become activists through their art. Their art has become a key act of resistance. 

“Hopefully, if you pick up something with my name on it, you’ll feel the pride and the fear and the anger and the love and the happiness and the goofiness and a sense of mentality that make me up as a person, and realize we can imagine our fictions in that way, we can imagine our realities in that way, and that’s what making art, making story, making magic is about,” Narcisse said. “Expressing a sense of yourself and your experience in a way that hopefully transmits and transforms into something universal that can be appreciated by other people. If I’m not hitting that, it ain’t worth it.” 

Although exhausting, Narcisse has been compelled to use his art to dispel the persistent perception that Blackness is a monolith, that there is a singular way in which Black folks show up in this world, and that all Black folks are nothing beyond the racialized violence inflicted on them by a white supremacist society. Narcisse strives to expose a narrative of Blackness as varied, as multicultural, and as something that can be soft, sweet and steeped in joy. 

“The depth and nuance and complexity of Black lived experiences is vast,” Narcisse said. “There are many different kinds of Black people. These ideas that Black people need to be stoic because of the oppression that we endure, that we have to control our emotions in different ways — there is an element of a survival tactic to that that I don’t want to dismiss — but it creates a rigidity in terms of what we tend to think of as possible with our lives and how we express ourselves.”

This rigidity can break us down, and it can make us brittle, Narcisse said. Black folks are in need of spaces in which they are afforded the flexibility to engage in the joys that build us back up, that feed our humanity, that we need to survive our lives. 

“They have the full range of hopes, dreams, responses, reactions that every other human being has,” Narcisse said. “Just because the predominant narratives about Black people are X,Y, and Z doesn’t mean the rest of the alphabet isn’t available to us. We’ve had to invent our own alphabets to subvert these ideas and to better communicate what our realities are, and speak truth to power with regard to calling out the elites and institutions that want to erase our history.”

When Narcisse sits down to write a comic strip, he envisions what he can conjure up that will excite the artist who will eventually turn his words into graphic frames of a comic. He wants to present a story that challenges them, that pushes them to paint a picture of a world of Black multiculturalism, Black joy and Black possibility. 

“I want to leave behind work that illustrates a sense of possibility and abundance for Black lived experiences that doesn’t feel constrictive, that feels it’s opening things up, hopefully, that’s charting history, that’s invoking the ancestors,” Narcisse said. “The collective spirit of my ancestors from Haiti who fought for their own freedom and really scared the entire world as to what Black agency could look like — I want to honor that spirit.”


Jasper William Cartwright

A gash of radiant light breaks through the raven-black sky, peeking over the mountains to the east and dissipating the fog that had covered the dense grassland. Rain pours from the storm clouds above, mixing with the blood that now stains the battlefield. Crimson-red dragons circle the skies overhead, spraying down flames that scorch hordes of undead and soldiers of the Animal Kingdom. An odor of dirt, iron and char clings to the air. Spread across this magical and mysterious landscape is a blur of chaos and violence, as a battle of creatures only found in the realm of fantasy ensues. 

This fantastical world, where armies of mythical creatures come to wage war, was born from the imagination of Jasper William Cartwright and his fascination with world-building. 

“I think that was always the thing I loved the most when I look back at my childhood or the books and games and shows and films that I loved — it was always the worlds I was fascinated in,” Cartwright said. “It was all about going somewhere that wasn’t where I was, just a normal human speaking to other humans. It was always about, can there be anything more fantastical to this?” 

When Cartwright was young, he spent hours dreaming up vast landscapes, mythical and strange monsters and new traditions and folklore. Once these new worlds took full shape, he would whisk his friends away to the whimsical lands, dank dungeons and thick forests of the Feywild, all of his own creation. Guided by Cartwright, his friends embarked on thrilling adventures, challenging battles and enchanting quests, crafting legendary tales of staving off hordes of undead from innocent town folk, overthrowing mad kings and freeing their people and rowdy bar fights that inevitably ensue during a drunken night at a tavern. 

For over 20 years, Cartwright has continued to build new worlds, cultivate magical realms and weave fantastical tales as a Dungeon Master (DM) and player of the fantasy role-playing game Dungeon & Dragons, known as D&D. Today, Cartwright is a regular DM at D&D in a Castle – a D&D retreat hosted in a real castle – and co-host of “Three Black Halflings”: a podcast Cartwright started with friend and fellow Black DM, Jeremy Cobb. 

In D&D, players create characters of different races, classes and combat abilities to form an adventuring party. These parties set out on riveting adventures in fabled worlds that take them into the depths of dungeons, the dens of monsters and the dimly lit taverns alive with rowdy drunks who are gambling, singing and conjuring up magic tricks. Candy-like dice are rolled to determine the success of players’ actions and how those actions will impact the overall story.

The game of D&D puts a unique type of art on display that relies almost entirely on collaborative and interactive storytelling.  

“What I love about it is it really feels like that kind of gathered-around-the-fireplace type of storytelling where you have to ask for a lot of buy-in from your audience,” Cartwright said. “What that creates is a really fantastic, immersive, shared space for everyone to exist in. I love the fact that my players are helping me write the story just as much as I’m helping to guide them on their journey. I think that’s a really exciting part of it.”

Along with hand-drawn maps and several opened books hidden from everyone’s view, the Dungeon Master sits at the head of the D&D table, ready to narrate this new story as told by their players. As a DM, Cartwright draws up maps and character art, introduces new challenges, performs all ancillary characters and makes sure his players are having fun. For Cartwright, it’s a labor of love.  

“I love this,” Cartwright said. “I want to throw myself into it because it fills me with joy, and I feel that I’m good at it, and I enjoy it, so I’m just going to go for it. It wasn’t until after [my start] that I was kind of like, oh, there’s some blockers here, or there’s some resistance.”

Here, Cartwright is alluding to D&D’s troubled history with race and representation. Although, D&D has been around for nearly half a century and is one of the most popular tabletop role-playing games of all time, it has also helped entrench some ideas about how we define and navigate race in fantasy. These ideas rely on a cultural default of whiteness that has continuously acted as the gatekeeper to the human imagination.

The realm of fantasy is imbued with European mythology and folklore — absent of multi-racial representation and diverse conjurings of new, mythical worlds. The game itself was developed during the 70s, receiving influence from notable fantasy writers such as J.R.R. Tolkein and H.P. Lovecraft, who was blatantly racist. Their works created a blueprint for the troubling conflation of race, culture, ability and, oftentimes, good and evil. 

“I’m a firm believer that every single person has something to say, has a story, has value — creative value,” Cartwright said. “We need people’s stories, and we see what happens when we only get the same kinds of stories over and over again. It has such an important impact, the way that it shapes the narrative of our society, the way that it allows our society to function.”

To address the racial stereotypes and colonialist supremacy that has seeped into the fantastical world of D&D, Cartwright has used the game as a vessel particularly suited for Black creativity and Black culture to flourish. Taking inspiration from the stories, myths and legends of different regions in Africa, Cartwright creates D&D campaigns to tell stories intimately enriched with the traditions and folklore of different cultures. 

“It’s really enjoyable watching players meet different types of cultures, myths and legends drawn from different places and that mean very, very different things,” Cartwright said. “Being a Black person in a world where prejudice doesn’t exist feels good.”

These topics, along with the lack of cultural representation among DMs and players, are points of conversation on Cartwright’s “Three Black Halflings.” Through thought-provoking conversations and guest interviews, the podcast explores racism and diversity in the worlds of D&D and popular culture and offers tips for other DMs. For Cartwright, being able to navigate these spaces with other Black folks and to engage in conversations about race has helped him connect to the rich, beautiful depths of his Blackness. 

“It was a way for me to connect to that side of myself, which historically I only ever did when I was around my other Black friends,” Cartwright said. “What I have discovered is this really wonderful connection to a part of me that I didn’t get to express for the longest time.”

Cartwright continues to carve out these Black creative spaces in D&D, providing countless Black players with their own space to connect with parts of themselves that are suppressed in an otherwise racist and tangible world. D&D can be an opportunity for Black players to recognize their own creativity and the value of their imaginations in creating these worlds where prejudice doesn’t exist.

Although their existence is real, spaces for Black folks to bask in their geekiness and express their fandom for D&D can be hard to find. Cartwright suggests starting with the “Three Black Halflings” Discord channel.  

“Never doubt that you will bring value to the table, whether that’s for jumping into a D&D campaign or deciding to write a script or paint something,” Cartwright said. “Whatever it is, I guarantee you that you have some value. If you have an urge and a passion to do it, you will add value to the space, and I, for one, will be thankful that you’re there.” 


Brandan “BMike” Odums

Brandan “BMike” Odums has always been a creative. Some of his earliest creations were doodled renditions of animated characters such as Sonic the Hedgehog and the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. Although only in second grade, a young Odums knew that he was going to be an artist.  

“I was always interested in drawing or putting pencil, crayon, marker to blank paper,” Odums said. “I was always doodling to the point where my classmates would offer to buy it or ask me to give it to them, or make requests.”

While in high school, he studied visual arts at the New Orleans Center for Creative Arts. He wanted to master creating visuals that delighted the beholders of his work. And he did, rising to the top of every art class. Driven deeply by his passion, Odums learned about professional art tools, different visualization techniques and how to create stunning works of art. 

For Odums, engaging in creatives spaces brought him joy. Every stroke of the paintbrush, every mark of the pencil, every line and every shape sketched, it all offered Odums a space to live within his wildest imaginaries. Creating art was a refuge from the obstacles life often presents. However, even though becoming a proficient artist while at NOCCA, the lack of Black representation deterred Odums from further pursuing art. He had a strong foundation to create art, but had not had the opportunity to explore the message he aimed to share.

“I didn’t have examples of what it looked like to be a Black artist, and not because these examples didn’t exist,” Odums said. “ This was before Instagram, before YouTube, and I had teachers who were predominantly white and who didn’t see the priority in introducing me to examples of Black artists or the legacy of Black art.” 

After graduation, Odums would go to college for filmmaking and videography, eventually founding 2-Cent Entertainment, LLC. Odums would spend the next eight years directing music videos for acclaimed hip-hop artists like Mos Def, Curren$y and Juvenile, and creating original content with a collective of Black creatives. Their projects aimed to educate, particularly the youth they engaged. These projects also sought to tell the story of a segregated city in the wake of Hurricane Katrina – of a politically violent landscape. 

It was September 2005 – Hurricane Katrina had made landfall, collapsing New Orleans’ levee system and releasing devastating floods that wreaked havoc on the Gulf Coast. Most of the city was under water. Over 200,000 homes were destroyed – over a million people displaced. Countless people were stranded on rooftops, and hundreds others had drowned. Survivors spent days without food or water, their resilience wilting under the beating sun. 

The disaster response was most tragic of all and exposed how racial and economic inequity, anti-Black policies and corporate greed work together to suppress New Orleans’ most vulnerable. Black folks suffered the most in the storm’s aftermath, including bracing themselves for an uptick in police brutality. Stuck without basic necessities, Black residents were labeled “looters,” as they scavenged for resources. Today, much of New Orleans is back. However, nearly 20 years after Katrina, in the Lower Ninth Ward – the city’s poorest and Blackest neighborhood – empty edifices and desolate streets continue to pepper the neighborhood.

These abandoned spaces became popular backdrops for the music videos Odums would direct. The videos sought to pay tribute to the neglected landscape and expose parts of post-Katrina New Orleans wrought by disinvestment, institutional failures and violent politics of racialized space that led to the death of over 2,000 people during the 2005 hurricane. 

In these spaces, it feels as though Katrina happened yesterday. And for many people, these spaces are a nuisance that elicit fear – a reminder of the neglect and the way anti-Black racism has egregiously impacted their communities. For Odums, these homes were everything but empty. The facades of these spaces were covered in graffiti art – blanketed in the voices and stories of a collective of people who once called these neighborhoods home.

“We were in the middle of these abandoned, forgotten homes, with the idea that people were displaced, that there were people in New Orleans that could not return because there weren’t places for them to return to,” Odums said. “Here we were in the middle of these apartment complexes, these housing projects, showcasing this idea that these spaces were there, and it was not being used for the reasons they should be used.” 

Odums ascribes a spark in curiosity to paint again to New Orleans’ housing crisis and community disinvestment. Attracted to the beauty and temporary nature of graffiti art, Odums began painting a series of murals, all depicting Black revolutionaries, in what was once the Florida Housing Development in New Orleans’ Ninth Ward. This project would soon become a radical, underground art movement, with young creatives from across the city sharing their stories through words and images added to the now abandoned yet luminous corridors of Odums’ project, called Project BE. 

“When it comes to the public art in the murals, I think it is an opportunity to collaborate,” Odums said. “It’s an opportunity to go into spaces, not as the voice but as the listener. I don’t live in this town of this city or this neighborhood, but I can sort of be at best a listener and an amplifier of the voices that are there or a collaborator with the voices that are there in hopes that that creates something.”

Soon after its conception, the Housing Authority of New Orleans terminated Project BE, demolishing the Florida Housing Development. Odums remained undeterred, eventually finding great success in his art form. He has collaborated with notable organizations and public figures, including Nike, Revolt TV, Ava DuVernay’s ARRAY, New Orleans Jazz and Heritage Festival, Boys & Girls Club, and so many more. He has painted murals from Palestine to New York City’s Times Square. 

Through five-story murals, indoor installations and found-object sculptures, he continues to tell the stories of state-sanctioned, racialized violence and creative forms of Black resistance.

Creating art has always offered Odums a haven of resistance – a sanctuary away from the often harsh outside world. There was no stress in these creative spaces. Odums wasn’t chasing some large entrepreneurial dream. Rather, he had discovered his message. Much like the graffiti art that inspired him to again create, Odums creates art to tell the stories of Black folks as they resisted and continue to resist the racialized violence that has been a distinct part of American history. 

“I really enjoy speaking to and for and with Black voices and Black people, and my work often represents that in a very direct way,” Odums said. “The why [I create] is simple, but it’s also complex in how you think about storytelling, how you think about representation. I think for me, the very simple part of it is I paint things that I love and what I appreciate. I love exploring Black history and the impact of people in the past.”

Through vibrant spray paint, a bold departure from realism and a unique play with color, Odums paints to respond, to resist and to call attention to the social and political fervor of a generation of Black folks and activists that blossomed in an environment marked by the nation’s first Black president, the revival of calls for police accountability and gained traction of the self-care movement. 

“Nina Simone said it’s the artist’s duty to reflect the time, so there’s this idea of reflecting the times and what’s happening from my perspective, and my reality, and my story, and just being authentic to my truth,” Odums said. “There’s the idea about the responsibility of Black art.”

“Sometimes my art can go places where people aren’t ready for me physically to be. They might not be ready to sit down and have a conversation with a Black man from New Orleans. But they will experience my work, or they will sit with my work and allow it to communicate with them.”

Today, Odums continues to use his art to be a steward of the present time, to cultivate creative spaces that offer a refuge for others to grow and create. He is the owner and lead artist for Studio BE, an art installation and creative space located in an abandoned warehouse. Studio BE is a space for community and the culture and stories that come with it. It welcomes folks from across the globe to engage with creativity to develop their critical voice and dive deeper into their imaginations to envision a future of possibility for Black lives.

“It was always a part of my journey to create stuff that was of service to people,” Odums said. “As the public art began to take more attention, it just became a natural fit to think about it as a community service project.”

Through their Eternal Seeds program, Studio BE also serves as a center to educate, empower and support young creatives. Embodying the power of Black creativity and collective expression, the program affords young artists with the space and the tools to radically transform the world into one that is loving, just and bursting forth with creativity. For Odums, it is important for this next generation of revolutionary artists to see themselves reflected in these creative spaces. 

“The space has allowed other people to create these moments that are valuable to them,” Odums said. “Even the weddings we’ve done in the space, where Black love has been exhibited and celebrated in that space specifically because the space existed.”

Odums is grateful to have been afforded the privilege to live a life deeply immersed within the beauty and richness of his imagination – dreaming up the possibilities for Black life to flourish. 

“I think New Orleans as a whole is such a magical place as it relates to the why in creativity or the why in artistry,” Odums said. “It’s a very old city. There’s a lot of old cultural practices and traditions that have existed and continue to exist outside of the idea of capitalism. It’s these things that people do because it’s the language they speak, not because they’re trying to achieve some sort of status or fame. 

“And the way this city loves me, and the way my parents love me has informed where I am. I wouldn’t be where I am if it wasn’t for the people of New Orleans who decided what I was doing was important enough to uplift.”


Myles “Fro” Martin

Myles “Fro” Martin hopes that people who attend his spoken word performances are able to find some type of connection with his poetry.

Myles Martin wrote his first poem when he was in eighth grade. It was a love letter to his then-girlfriend. At the time, Martin didn’t make much of his writing talent. He put down his pencil and paper for what he thought would be forever. 

In 2019, Martin had been incarcerated for a crime he didn’t commit. He spent a total of 30 months behind bars. And, although their young love didn’t last, Martin and the girl he had written a poem for all those years ago reconnected, finding love and admiration for each other again. Martin wrote a new poem, this time about their connection. Inspired by the same muse, Martin began to write again. 

“I had my own personal space and time, and it was just quiet times to think,” Martin said. “That’s why I just started writing. When I reached the two-year mark in October, 2021, I wrote a poem about what it was like for me to be locked up that long, and where my mindset was, where my mental state was, and I just kept writing.”

After his release, Martin began trying to readjust his life. He had been gone for so long. He no longer had contact with his two children. He worried about getting his record expunged. He had to find employment. He had to find shelter. 

Like so many other Black men in the United States, Martin has struggled to find stability after he was stripped of his life by the Prison Industrial Complex — an institution that imprisons Black men at an alarming rate. Labeled “convicts,” these men are barred from housing and food assistance, quality jobs and quality healthcare. Their mental health, which is greatly impacted by incarceration, is never tended to. The previously incarcerated are forced to navigate a hostile environment that is challenging and actively sets them up to fail once they are released. 

A month after his release, Martin decided to participate in an open mic night at a local establishment. He had never performed at an event like this before. He had never even been on a stage. But this was an opportunity to share his art with an audience. Over time, Martin became a popular act, adopting the stage name Fro

“People loved my poem,” Martin said. “I went back two weeks later, did another one.”

For Martin, poetry is an escape. His art is like a journal — a creative space that offers refuge for self-expression. When the world becomes heavy, Martin is able to carve space in which he can find joy, in which he can find release and in which he is able to honor the deepest parts of his Blackness. His poems contain real stories. They speak to Martin’s struggles, to Black struggles, and call on readers and listeners to have honest, and often difficult, conversations about race and racism.  

“I want people to feel, I can relate to that, but I also want people to feel like, oh, I never looked at it like that,” Martin said. “I want people to see another perspective on things.”

Poetry has also provided Martin a platform to advocate for other folks who are routinely funneled into the criminal justice system. He has performed moving spoken-word pieces at the Texas capitol in Austin, at a Tyre Nichols rally and at press conferences, decrying the maltreatment of Black folks by the criminal justice system and calling for reform.

Recently, Martin performed at a press conference and rally for Joshua Wright, who was shot and killed while in custody in Hays County, Texas. Corrections officer Isaiah Garcia fatality shot Wright while he was still shackled to his emergency room bed at Seton Hospital in Kyle. 

“That’s the same county I was locked up in,” Martin said. “That’s the same guard that used to harass me when I was locked up. So [his death] hit home.”

Upset by a lack of attention paid to Wright’s case, Martin felt compelled to write a poem, calling for “Justice for Josh.” 

“I had to try to make sure that if nobody is listening to [the family], please at least listen to me,” Martin said. “I’m like a megaphone for people who don’t know how to express themselves, or can’t, like the people in jail. 

Martin also writes poems to advocate for his childhood friend, Cyrus Gray. Gray, who was never convicted of any crime, spent four years in jail while he awaited trial. 

Martin never intended to acquire a platform with his art. He was empowered to write as a means of helping his friends and other Black folks subjected to the cruelty of a racist society. 

“I feel like when it comes to doing activist stuff, I feel I have no choice,” Martin said. “I have to be as loud as possible because there are people out here that you can’t hear at all, people in jail that you can’t hear from.” 

Martin writes at least six poems each week. While some weeks reap gold, others take him back to the drawing board. Regardless of what he writes, Martin seeks to paint a picture of Blackness that is softer, more emotional and deserving of freedom. 

“My goal is to show people that being arrested doesn’t mean guilty, so that people can have actual fair trials,” Martin said. “When you go on trial, everybody automatically thinks you’re guilty. You can just tell people looking at you like you’re guilty. You don’t even know the crime yet; they’re already judging whether or not I’m guilty. And just based on my appearance.” 

Martin has every intention to continue his art and to continue carving out these Black creative spaces in a society that would rather see him in chains. He hopes to someday use his platform to create his own independent comic book, beaming with Black characters and Black stories. He strives to continue to tell Black stories through art. 

“Every single day I’m pushing, I’m doing something,” Martin said. “I hate when I’m not working. I hate when I’m not writing. I hate when I’m not doing something. And I hate when I’m not making some type of impact.”

Through poetry, Martin seeks to weave a narrative of Blackness that is deserving of freedom rather than inherently an offender. 

two week notice

by Myles “FRO” Martin

I put in my two weeks 
Because to weeks ago my coworker thought he could relate to 
Hed’d say to me how he got harrassed by the police and ticketed 

I didn’t get it 

So I changed the subject 
Yet he continued 

Talking bout how he was subject to police brutality 
Saying things like “don’t get me wrong I know it’s hard for your people but we have it hard too”

I changed the subject….

He continued 
Like “we really need to bury these issues 
Because blacks-“

That’s where I stopped him 
I gave em 2 options 
I said “you can walk away now or jump down this rabbit hole
But you can’t climb back up”

He nodded 

Then said he’d been to Tdc 
hes saying he’s been to prison so what’s the difference 

My answer was the difference is you did it and I didn’t 

U earned your criminal position 
The same position I was born in
U went to an all white gang and got sworn in 

Forced it 

My upbringing was torture 
We wasn’t gangbangers 
We were hard workers working hard to shake reality 

U get arrested for possession of meth and claim police brutality 

I got arrested for being black and thanked god I was still breathing 
I was Arrested for no reason 
I could’ve been shot fa sneezing 

Then he said we’re the same 

I called my boss n put my two weeks in

Black Fugitivity and the Need for Spaces that Belong to Black Communities

This article is part of Dreaming Out Loud, a media series written as part of the Bioneers Young Leaders Fellowship Program. To learn more, visit bioneers.org/dreaming-out-loud.


Brick and wood-frame homes peppered the landscape, nestled in between an abundance of Black-owned stores that lined the streets for blocks. It wasn’t unusual for residents to dress lavishly as they attended doctor appointments, got haircuts, stocked up on groceries, danced at nightclubs and sat down to a nice dinner.

This was Greenwood in the early 1900s: a bustling, vibrant and thriving Black neighborhood in Tulsa, Oklahoma. Built in a northern pocket of the city, this affluent commercial and residential neighborhood became a robust and self-sustaining community and a pinnacle of Black success. By 1921, Greenwood had become so promising for Black futures that American author, educator and orator Booker T. Washington affectionately called it America’s Black Wall Street. 

But the prosperous Black neighborhood that took years to build would be erased in less than 24 hours by acts of racial violence motivated by resentment toward Black prosperity. Between May 31 and June 1, 1921, as many as 300 Greenwood residents were brutally killed. Their homes and businesses were burned to the ground. All of them were casualties of an enraged mob of white Tulsa residents. 

Greenwood Avenue, once a thriving Black business district, was destroyed by racial violence in less than 24 hours. – Tulsa Historical Society and Museum

In the crisp morning air of June 1, 1921, a throng of white residents descended on Greenwood. The city’s law enforcement officers had deputized every able-bodied white man, providing them weapons from the city’s armory. The mob threw dynamite into homes and businesses, while planes flew low overhead, dropping bombs across the neighborhood.

“The neighborhood I fell asleep in that night was rich, not just in terms of wealth, but in culture…and heritage,” recounted 107-year-old Viola Fletcher in a 2021 testimony before Congress, 100 years after the massacre. “I still see Black men being shot, Black bodies lying in the street. I still smell smoke and see fire. I still see Black businesses being burned. I still hear airplanes flying overhead. I hear the screams.” 

Many of the 300 murdered Black Greenwood residents were buried in mass graves, while others who survived the attack fled the city. Property loss claims totaled $1.8 million  — the equivalent of $27 million today. 

Not a single individual was convicted of a crime. 

Black empowerment necessitates Black spaces

Before its demolition, Greenwood exemplified Black economic empowerment. It was a paradigm for how Black communities create their own opportunity and wealth — for the power and importance of Black self-determination.  

“If we are excluded from engaging in practices that allow us to flourish in different ways in the outside world, then we imagine that the space we create with one another is where we can begin to build the foundations of all of those things,” said Dr. kihana miraya ross, Assistant Professor of African American studies at Northwestern University. “What was happening [in Greenwood] was happening because that’s all we had. We had to make something for ourselves in order to survive.”

Dr. kihana miraya ross

Though Black folks have been dreaming up spaces in which they can thrive throughout history, their endeavors and experiences are continually questioned, attacked and made invisible as a product of anti-Black racism — the dehumanization and systemic marginalization of Black people. 

This has been highlighted by a slew of recent, highly publicized and flagrant incidents in which racial targeting of Black people has occurred as they live, work, celebrate and navigate the world around them: a couple is held at gunpoint for picnicking at a KOA campground in Mississippi; the police arrest two men enjoying coffee at a Starbucks in Philadelphia; a birder is harassed while strolling in Central Park; the police are called on a college student napping in a common area at Yale; three filmmakers are surrounded by police as they checked out of an Airbnb in California.

According to Dr. ross, this anti-Black racism is an inescapable facet of society, making it natural and essential for Black communities to seek a reclamation of spaces that “promote the myriad of ways in which Black people practice seeing one another, loving one another, and granting one another breathing room in a world where anti-Black racial violence is normalized and asphyxiating.”

Simply put, Black folks need their own spaces — their own settings and experiences created in solidarity, in opposition to, and as a refuge from the conventional stereotypes and marginalization that permeate the public spaces they are regularly forced to occupy. It is crucial to the resistance of anti-Black oppression that spaces exist where Black folks may gather as their authentic selves to relish in their culture and affirm their humanity, unencumbered by white peoples’ judgment and prejudice.   

We need spaces where we may simply be Black. 

Black fugitivity is a practice of resistance

As witnessed in Greenwood, it is crucial for us to unapologetically take up space — to escape and become fugitive from the racial apartheid and persecution of anti-Black racism. Our very future is contingent on this fugitivity and our creations of this reclaimed, stolen and fugitive space. 

This concept of fugitive space has been utilized by scholars, such as Dr. ross, to analyze a transformational struggle from oppression to freedom. In other words, fugitive space provides a meaningful pathway for us to recognize the possibilities of a just and equitable future as articulated by Black communities and their experiences.  

In this context, fugitive spaces are a practice of resistance that acknowledges the reality of the harsh, oppressive systems that marginalize Black communities while simultaneously recognizing the diverse ways in which Black people experience, perceive and find joy in the world.

“Really, this is our only way of being in relationship to this world that we’re in. Otherwise, we risk becoming a part of it. If we’re trying to develop a stance that demarcates the world that we’re in from the world that we want to see, then we have to get out in order to do that. There’s no way to imagine Black futurities in the context of anti-Blackness. Any way we move toward liberation is going to be a fugitive act.”

Dr. kihana ross

To understand fugitive space, it is crucial to explore the historical roots of the term “fugitive” — which is rooted in chattel and plantation-style slavery. When enslaved Africans escaped from the plantations that shackled them, they were cast as fugitives of the system — criminals of the plantation economy, soon to be known as capitalism. They were considered property, which meant they were considered simultaneously thieves as well as the stolen goods.

“That act is a criminal act, and so if we’re thinking through that lens, then we can think about it as something criminal,” Dr. ross said. “But if we think about the system of chattel slavery as criminal, then we can start to reframe how we think about what is criminal, who is criminal. What does it mean to steal or not in those contexts?” 

Today, “fugitive” is utilized in the same sense — to describe a journey toward freedom. In a society infested by anti-Black racism and white supremacy, this freedom is only achievable when we actively participate in acts of escape. We can undermine these oppressive systems when we fearlessly seek love, joy and rest in spite of them — when we seek creative methods of refusal and resistance.  

“I think that in this particular case, we are saying that we honor our ancestors who dared to become fugitive, and we think about what it must have taken,” Dr. ross said. “As much as we read these books, as much as we listen to these audio files, as much as we watch, [we will] never, ever, understand the experience of the enslaved. And so, for me, a part of honoring that experience is trying to imagine what it must have taken for a person to literally risk their lives, risk the lives of their families, in order to get free.”

Black fugitivity is always present

These spaces don’t only take form as the edifices we erect. Most fugitive space is easily overlooked as it is commonly unmarked by the protests, walk-outs and burning buildings often associated with the resistance of nation-state practices and violence. 

As seen and heard on plantations in the antebellum South, fugitive space also takes shape as the community, relationships and experiences that are built in spite of the anti-Black racism and immense oppression imposed on the lives of Black folks. Drawing on both African musical heritage and western European sources, enslaved Africans created a rich musical tradition of spirituals known as sorrow songs — a name given by American sociologist, writer and civil rights activist W.E.B Du Bois.  

These songs, while generally conveying an atmosphere of melancholy and mourning, transcended the constraints of chattel slavery through meaningful self-expression. They embodied a critique of the conditions of enslavement and the broader social systems that supported it while simultaneously articulating and preserving the communal values of enslaved people.

Enslaved folks continued to find joy through the oppression that sought to strip them of it. After the Stono Rebellion — a 1739 slave revolt — enslaved Africans were forbidden to use drums on plantations for fear that they were hiding secret codes in their drumming patterns. In lieu of drums, enslaved people began creating dances to accompany their songs. This fugitive space was known as Juba. 

“There is a term of shouting Juba, or singing Juba, which to white folks from plantations, seemed very chaotic and non-linear, and it didn’t make sense,” said Dr. Justin Coles, Assistant Professor for Social Justice Education at the University of Massachusetts Amherst and Director of  Arts, Culture, and Political Engagement for the Center of Racial Justice and Youth Engaged Research. “But for [the enslaved], it was a coded celebration of language. That sort of fugitivity is always present.”

Dr. Justin Coles

According to Dr. Coles, fugitive space is all around us. It exists where Black folks are afforded the grace to live a full and valued life. It exists as any moment of time or experience where Black folks are honored and celebrated in ways that are humanizing and beautiful and where Blackness is not seen as deficient or less than.

“It might simply be a [Black] person walking down the street, and they see another Black person, and they give a head nod,” Dr. Coles said. “What if we also look to just the everydayness of Black folks where they’re not fighting, like a white supremacist nation; where they might simply be relaxing or resting?” Dr. Coles said. 

This practice of peering into the ordinariness of Black life is illustrated by Black feminist writer bell hooks’ interpretation of the concept of “homeplace.” According to hooks, the homes that Black women create, however fragile and tenuous, provide a space where individuals and families can freely live within their Blackness. They can resist their subjugation and nourish the soul and self. Throughout history, homeplace has offered space to organize and unify Black communities toward the common goal of achieving Black liberation. 

hooks explores Black homes – or homeplace — as space that Black folks need to understand their humanity as it relates to themselves and the world around them. 

hooks says the mere existence of Black homes represents resistance against racial domination and oppression: “Black women resisted by making homes where all black people could strive to be subjects, not objects, where we could be affirmed in our minds and hearts despite poverty, hardship, and deprivation, where we could restore to ourselves the dignity denied us on the outside in the public world…Historically, black women have resisted white supremacist domination by working to establish homeplace.”

While wanting to avoid further entrenching normative gender roles that continue to alienate us in the Black community, hooks also wanted to display the political power of homeplace and Black women’s power to uplift their people and their voices. 

According to Dr. Coles, the voices of Black communities and the stories those voices carry can help shed light on the essential existence of fugitive spaces. Dr. Coles refers to these stories as “Black literacies” — the narratives that make Black identities and social practices the focal point and shamelessly proclaim Black aspirations, experiences, imaginations and artistic expressivities.

Here, Black literacies seek to explore the multiple ways Black folks live within and experience joy in the world.

“Black literacies, for me, are essentially the tool or the energy source that keeps us being able to continue these various cycles and fights toward liberation,” Dr. Coles said. “Allowing us to, on those journeys, celebrate and relish in the joys of it all, to carve out time to understand that our totality is not suffering from those structures. I see that as a tool or a pathway, rather, toward those liberatory futures.”

Fugitive space: separation vs. segregation

Some may feel that creating Black fugitive spaces is a regression to pre-Civil Rights-era segregation. That feeling, however, highlights a disconnection with the reality of anti-Black racism as it persists in America today. 

“Regression” would assume that we have achieved a certain level of equality and are now regressing from it. It would mean that we’ve successfully created spaces in which everyone can easily find jobs, housing, healthcare and justice in the legal system — where everyone has equitable access to being felt, seen and heard. This is simply not our reality today.

When Black folks create space to be with only each other, those spaces aren’t acts of oppression. They’re responses to it. They’re our opportunities to separate ourselves from the abuses of anti-Black racism and patterns of white dominance. 

When Black folks find themselves in community — whether it’s occupying a makeshift piece of land, singing songs in the plantation fields or gathering in the homes where we find refuge — there can be healing. We’re able to offer and find support in a way that allows us to reclaim the beautiful parts of ourselves that have been repressed by anti-Black racism and white supremacy. This togetherness offers us resiliency for bringing our full humanity into spaces where it will inevitably be challenged.

“When you have these fugitive spaces, particularly Black fugitive spaces, they are counter to racial capitalist logic, to settler colonial logic, and all these things that tell us to not — that tell people not to work together. In a way, [those spaces] foundationally and slowly disrupt those systems. Black fugitive spaces are a disturbance — a way to cultivate and sustain a counter power to this larger weight that is working to oppress folks.”

Dr. Justin Coles

‘I love my hair, I love my nose, I love my skin, I love myself’

Ember Charter School’s halls are lined with pictures of Colin Kaepernick, Harriet Tubman and scenes from marches of the Civil Rights Movement. From the auditorium, the predominantly Black student body can be heard in chorus: “I love my hair, I love my nose, I love my skin, I love myself!” A teacher raises her fist in a Black power salute. The students mirror her actions and then make their way to their classroom – or schoolhouse as they are called at Ember.

This message is recited every morning at the Bedford-Stuyvesant, Brooklyn school. Ember is Afrocentric with an aim to empower Black children in ways traditional public schools in America have historically and consistently failed to do. 

Although very few exist, Afrocentric schools like Ember provide educational spaces to Black children that mitigate the racialized harm they experience in the traditional school system. Ember’s approach to education is holistic, with a curriculum that focuses on love, mindfulness, community, and is trauma-informed and culturally responsive. Black life is not only honored at Ember, it is celebrated.

Ember is a school explicitly designed for Black children. It’s a reprieve from the New York City public schools, which are among the most racially segregated in the country.

Dr. ross and Dr. Coles’ academic work in fugitive spaces play a major role in the envisioning of Black educational spaces like Ember Charter School. Both scholars agree that Black educational spaces are crucial to the development and socialization of young Black people, as these spaces afford Black students the grace to navigate their own education, their identities and the broader anti-Black landscape.   

“It is absolutely, 100% necessary for Black students to have exclusively Black space because it is the only space that they are allowed to, encouraged to, and free to unpack what it means to exist as a Black student in an integrated school — what it means to exist as a Black person in an anti-Black world,” Dr. ross said. “It’s the place where they start to, from my experience, understand that the predicament that they’re in is not just a predicament that they’re in, it’s a predicament that all of us are in because of the way we’re racialized in society.”

Afrocentric schools and Black educational spaces engage in educational practices that provide healing and liberation — that allow Black youth to explore themselves and their history and arms them with a political analysis of the world and the tools to oppose anti-Blackness.

According to Dr. Coles, Black educational spaces encourage youth to learn who they are, who they are not, what they can achieve and what they can’t based on the way they are racialized in this society. 

“It’s all about, how do we get people to see the value of Blackness? And that’s what Black education spaces do. There is great intention in needing to be in built space that exclusively centers Black people.”

Dr. Justin Coles

Ember Charter School is just one of many examples of a modern-day Black fugitive space. They exist everywhere, all around us. They exist in every setting, every experience and every thought that allows us to relish, unapologetically, in the Blackness of our minds, our bodies and our souls. Every community standing in solidarity, every dap given, every act of self-care. The blossoms of Black liberation are rooted throughout the nation.

This isn’t to say that they can’t be difficult to find. Whether medical, agricultural or creative, it can be arduous to find yourself in a space that values and humanizes Black life. And for white folks, this doesn’t mean that those spaces want to be found. It is undeniable that for Black folks to move freely toward liberation, they must be able to exist within spaces that are unburdened by the white gaze and the anti-Black racism that comes with it. 

In the fugitive pieces that follow, explore with me several ways in which white supremacy has sowed its dangerous seed deep within different systems and institutions that compromise integral parts of society. The journey will expose to us Black fugitive spaces, Black refuge and a path toward an anti-racist future.  

Uncovering the Complex Relationships of Non-Human Animals

As scientists continue to deepen their studies of the natural world, we find ourselves increasingly at odds with the prevailing worldview that sees non-human animals as less-than-intelligent, unable to possess “culture” or meet various requirements that have been used to designate humans as the superior. A rapidly expanding collection of researchers around the world are unearthing the intricate intelligence and relationships that characterize the life of many other-than-human species. A number of animals have long been recognized for their adaptability, communication and social structures, but ongoing research is unveiling even deeper layers of complexity, proving that we’ve only scratched the surface of how animals perceive the world and relate to one another.

From sperm whale communication to the gender dynamics of apes, the evidence of animal culture is ever-growing. A number of animals, it is now clear, display unique behaviors, customs, and knowledge that are passed down through generations, shaping their societies and enabling them to thrive in their environments. In this newsletter, we will embark on a journey of discovery, exploring some of the latest advances and thought-provoking insights into animal culture and consciousness.


Want more news like this? Sign up for the Bioneers Pulse to receive the latest news from the Bioneers community straight to your inbox.


What Sperm Whale Communication Can Tell Us About Communities & Cultures Beneath the Ocean’s Surface

Until fairly recently, the dominant view among scientists was that non-human animals didn’t manifest real intelligence and certainly didn’t live in dynamic cultures. But those ideas have been entirely demolished in recent years. Several examples of sophisticated decision-making, tool usage, emotional richness, and complex social organization in species have come to light.

In this edited conversation led by journalist Kate Golden, we hear from two major figures in this burgeoning scientific and societal renaissance, Carl Safina and Shane Gero, about what we know and what we might be able to learn from studying sperm whales.

Read the Conversation


Busting the Myth of Primate Patriarchy: The Nature of Sex and Gender in Our Ape Relatives

In this podcast episode of Bioneers: Revolution From the Heart of Nature, world-renowned primatologist Professor Frans de Waal explores the nature of sex and gender among our cousins the apes, and how gender diversity is a common and pervasive potential on nature’s masculine-feminine continuum. In the quest to overcome human gender inequality, he suggests that our focus needs to be on the inequality.

Listen Here


Shane Gero | Preserving Animal Cultures: Lessons From Whale Wisdom

Shane Gero, Ph.D., is a Canadian whale biologist, Scientist-in-Residence at Ottawa’s Carleton University, Biology Lead for Project CETI, and a National Geographic Explorer. In this presentation, Shane shares what he has learned from the thousands of hours he has spent in the company of sperm whales, including how fundamentally similar their lives are to our own and how their cultures define their identity, just as ours do. Shane explains why we need new approaches to whale conservation that recognize the biologically important divisions between different communities of whales, so we can respect their identity and cultural diversity; and how this can be extrapolated to the larger struggle to conserve biodiversity.

Watch Shane Gero’s Presentation


Stories From the Field: Carl Safina

Carl Safina, Ph.D., is an ecologist and the inaugural holder of the Chair for Nature and Humanity at Stony Brook. He is President of The Safina Center and a world-renowned, award-winning author on oceans, animals, and the human relationship with the natural world. In the following stories, Carl shares his insights about animal culture and consciousness.

What Sperm Whale Communication Can Tell Us About Communities & Cultures Beneath the Ocean’s Surface

Until fairly recently, the dominant view among scientists was that non-human animals didn’t manifest real intelligence and certainly didn’t live in dynamic cultures. But those ideas have been entirely demolished in recent years. Several examples of sophisticated decision-making, tool usage, emotional richness, and complex social organization in species have come to light (something Indigenous traditions have long held to be self-evident). 

In this edited conversation led by science journalist and artist Kate Golden, we hear from two major figures in this burgeoning scientific and societal renaissance: Carl Safina, a longtime, world-renowned advocate for animal intelligence; and Shane Gero, a National Geographic explorer and daring, visionary young scientist on the frontlines of research on animal societies. Carl and Shane discuss what we know and what we might be able to learn from studying sperm whales, and if we can get beyond our species chauvinism. 

This conversation took place at Bioneers 2023.


KATE GOLDEN, SCIENCE JOURNALIST: Tell us what it is like studying sperm whales.

SHANE, SCIENTIST & NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC EXPLORER: I’d love to tell you that the reason the sperm whale project has been so successful has been because of my amazing skill as a biologist, but there is the right place to study the right animal, and Dominica has this magical combination of ecology and the species and the oceanographer that means the sperm whales are there.

We went to Dominica, and it was like the promised land. Before that, we’d only spent maybe 14 days in a row with a family of whales. So to spend an entire month was unheard of. 

They’re there virtually year-round, and the families sort of take turns. There’s usually only one family of seven animals off the island on any day. The project leaves from shore in a small open boat, and then we go home every night and sleep onshore, and the whales go about their business. In other years, we’ve lived on a sailboat, spending 24 hours a day with the whale families. The project has built this family of people who are literally living above the surface of this family of whales that we care so much about. 

KATE: What kind of intuition do you get about whales from spending so many hours watching them?

CARL SAFINA, WRITER & ANIMAL RESEARCHER: I guess the overarching impression is that they really know who they are, and as Shane taught me, not only do they know who they are because of who they’re with, but we know who we are because of who we are with. Our companions create our identity, our relationship to other individuals is what creates our identity. It’s so completely universalizable that it changed my view of a lot of things.

SHANE GERO: I would agree. I often say that by spending a lot of time trying to learn how to be a whale, you actually learn to be a far better person. Their lives are about fundamentals that make a ton of sense.

CARL: They’re fundamentally the same as us. Shane may have a different impression after 20 years, but my impression is that they’re concerned about their families, and they’re concerned about staying together and who they’re with and how they do the things that they do, and that applies entirely to us. The details are very different, but I think fundamentally we’re very similar.

They don’t look like a typical mammal, and they have that incredibly unusual head, but when they’re swimming over to each other to meet after a dive, they’re greeting each other like dogs greet each other, or like dogs greet us. They’re greeting their family, and they like to rub, they like to touch. 

SHANE: The truth is that they’re individuals as much as we are. There are some that are super curious, especially when they’re young, about pretty much anything, whether it’s a sea turtle or ocean plastic pollution or our boat. 

KATE: Can you talk a little bit about their worlds — the pressures they’re dealing with, the decisions they have to make on a daily basis?

CARL: One thing about the sperm whale society that is surprising and interesting and cool is that their family structure is a lot like elephants. They live in female groups, and females stay in the group they were born into. So if you’re a mother, you’re with your daughters and your sisters and your mother, if she’s still alive. The males leave at adolescence, and they have a different kind of social life. That’s very similar to African elephants. 

The reason for it, with sperm whales, seems to be that because the food is really far down and the babies can’t go, babies always need babysitters. The adults have to leave the surface, and somebody has to stay with the babies. It can’t always be the mother because the mother also has to go and find food. 

Their physical world is obviously much more vertical than ours. They fly up and down in the ocean. They can’t breathe in most of their environment. They can go where there’s oxygen, but they have to take the oxygen with them, which connects them to the surface every hour or so. They’re not just holding their breath in their lungs like we do when we dive. They’re dissolving the oxygen into their blood. 

But the other thing is, they go into places with no light at all. We call that darkness. When humans see things, we have the impression that we are seeing out. But that’s literally an optical illusion. What’s really happening is that there’s a lot of light bouncing around in the entire room. Since it travels in straight lines, it comes into our eyes, and in certain patterns of reflection, our eyes code the patterns, and they send a code along a wire called a nerve, and that goes into our brain. Our brain decodes what’s come in on that nerve, and it creates a picture. So what we see actually only happens in our brain.

It may be that whales and other cetaceans and bats take the reflections of sound and make pictures out of it. There are blind people who claim that they see the sounds that are reflected; they hear and they make a visual picture in their brains. If blind humans can do that, it’s likely that cetaceans and bats can do that. Is that a possibility?

SHANE: Yeah, I love it. I don’t think it’s far-fetched at all. I think how they’re doing that and how much they need to do that is an amazing question. 

In dolphin groups, all of the dolphins click. You can have a thousand common dolphins flying around in the open ocean, all of them echolocating all of the time, whether there’s food around or not. Why is that? Couldn’t just the 10 in the front echolocate? 

One analogy is, imagine we’re all running through the forest with flashlights. You’re going to use mostly your flashlight to make sure you don’t trip, but everyone else with flashlights around you helps to create a 3D map of the world. 

So we know they make clicks and they get echoes back, and they use that information to navigate and find food. Recently, marine biologists have been able to put suction cup computer tags on smaller porpoises. With the echoes that the porpoise is making and then hearing, they can actually see the resolution enough that they could watch the tail beats of the fish that the porpoise trying to hunt. 

There is this amazing echoic scene in front of a sperm whale, which can sometimes have 600 or more targets. Who knows if it’s marine debris or a squid, but there’s a lot going on in front of a sperm whale, and we know now that they’re picking up squid over 120 meters away. That distance is really, really huge. 

There’s a war going on in the dark in the ocean. You have this amazing mammal that’s developed a sound system to see through the dark, and then you have this amazing squid whose eyes are getting bigger and bigger and bigger in order to see the whale before it gets hit. The idea has been that the squid is potentially looking for this bioluminescent bow wave as the whales come through those layers in the ocean, and they get out of the way. But if sperm whales are picking up a squid at 120 meters away, it seems like they have, hands down, won that arms race. 

CARL: I never thought about the fact that a sperm whale’s bow wave could be literally lighting up all of the phosphorescent organisms down there. But there are a lot of things in the ocean that make a tiny little bit of light when they’re disturbed. That’s pretty amazing to me. 

KATE: What do you know about what whales are saying to each other?

SHANE: I know what I believe they’re saying. It’s pretty clear based on how they interact that they have a need to label each other as individuals, as family groups, and as clans. Those patterns of differences emerged in such an obvious way. We figured out who spends time with who, mostly by building family albums. Once we figured out those social patterns, the sound overlapped perfectly. That explains how they might be able to not only label each other but also broadcast their own identity.

But it gets complicated in terms of a couple of problems, technologically. One is figuring out who’s saying what. The second problem comes with a bias in how we study the whales. I call that the dentist’s office problem. If your microphone happens to be in a dentist’s office, and you don’t know what a dentist’s office is, you’re going to think the term “root canal” is critically important to English-speaking society. But it’s only because you have such a narrow picture of all of the potential contexts and behaviors that humans do when they talk. 

Scaling up across contexts allows us to get the who and the what, but also the where and the when so we can answer that why question of what are the important things that whales talk about. 

KATE: Tell us how the tags that you’re using in machine learning might help you a bit with that problem.

SHANE: Project CETI is one of the big projects that we’ve launched over the last number of years with roboticists, computer scientists, cryptographers, and linguists. We’re working on being able to record on a much larger scale, to create technologies that allow us to record off Dominica across 30 kilometers or more. And then we’re working to create pieces of equipment that can add all of the behavioral context of what the whales are doing. That involves new suction cup tags that last longer. We’re working with Harvard microbiotics lab to create those. 

I feel like a kid in a candy shop because 20 years ago, I would sit there and record with one hydrophone and know that there was information being exchanged. You can’t watch siblings play and chat and not recognize what’s happening there, but we had absolutely no clue what they were saying. Now we have all of these amazing experts. 

CARL: I just want to add that there are some things that dolphins have done that appear to be impossible unless they were communicating really detailed information to each other, similar to what humans are capable of doing. For instance, you can train dolphins in captivity to understand a signal that means “Do something we never taught you to do.” Two dolphins will go swim around their enclosure for a few moments and then, in perfect synchrony, they will together do something they were never taught by people to do. It will be the exact same thing, like they’ll both jump out of the water spinning to the right. Nobody knows how they’re communicating that because they don’t appear, to us, to be talking to each other at that moment. 

In the period when the orcas in the Northwest were being captured for aquariums and amusement parks, a lot of those families were repeatedly chased and had babies taken from them. At one point, all of the males of one family split off and stayed at the surface, very obviously and very noisily, while all the females with babies went in a different direction, stayed underwater for as long as they could hold their breath, and traveled to the backside of an island. That seems impossible unless they were telling each other what to do based on knowing what was about to happen to them. 

But when I spent a bunch of time with Ken Balcomb, who had studied the orcas in that area for 40 years, he said to me, “I’ve never heard them say anything that made any sense. I’ve never heard a call repeated that sounded like something.” But it seems to me perplexing that they would spend so much energy, and evolution would give them these voices to make all these sounds if it meant nothing to them. But it meant nothing to the leading expert in the world. 

I have this question about whether our human brain is capable of actually learning the language of another kind of mind. I think it might be possible. That’s what Shane is working on. 

But I also think that coming up with nothing doesn’t mean nothing is there, necessarily. And I’m not saying that because I believe that they are definitely talking to each other. I don’t know. It certainly seems like dolphins or at least some dolphins are capable of saying some complex things that our brain might not be capable of understanding. And if it gets somehow coded into something that we can understand, maybe we wouldn’t understand it.

Since we know that in our Western culture for the last 5,000 years or so, we’ve continually sold every other living thing short of what it’s capable of, my little caveat is that if the machine-learning stuff doesn’t come with a transcription of what they’re saying, that doesn’t necessarily mean they’re not saying something. It may mean that the human mind cannot understand their language.

SHANE: I agree in so many ways. Where I find a lot of hope already with machine learning is that it’s blowing open the encoding space potential. What the machines have done, quite rapidly, is open up multiple new dimensions within an individual call, within a click for sperm whales, where there is the potential for variation. So while we used to identify a 1+1+3 pattern, there are now four different types of 1+1+3, and they seem to be used in different contexts. 

Computers are giving us the capacity to see a deeper phonetic alphabet of possibilities, and that’s going to be a big jump. It’s not going to be Google translate next week, but what it will do is give the whales a bit more credit in terms of literally defining the complexity of the information that they’re sharing with each other.

Keep Reading About Intelligence in Nature

  • Subscribe to Earthlings: a biweekly newsletter exploring the extraordinary intelligence of life inherent in animals, plants, and fungi.
  • Download our free Intelligence in Nature Reader: Bioneers thought leaders have shared research and observations about nature’s intelligence for decades. In this reader, we’re excited to share a small selection of the groundbreaking concepts buzzed about within our community.
  • Take a Deep Dive: Our Intelligence in Nature Deep Dive is a growing collection of incredible stories and conversations with researchers and leaders who are uncovering nature’s intelligence.

Can Storytellers Help Save the World: From Fictional Narrative to Real World Change 

In times of crisis, societies look to their storytellers to understand and process the challenges and to peek around corners to see pathways that purely rational analyses simply can’t fathom. Today, best-sellers in fiction and memoir are setting real-world information about the climate crisis, social justice movements, and migration realities within their narratives. Audiences are ready for these stories, but what about artists? Does the moment dictate the art? In our ancestral past it was the myth-makers who guided their communities through crisis. How do storytellers move in or move out of our current reality? 

Bioneers invited a world-class group of writers from around the world to explore these questions and more. Hosted by Laleh Khadivi, Iranian-born writer and filmmaker, the conversation featured Keenan Norris, novelist, essayist and scholar and Andri Snær Magnason, Icelandic novelist, poet, filmmaker and environmental activist. Their complete bios can be found below. 

Please enjoy this excerpt of their fascinating conversation on the Bioneers stage, as three writers coming from tremendously different backgrounds explore the overlapping themes of mythology, family history, and migration as they weave fictional narratives with real world movements for change.


LALEH KHADIVI: As I was researching the books and the writers we have here today, I realized something that was startling, and it made me want to begin with a quote from Jorge Luis Borges’ short story, The Library of Babel: 

“Methodical composition distracts me from the present condition of humanity. The certainty that everything has already been written annuls us, or renders us phantasmal. I know districts in which the young people pros­trate themselves before books and like savages kiss their pages, though they cannot read a letter. Epidemics, heretical discords, pilgrimages that inevita­bly degenerate into brigandage have decimated the population. I believe I mentioned the suicides, which are more and more frequent every year. I am perhaps misled by old age and fear, but I suspect that the human species –­ the only species – teeters at the verge of extinction, yet that the Library­ enlightened, solitary, infinite, perfectly unmoving, armed with precious volumes, pointless, incorruptible, and secret – will endure.”

I’m going to start with something rather uncanny. Both of you begin your most recent books in libraries. Not only that, but you both begin your books holding precious texts. Not only that but you both hold the texts with fear that they will evaporate in your hands. Not only that but you then go on to put the text down and begin interviewing your families, which is another archive unto itself. I’d like to begin the conversation by asking why, when you set out to write about our current moment and the future, do you begin by going backwards?

KEENAN NORRIS: That’s a wonderful question. Why go backwards first? I feel particularly, as a Black person, as a Black American, that the many material barriers to a fuller historical knowledge of my family members heritage and history – let alone my people’s heritage and history – creates really an exceptionally intense desire to go backward, to look backward. To somehow recapture a glimmer of this historical lifelong past that none of us can fully know, to understand that which has come before.

ANDRI SNÆR MAGNASON:  Thinking about a time in the future, like 2100, is strangely culturally meaningless for us. I found that it was easier to connect to the future by first connecting to the past and creating a ballast against that. I was recalling the oldest thing that I had handled. My first summer job was in the archives of the University of Iceland, which have the primal sources of Nordic mythology, like the Edda Manuscripts written around 1200 that contain memories from, well, who knows how old the memory is. We lost all the Viking ships, but we preserved almost all the stories that were in the people’s heads that came to Iceland.

If that single manuscript had been lost, we would know little about Thor, Valhalla, Ragnarök, all these concepts. I was handling this manuscript, this primal source of Nordic mythology, putting it on display every single day. I had nightmares every night where I was dumped down with the manuscript, and I lost it, and suddenly I was in my underwear, and I had lost the manuscript.  

The same summer, I had my first child. I was 23. In my hands I had this slimy little unwritten future and then this 800-year-old wisdom. I was thinking, wow, if he becomes 100, he will be alive in 2100. Meanwhile this manuscript has been around for 800 years. How do you decide to preserve something for 800 more years, to the year 2800? Will the language be here? The Earth has changed more in the past 100 years of the manuscript than it did in the previous 700 before that. I was using the past to understand the future.

LALEH: That’s kind of what I suspected, given the similarity of your books. Keenan was in the Yale archives, and he was holding Richard Wright’s notes, and the beginnings of the manuscripts. Both encounters are with stories that are reaching through time to get us. The stories that you both wrote reach through time to get the people in the future – and they lead you back to your families.

KEENAN: I understand history first through my family. The first histories that I was told were the histories that my father and mother told me about our family, about how we got to California, how on my father’s side they came through Chicago; how on my mother’s they came through Oklahoma via the Central Valley in California, both leaving the South, as part of the Great Migration. For me, history is rooted in the family.

When I went to the Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library at Yale, where Richard Wright’s archives are kept, a realization that came upon me as I moved through the successive layers of surveillance in this kind of un-layering process – they literally make you disrobe and go through security to make sure you can’t record, take photographs, all that. As I spent time at Beinecke, I realized: Richard Wright isn’t really here. This is where his papers are; this is where his formal archive is, but the Richard Wright who lived and wrote in Memphis and in Chicago and in New York and in Paris isn’t here. I needed to go back to where he had actually written this work, to the extent that I could.

When I was 13 years old, my father gave me James Baldwin’s Go Tell It on a Mountain. He said, “Read this and you’ll know more about who I am.” When I was 14, he gave me Richard Wright’s Native Son and Black Boy, the real title of which is American Hunger, and said, “Read these books and you’ll know more about where I’m from.” Those books became a second way of understanding my own family history.

Again, history is mostly lost to us. It’s mostly lost to us, but I hoped to recover some fragments of these stories that Wright told, which my father had given to me as kind of a second layer of history, to help me understand our family and our family’s journey, that wasn’t to be found in this formal archive. Literature and stories are a way in which we try to make ourselves legible, understandable across generations.

ANDRI: The archives I worked in also contain thousands of hours of recordings that folklorists had been collecting. I was listening to these recordings and learning the stories of the folklorists themselves, the work they did to gather what remained from elders. For example, they heard that an old lady knew a fragment of some lullaby, and they rushed up north to catch her at the elderly home, asking her to sing, but then her voice was broken and she just had a stroke a week before. So they eternally lost this lullaby.

I was listening to thousands of hours of old ladies singing songs that they learned from their grandmothers, that they learned from their grandmothers, that they learned from their grandmothers, and they could trace it maybe 300 years back.

I was thinking about how something goes from being common to becoming rare to becoming precious and then just lost.

I still had two grandmothers and three grandfathers (my grandmother had two husbands – not at the same time). Here I had a direct connection to the Great Depression, to all these stories. I began to interview them, no real structure or goal, just randomly. How was it during the occupation during the war in Iceland? What about Christmas, 1930? I thought that anything I recorded would become precious for my children.

Years later I met this climate scientist in Potsdam, and he asked me why I didn’t write about climate change. I said, “I don’t have authority; I’m not a scientist. Scientists should write about the science.” But he said, “People don’t understand that; they understand stories.”

I started to think about my family’s stories and what stories I could bring to the table, what my contribution to the global understanding of climate change would be. My grandparents were glacial explorers at a time when women were not supposed to go out to glaciers. They went on a glacial honeymoon in 1956, and they were stuck in a tent on a glacier for three days as a storm raged over. I asked them, “Weren’t you cold?” And they said, “Cold? We were just married.” I asked that question first when I was 10 and I didn’t quite understand the answer.  

They were exploring the glaciers and actually naming this tabula rasa, this white infinite 10,000 square kilometer mass, which is the biggest glacier in Iceland, one-tenth of the country. It didn’t even have a name at the time. I knew the person that was exploring and naming the place, but I would also know the person that would be here to see that place lost.

Suddenly my family story started to make sense.

LALEH: I want to stay on family for just one more second. My own fiction is inspired by interviews that were a little more methodical, a little less random. The understanding that formed me as a writer that writes about migration is that it has been in the history of my family forever.

My Kurdish father’s family migrated around the Kurdish mountains for as long as he had record of or could remember. My mother’s family from Esfahan had come from different places to land in Esfahan when they could finally afford it. Then, of course, there is moving to the United States. But looking at the future and seeing the story of human movement in the inevitability of what’s going to come made me able to link that family inheritance with the narrative to come.

Andri, your glacier story is a very good example of how exploring your family story or inheritance gave you the authority to approach writing about science, climate and the future. Keenan, how do your family stories give you the confidence to write into the future?

KEENAN: As I learned more about my family, I saw how their stories, our stories, were really stories of Black American migration, this history of Black American migration in microcosm. When I talked to my great Uncle A.W., and he told me that he was born in Tulsa, Oklahoma in the spring of 1921, and I asked him, “Did your family leave because of the massacre?” he just nodded at me. I was able to place another brick in this wall of my understanding.

My father told me about growing up in Chicago, and his memories of living 13, 14, 15 people to a two-bedroom apartment. Landlords had taken a full-size apartment, thrown a partition between to create two apartments, and they were charging Black people as much as they had charged the former white residents for half the space. I learned something about our migration and how we became an urban people (and, in part, why our cities are so messed up).

You asked how that informs my writing about the future. I think that I’m really unable to conceive of a future that is not in some way actually bound to this American past. This compelled migration is the root of my writing about what is yet to come.

To learn more about these three incredible authors, please consider purchasing their books via the links below or at your local bookstore.

The Confession of Copeland Cane

Keenan Norris, an Associate Professor at San Jose State University, is a novelist and essayist whose latest novel, The Confession of Copeland Cane, won the 2022 Northern California Book Award. His essays have garnered a 2021-22 National Arts & Entertainment Journalism Award and 2021 Folio: Eddie Award, while his debut novel, Brother and the Dancer, won the 2012 James D. Houston Award. His most recent work is a “biblio-memoir,” Chi Boy: Native Sons and Chicago Reckonings

A Good Country

Laleh Khadivi, born in Esfahan, Iran, is a writer of fiction and nonfiction as well as a director, producer and cinematographer of documentary films. Her debut novel, The Age of Orphans, received multiple prestigious awards, and her documentary film, 900 WOMEN, aired on A&E and premiered at the Human Rights Watch Film Festival. Her fiction and non-fiction have been published widely, including in The Los Angeles Times, San Francisco Chronicle, VQR and The Sun. She was also the recipient of a National Endowment for the Arts Grant and a Pushcart Prize for her story, Wanderlust. Her most recent novel, A Good Country, was published by Bloomsbury Books. 

On Time and Water

Andri Snær Magnason is a leading Icelandic writer and documentary filmmaker. His latest book, On Time and Water, is a search for a new language to explain the climate crisis through science, family stories and mythology. His work ranges from poetry to non-fiction, children’s literature, science fiction, theater and documentary film. Andri has won multiple international awards, the Tiziano Terzani Award in Italy, the Philip K. Dick honorary mention in USA for LoveStar and the Icelandic literary Award in all categories. He ran for president of Iceland in 2016 with environmental issues on the agenda and came in third. 

Solutions Journalism within a Shaky Media Landscape: An Interview with Evette Dionne of YES! Media

To understand the astronomical shift in media consumption over the past several years, one needs only to look at the trends in local newspaper readership. From 2015 to 2020, weekday circulation of local newspapers in the U.S. dropped by 40% and Sunday circulation dropped by 45%. Many of these struggling publications have been bought up by private equity funds, hedge funds, and other newly formed investment partnerships, which generally lack journalistic backgrounds and interest in local enrichment. Their focus is on quick profit instead of quality journalism, and communities are suffering as a result.

Pull that focus back to a national level, and the picture is just as bleak. Audiences have a low level of trust in news media organizations, and Americans under 30 are almost as likely to trust information on social media as they are to trust information from national news outlets.

The great news is that independent nonprofit news organizations have gained steam on a local and national level. These organizations, largely supported by foundations and individual giving, aren’t obligated to consistently and rapidly grow their bottom lines. They’re perpetuating a model of journalism free from the trappings of market pressures, and they’re filling the void left behind by shuttered traditional newsrooms.

YES! Media has been traversing the media’s choppy waters for 27 years. As an independent nonprofit publisher, the organization has consistently prided itself on publishing high-quality, solutions-focused journalism. YES! seeks to be a constructive part of essential conversations, and while it has managed to stay afloat without sacrificing its values, its success hasn’t come easily.

We had the opportunity to sit down with Evette Dionne, YES! Media’s executive editor for nearly a year. Hired after a short stint at Netflix, Dionne’s experience is largely in journalism that tells the important stories from which other organizations shy away. She spent more than four years as the editor-in-chief at Bitch Media, a feminist storytelling organization focused on pop culture. Today, she’s ushering in YES! Media’s new wave of editorial direction and journalism that speaks to audiences ready to change the world.

What was it about working with YES! that appealed to you? 

The idea of doing solutions journalism. I’ve been a journalist for more than a decade, and journalism tends to focus on the problem. It’s rare that people, especially ordinary citizens, are empowered with the knowledge and the information to try to fix problems in their communities. What appealed most to me about YES! was moving to the other side. Instead of just saying, “Police violence is an issue,” it’s, “Here’s what we can do about police violence. Here’s how we can approach it. Here are different things that have worked. Here are things that are not working. Here are solutions that you can scale.” 

Has YES! always been dedicated to solutions-focused journalism? 

YES! began on Bainbridge Island, Washington, 27 years ago. Originally, their focus was mostly on how to bring people together in ways that allow communities to build toward solutions. 

The earlier iterations of YES! were focused a lot on the environment and climate change. Over time, it’s evolved to be more social-justice and racial-justice focused. It’s not just about whether it’s possible for us to come together to make things happen, but rather, what are the impediments to that? Often the impediments are around class and race and gender and gender identity. The newer iteration of YES! focuses a lot on if a solution will work for the most marginalized among us. If it works for the most marginalized among us, then we can scale it. 

How do you envision YES! as part of the broader media landscape?  

I think one of the things that YES! is trying to orient ourselves around is moving from taking a broad view of the issues. Even though the publication has been solutions-focused, it’s really been this broad view. We’re learning how to go from that to being embedded in movements and being an outlet for organizers and lobbyists and people who are on the ground involved in these issues. We want to allow them to speak their piece and explain the reasons why it’s important to become involved from that ground view. I would say that’s really the mission and the purpose now. Instead of being on the advocacy side, we want to move into the activist element of it. 

Could you tell us a little bit about your editorial process and how you determine which stories to tell? 

Actually, you’re asking me this question at the right time because we’re switching it up. In addition to becoming executive editor, I’m now responsible for our strategy, which means overseeing our content vision, overseeing our strategy and how we do what we do. A lot of it now is around intentionality.

We come together collectively to determine the stories we are going to pursue and the reasons why. Sometimes we want to reach a broader audience, and sometimes we want to deepen our relationship with an audience that we already have. Sometimes we want to start to build relationships with particular audiences, and it’s important to create and publish stories that appeal to them. 

We’re in a really unique place because we’ve been doing this a certain way for so long. Our editors have been on beats for a long time. This shift asks them to come out of their beats and asks us to come together collectively to decide what we want to do. Our test run of doing that was the magazine. We have shortened the number of stories that are in each issue, and we come together to decide which are the best stories around the theme that we can pursue. It requires us to do a lot more soliciting, which is also a change. Typically, we were a pitch-driven organization. Now, it’s all around this idea of being more intentional in the kinds of stories we’re pursuing.

YES! has never been and will never be a breaking-news organization. That’s not what it exists for. But that doesn’t mean that we can’t become a part of news cycles. Consider what happened to Jordan Neely on the subway. People may feel hopeless in that situation. We might tell the story of how to become a better bystander in that situation, for instance. We’re really infusing ourselves into those sorts of situations and being more timely by looking at the landscape and saying, “Okay, that’s important. What is the solutions angle?” 

Then we find the right writer for the story and the right sources, and then we present it to our audience as almost definitive: “This is our single story about this.”

I always say we’re building toward a quality rather than quantity model. There’s no need to keep producing, producing, producing. We can take our time and be the definitive story around a single issue. That’s worth our time. So that’s the way I’m trying to shift our team to think about it in our organization. 

Which recent stories are resonating with your audience the most? 

We did a story about the importance of ethnic grocery stores, and people loved it. I think that’s because one of the things that solutions journalism fills people up with is a sense of hope. I frequently quote the abolitionist Mariame Kaba: “Hope is a discipline.” Sometimes you just need something like a bright spot. Something to read that makes you feel warm and fuzzy. It’s a solutions story. But it’s not a solution to an evil problem that is keeping you up at night.

The story talks about the need for people from marginalized communities to go to a grocery store and feel like they’re at home. They have all the things they need to prepare their cultural cuisines. There is a problem there, clearly, but the solution is also fuzzy and warm. It makes people feel good, which is always good. 

Do you see any other trends within your audience?

I’m a big data person. I believe a lot in using data and analytics to tell a story about what audiences care about. Instead of just throwing spaghetti at the wall, we can use data to guide the decisions we make about what stories to pursue, especially when we have limited resources.

The thing that we found on the digital end, in particular, was that those audiences care a lot about racial-justice-focused stories, far more than anything else. I wish I could see that more around body politics, around reproductive justice, around gender identities and the attacks on trans people in our world. Audiences tend not to care as much about that, which is interesting to me. 

Does that data influence the types of stories you tell?

Yes and no. Data can inform, but it’s not definitive. There are times when all the metrics tell us that we shouldn’t do something, and we do it, and people love it. Data can inform a picture, but it’s not the entire picture. That’s where editorial instinct needs to come in. We might publish a story that only 10 people read, and then publish another story in that same realm, tweak an SEO headline or tweak a social headline, tweak a social image, and it can make the difference between a story performing well and not performing well. 

Sometimes a story’s success isn’t about the topic or the sources. It’s not the writers. Sometimes it’s completely out of your hands. Sometimes it’s algorithms. I think part of this is also figuring out distribution. How do you reach people? Being beholden to tech really sucks in that way, which is why YES! is really big on newsletters and direct-to-reader communication. 

Do you have a favorite type of story to tell or a favorite format to tell a story in? 

I love to tell stories in video format. I think that we’re in a time when we have to meet people where they are. I get asked quite a bit about combating disinformation. So often people are consuming things in video form, and they assume if they see it on TikTok or YouTube, that means it’s accurate. I think a solution to combat that is presenting things in video format that are fact checked, copy edited, and reviewed, and are taking on these big issues of the day in a format that is compatible with what people are looking for.

What’s your ideal future media landscape?

My ideal feature media landscape involves a lot of co-ops and a lot of worker-owned publications. Indie publications that are taking journalism back to its roots. One of the things that really gets my goat is everything being called “journalism” when it’s not. 

I think moving into those financial models where you’re not relying on advertising allows you to hold power to account. It also provides space for more people from marginalized communities to get into leadership roles because they don’t really have to play the same political games that you have to play at a legacy publication.

My future of media really takes seriously the purpose of informing and educating the public and doesn’t play footsie with fascists.

How can we take the steps to get to that future?

I think it’s really important to support your local news. They’re being bought by conglomerates. They’re being decimated. If there’s an alternative to a news source bought by a billionaire conglomerate in your local community, support them, because that’s where you’re going to get accurate, real information about what’s happening in your community.

We need to put pressure on legislators to start to control disinformation, whatever that could look like. We know that public television is owned and regulated by the federal government through the FCC. That should start to happen in digital media as well. 

And then support unions. Support the folks who are helping people secure jobs and build careers, especially in the digital media landscape. My biggest worry is how much brilliance journalism is going to lose because the financial models don’t allow people to have financial security and job security for long periods of time.

Bioneers readers have the opportunity to subscribe to YES! Magazine at a discounted rate. For just $5 (regularly priced at $24), you’ll receive four issues of their inspiring and solution-oriented magazine delivered straight to your door.

The Art of Storytelling: A Catalyst for Positive Transformation

What persuades us to take action in a world that desperately needs citizen involvement to solve some of its most pressing challenges?

Facts and statistics are available to us in abundance: Wildlife populations have decreased by 69% in the past 50 years. The wealth gap between America’s richest and poorer families more than doubled from 1989 to 2016. In 2021, women made up 47.4% of the workforce, but only 31.7% of top executive roles.

These data points are compelling, but research in many fields has long since concluded that humans are hard-wired for stories, regardless of the facts on the ground. As the author Margaret Atwood describes it, storytelling is, “built into the human plan. We come with it.”

Storytelling has the ability to succeed where facts often fail, creating an emotional connection to a cause or issue. There are real people and real lives connected to each of the data points above — the empathy created by their stories can spell the difference between action and indifference.

In this newsletter, we’ll dive into the transformative potential of storytelling and explore the ways in which stories can be used as tools for social and environmental justice. From personal narratives that inspire us to take action, to community-based storytelling initiatives that empower people to share their stories, we’ll examine the many ways in which storytelling can be a catalyst for change.


Want more news like this? Sign up for the Bioneers Pulse to receive the latest news from the Bioneers community straight to your inbox.


Rebecca Solnit | Not Too Late: Changing the Climate Story from Despair to Possibility

How do we imagine what’s possible, what matters? Who we are shapes what we do, and what we do in the present shapes the future. In addition to the many practical, scientific and material aspects, the climate crisis has cultural aspects with which we need to engage in order to meet this emergency. Drawing from the new anthology she co-edited, Not Too Late: Changing the Climate Story from Despair to Possibility, Rebecca Solnit talks about the stories emerging from what science, Indigenous leadership, good organizing, and visionary thinkers are giving us. These stories offer grounds for hope and the work hope does.

Watch Rebecca Solnit’s Presentation


Amara Ifeji | Storytelling for Social Change

Amara Ifeji mobilized a grassroots effort to address racism in her high school in Maine, at age 14. She also developed a love for the mountains and woods around her, but she saw her passions for the environment and racial justice as distinct until she heard youth of color like herself share their experiences working at this intersection and realized these struggles were completely intertwined. She shares how this awakening shaped her subsequent work as a remarkably effective organizer and advocate who centers storytelling to advance environmental justice, climate education, and outdoor learning for ALL youth.

Watch Amara Ifeji’s Presentation


Can Storytellers Help Change the World? From Fictional Narrative to Real World Change

In times of crisis, societies look to their storytellers to understand and process the challenges they face and to peek around corners to see pathways that purely rational analyses simply don’t reveal. Today, best-sellers in fiction and memoir are setting real-world information about the climate crisis, social justice movements, and migration realities within their narratives. Audiences are ready for these stories, but what about artists? Does the moment dictate the art? Join a conversation with leading writers about their creative process, how they consider the bigger local and global conversations as they craft their work, and the relationship between fictional narratives and real world movements for change.

Read the Conversation


Kim Stanley Robinson | What I’ve Learned since The Ministry for the Future Came Out in 2020

Kim Stanley Robinson is one of our greatest living science fiction writers. His more than 20 award-winning books over four decades, translated into some 26 languages, have included many highly influential, international bestselling tomes that brilliantly explore in a wide range of ways the great ecological, economic and socio-political crises facing our species, yet nothing had prepared him for the global explosion of interest in his visionary 2020 novel, The Ministry for the Future, which projects how a possible climate-disrupted future might unfold and how the world might respond meaningfully. It’s also chock full of brilliant science and wildly imaginative ways humanity steps up. Among other results, he was invited by the UN to speak at COP-26 in Glasgow. In this presentation, Stan offers us his overview of where we currently stand in relation to the climate crisis.

Watch Kim Stanley Robinson’s Presentation


Solutions Journalism within a Shaky Media Landscape: An Interview with Evette Dionne of YES! Media

We had the opportunity to sit down with Evette Dionne, YES! Media’s executive editor for nearly a year. YES! Media has been traversing the media’s choppy waters for 27 years. As an independent nonprofit publisher, the organization has consistently prided itself on publishing high-quality, solutions-focused journalism. YES! seeks to be a constructive part of essential conversations, and while it has managed to stay afloat without sacrificing its values, its success hasn’t come easily.

Read the article to see how you can subscribe to YES! Magazine at a discounted rate.

Read a Q&A with Evette Dionne of YES! Magazine


Bioneers Learning: Permaculture, Regenerative Design and Earth Repair for the Great Turning with Penny Livingston

Through engaging courses led by some of the world’s foremost movement leaders, the brand new Bioneers Learning platform equips engaged citizens and professionals like you with the knowledge, tools, resources and networks to initiate or deepen your engagement, leading to real change in your life and community.

Register now for a live course with Penny Livingston, “Permaculture, Regenerative Design and Earth Repair for the Great Turning,” to learn about the principles of permaculture, including how to work with natural systems, design for resilience, and create regenerative systems.

Register Now

Seasonality: Eating and Living in Rhythm with the Changing Seasons

Alice Waters started a culinary revolution based on local, organic food in season when she open the renown Chez Panisse restaurant in 1971. Her belief that “food is not just something to eat, but a way of life” lead her to found the Edible Schoolyard project in one school in Berkeley, CA. That project has spread to thousands of schools worldwide. In this excerpt from her latest book, We Are What We Eat: A Slow Food Manifesto, Waters explains how eating foods in season puts us in harmony with nature and awakens our innate attraction to ripeness and flavor.

Seasonality means eating and living in rhythm with the changing seasons. We are all aware of the seasons and their impact on our daily lives. But not many people understand what the seasons mean for our food supply. When we eat foods that are in season, we are connected with the local cycles of germination, growth, fruiting, death, decay, dormancy, and regeneration. Understanding the seasons teaches us patience and discernment and helps us determine where we are in time and space and how we can live in harmony with nature.

 In the very early days of Chez Panisse, I knew the importance of the flavor and freshness of our ingredients, but seasonality wasn’t uppermost in my mind. We’d have a chilled soup in the summer and a warm one in the winter, but we were more focused on following traditional recipes and figuring out what made a good menu. We had a different menu every day, but not strictly because of what was in season. It was more of an intellectual exercise: because we served only one fixed-­price menu in the early 1970s, we had to make sure it was interesting and different every evening so we could please the clientele. This was a big challenge. Back then, desserts were the arena where our cooking was more seasonally determined, though we weren’t consciously talking about it that way at first. It was more along the lines of “Oh, God, the fruits that came in aren’t good enough—we’d better make an almond tart instead.” The truth was, seasonality was an invisible force out there that we were grappling with every day, but we weren’t fully committed to understanding what it meant. At a certain point, instead of feeling limited by seasonality, we started to embrace it. We could focus on exactly what was ripe and perfect in that moment and surprise people with the taste of a fruit or a vegetable they didn’t expect. It invigorated our daily menu, which is now entirely inspired by the seasons. I can’t think of planning a menu any other way.

The shift to seasonal cooking at Chez Panisse came with our connection to the farmer Bob Cannard, and the aliveness of the food that came into the restaurant from his farm. In the late 1970s, my father and mother were tasked with the job of finding a local, sustainable farm to partner with the restaurant. We wanted a farm that we could rely on to provide a significant portion of the produce we needed every week. My parents visited at least twenty-­five farms in the area and ended up choosing one: Bob Cannard’s. When my dad first went out to Bob’s farm, he looked out onto the fields and couldn’t even see the lines of crops. What was Bob even growing? It looked like fields of weeds to my father, a man who had long prided himself on his immaculately mowed lawns and fastidiously weeded gardens. Then Bob took him on a walk through the fields, pushed the weeds aside, and unearthed a beautiful carrot that was unlike any other carrot my father had encountered. The taste of it was transcendent, and it changed my father’s entire outlook on business and agriculture.

When we started our work with Bob, we were disappointed that we couldn’t get things from his farm that we’d hoped to get all year round. We adapted quickly, because the ingredients we could get from him were so remarkable. Part of this was because of his semi-­coastal Sonoma microclimate; part was because he knew precisely which vegetables and fruits he could grow successfully at different times of the year. He would send us vegetables we didn’t even know were in season. Finding something in the winter like Bob’s carrots or chicories—which were so beautiful and flavorful—was an edible education. His ingredients made us realize that there were new and different flavors to be found, whatever season we were in.

Ripeness is the key to seasonality. There’s a subtlety to ripeness, and it takes discernment to know when something is ripe: the right amount of give to an avocado, the color of the shoulders of the Blenheim apricot, the scent of a passion fruit. You must look carefully, evaluate the flavors, and figure out the essence. I find that practice at the restaurant deeply stimulating, and I’ve gotten better and better at it over the years. It’s an exciting and educational process to understand different gradations of flavors. Discernment is not the same thing as judgment; it’s not merely This is good; this is bad. To understand ripeness, you have to learn through trial and error—you have to taste and taste again.

You really come to understand ripeness when you grow food yourself. People who farm or have fruit trees and vegetable gardens in their yards—or tomatoes or herbs on their fire escape—learn through experimentation, and after a few seasons they begin to figure it out. At the Edible Schoolyard, for example, the kids now know exactly when the raspberries and mulberries are ripe, because they’ve learned from exploration. Before they started school, they had no idea what a mulberry was! But when they come back to school in mid-August and go out for their first science class of the year in the garden, they go straight for the mulberries. Ripeness pulls them in every time.

People might think eating only what’s in season is unfeasible, or means denying ourselves foods we have grown accustomed to eating all year. We have been conditioned to expect the endless bounty of summer foods through every season, even though that’s simply not the way nature works. I say this all the time, but in truth, when all year long you eat those same second-­rate fruits and vegetables that have been flown in from the other side of the world or grown in industrial green‑houses, you can’t actually see them for what they are when they come into season, when they’re ripe and delicious. By that time, you’re already bored. You’re eating in a thoughtless way. Letting go of this constant availability doesn’t have to be restrictive. On the contrary. It’s about letting go of mediocrity. It is liberating.

Another argument I hear against seasonality is that we can’t possibly feed everyone on this planet if we have to survive on what’s locally grown. I don’t believe that. I’m convinced that using networks of small, local farms is the only way we actually can feed everyone sustainably. Yet I’m always told, “It’s all very well for you to talk about seasonality in Berkeley, but I live in Maine. We have a long winter. What am I supposed to eat?” I recognize the challenge. And it is true: in California, some fruits and vegetables do grow outside all winter long. Bob Cannard’s extraordinary farm is proof of that. We are lucky. But it is possible to eat seasonally in seemingly inhospitable climates. We are so unaccustomed to eating in season that we’ve forgotten the traditional ways people have preserved and cooked food. I am amazed by all the ways it is possible to capture seasonality: salting cod, curing ham, pickling cabbage or carrots or turnips, canning tomatoes or peaches—or cooking with all the heritage varieties of dried beans, lentils, pasta, rice, spices, nuts, and dried berries. As recently as sixty years ago, preserving was a skill that most families had. One of the few things I remember my mother did do in the kitchen while I was growing up was stock our New Jersey cellar for the winter with foods from our victory garden: winter squashes, canned rhubarb, applesauce. When you know how to cook and preserve foods, you can employ these ingredients in myriad ways. Freezing can also be used to capture a moment, as with stocks or fruit that can be made into smoothies and ice creams later in the year. Preserving food helps us all be less food insecure. And while I am completely devoted to seasonality and the primacy of localness, I do recognize the benefits of Carlo Petrini’s idea of “virtuous globalization”: buying coffee, tea, spices, chocolate, and other nonperishable goods from people in other countries who are using best farming and labor practices.

I am constantly inspired by other cultures and how they’ve eaten seasonally for centuries, whether in the mountains of Tibet or the deserts of Morocco. Living in the season is empowering—and there can be enough local food, even in the months when there are fewer fresh ingredients available. It’s possible to prepare yourself. You need to have cool places to store sweet potatoes and apples and nuts. You need to have the forethought to capture and preserve the bounty of the harvest when it’s at its peak.

Eating in season also challenges you to be inventive. I find I take much more care with ingredients when I’m eating seasonally. I’m more economical, too: I might candy the orange rinds instead of throwing them away, and I might make a broth using the green tops of vegetables and onion skins. I’m not as inclined to let things go to waste, because I know this is the one moment of the year to have that beautiful spring pea, or that September fig. I cherish it. The good news is there are also many ways to naturally extend the growing season. This is not the same thing as shipping food halfway around the world or building industrial greenhouses that rely on the use of pesticides. It’s a way of working creatively with our shifting seasons. We know from the farmer Eliot Coleman’s greenhouse operation in Maine, for example, that it’s possible to grow food organically all winter long. In Milwaukee, Will Allen is growing food on a massive scale right in the middle of the city, using green‑houses that are heated by the composted by‑products from local breweries. In cold climates, we absolutely need green‑houses where we can grow carrots and salad and herbs in a warm environment. One of the most extraordinary organic greenhouses I’ve ever encountered is at the Ballymaloe Cookery School, in Ireland; the sheer diversity of plants in it is staggering. It is an organic laboratory. They have taken the local agriculture around them and extended it through the winter. There are still limitations, of course—you cannot have a ripe cherry from a greenhouse in January—but your options can be expanded through skillful organic, regenerative growing practices. And it can happen all over the world