Toward a More Perfect Union: Unleashing the Promise in Us All with Angela Glover Blackwell

In this time of radical upheaval and change, fulfilling the promise of a “more perfect union” in the United States means building a multi-racial democracy through transformative solidarity. As the Founder-in-Residence at Policy Link, Professor Angela Glover Blackwell has spent decades advancing racial and economic equity at the national and local levels. She says the fate of the wealthiest nation on Earth depends on what happens to the very people who’ve been left behind.

Featuring

Angela Glover Blackwell, one of the nation’s most prominent, award-winning social justice advocates, is “Founder-in-Residence” at PolicyLink, the organization she started in 1999 to advance racial and economic equity that has long been a leading force in improving access and opportunity in such areas as health, housing, transportation, and infrastructure. The host of the “Radical Imagination” podcast and a professor at the Goldman School of Public Policy at UC Berkeley, Angela, before PolicyLink, served as Senior Vice President at The Rockefeller Foundation and founded the Urban Strategies Council. She serves on numerous boards and advisory councils, including the inaugural Community Advisory Council of the Federal Reserve and California’s Task Force on Business and Jobs Recovery.

Credits

  • Executive Producer: Kenny Ausubel
  • Written by: Kenny Ausubel
  • Senior Producer and Station Relations: Stephanie Welch
  • Program Engineer and Music Supervisor: Emily Harris
  • Producer: Teo Grossman
  • Host and Consulting Producer: Neil Harvey
  • Production Assistance: Anna Rubanova

This is an episode of the Bioneers: Revolution from the Heart of Nature series. Visit the radio and podcast homepage to find out how to hear the program on your local station and how to subscribe to the podcast

Subscribe to the Bioneers: Revolution from The Heart of Nature podcast


Transcript

Neil Harvey, Host: In this episode, Professor and policy advocate Angela Glover Blackwell shows how equity is good for everyone. In this time of radical upheaval and change, fulfilling the promise of a “more perfect union” in the United States means building a multi-racial democracy through transformative solidarity. The fate of the wealthiest nation on Earth is dependent on what happens to the very people who’ve been left behind.

I’m Neil Harvey. This is “Toward a More Perfect Union: Unleashing the Promise in Us All”.

Angela Glover Blackwell: I want to talk about how lucky we are to be alive, to be adults, to be in tuned, to be functioning right now, because this is the most amazing moment I have seen, that everything is on the table and causing us to have to think hard about things that we often pay very little attention to. 

Host: When professor and equity policy advocate Angela Glover Blackwell says everything is on the table, the context is that the tables are turning. 

When engineers prototype a machine, they run it at high speed and high stress to see what blows out – to find the flaws. These days, as Bob Dylan put it, “everything is broken.” What feels like a permanent five-alarm emergency is a civilizational stress test. 

Our institutions are woefully not designed to manage the scale, scope and complexity of the wicked problems that bedevil us. In most cases, they’re actually causing the crises.

We’re living through an epic time of radical transformation – of breakdown and breakthrough. It opens up the space for authentic metamorphosis. To paraphrase Carl Jung, there’s a “changing of the gods,” a reset of the basic values, principles, symbols and structures of civilization. Everything is on the table.

Angela Glover Blackwell believes that for the United States to fulfill its original democratic promise, it requires unleashing the promise in us all to create a more perfect union. She says there’s actually a whole lot of popular agreement on the issues that really matter, and the stress test is causing us to question everything, which is where this story starts.

She spoke at a Bioneers conference…

Angela Glover Blackwell: We have had to think hard about democracy, something that we just thought was there. We didn’t think that it could be given up, didn’t think that it could be seriously threatened, didn’t know how fragile it actually was, but we’re having to face that.

We’ve had to reflect on institutions that have always been around and we thought they always would be around. We thought that they function the way that they function because they had to. We didn’t realize how much of the functioning of our institutions was because of custom, because of respect, because of habit. We had no idea. 

We’ve had to think about all of these things, and we’re at a moment where history will look back, the future will look back, our ancestors will look back and they’ll say either that’s when they absolutely started on the road to getting it right, or that was the beginning of it all being lost. You are living through that moment, and we are not without agency. We are not without agency.

Host: As the Founder-in-Residence at Policy Link, Angela Glover Blackwell has spent decades advancing racial and economic equity at the national and local levels. That work has been a leading force in “lifting up what works” in sectors such as housing, transportation, infrastructure and public health.

When the Covid pandemic began convulsing society in early 2019, she saw how dramatically it laid bare what so many equity advocates had been highlighting for so very long: Public health was dangerously vulnerable because we were not investing in the health of us all.

Angela Glover Blackwell: It laid bare that what people had been saying about the baked-in nature of racism had just permeated throughout every institution, whether they were work institutions or educational institutions, or safety institutions. Whatever they might be, racism had been deeply embedded.

George Floyd’s murder caused us to have to face that. And part of the reason we faced it is because we all saw it. It was the first time in decades that we had had a moment like when the sit-ins were happening and everybody saw the SNCC and other young people being brutalized by the police, by dogs, by hoses, because we only had three channels. The same thing was on all the channels. Because we were all home and we were glued to our TV, we saw the murder of George Floyd over and over and over again. And whatever prejudice or bias or ignorance, we were taken into viewing it. It was clear what we were seeing, and there was no getting away from it.

It also was the time in which we saw that, for many people, racial superiority is more important than democracy, and that was a tough one. That was a tough one. But when we saw what happened on January 6th, there was no question that people were willing to sacrifice belief in a political voting system that really came to the conclusion that a multi-racial majority was putting someone into the White House. That was illegitimate in and of itself. 

So here we are with all of these things causing us to think, to study, to talk to our friends and neighbors and strangers about things that we never talked about before. And what we can do if we get it right is absolutely extraordinary, because we really cannot create a thriving multi-racial democracy if we don’t understand it, if we don’t know its history. We really cannot create a thriving multi-racial democracy if we don’t see the extraordinary asset that our difference is. It is so essential that we lay out a marker for where it is that we want to get to, and we develop a plan for how we’re going to get there.

Host: As the United States approaches its 250th anniversary since the July 4th 1776 Declaration of Independence, the nation faces a stark reckoning. Angela Glover Blackwell believes that fulfilling that founding promise of equal rights for everyone was aspirational. Now is the moment of truth to deliver on it. 

Angela Glover Blackwell: I think it’s going to really require us to be able to take our beautiful and exciting multi-racial coalition and realize that starting in this country, that that coalition is the natural heir of the framers of the nation when they sat down to form a more perfect union, to be able to do something that actually it’s taken me a little time to come to, and let me confess that. 

Because I will tell you as a black person growing up in this country, and I grew up in St. Louis, Missouri, I was not feeling it. I was not. I was not feeling it. Like what is the big deal about these founders? And then as I learned more about them and started reading their biographies, and hearing history that’s told in more honest ways, but I will tell you is I have studied democracy, and as I have studied those founding documents, it is clear to me that the framers punched way above their moral weight. They punched way above their moral weight. And once you realize that, you can accept extraordinary ideas, even if they come from people who were deeply flawed.

And so as I think about the… the opportunity that we have now, it is just so clear that what we’re going to have to do is own that we are the heirs to something that’s very special, and the work is really hard, because now we really can create a democracy that works for all.

Host: Like the concurrent French Revolution, the American Revolution resounded around the world with its vision of equal rights and democracy. It captured the world’s imagination of the possible.

Yet as powerful and catalytic as that narrative has been, the real history is way more complicated. Its burdens continue to haunt the nation, but Glover Blackwell says we must unearth it, learn from it and reconcile it. 

Angela Glover Blackwell: The United States of America is a nation that was founded on genocide for the purpose of stealing land, and human bondage for the purpose of slave labor. This theft of land and theft of labor is the basis upon which the country was built, and in order to be able to justify that, there was developed a hierarchy of human value, and that hierarchy of human value, not just justified, but it then got baked into every institution, that when you think about how it functioned, one of the things that is just starkly true when you think about it is that the dehumanizing relationship that formed the black/white paradigm during slavery, that dehumanized the slave and dehumanized the owner, created a paradigm that actually defined the way that oppression and repression would take place. 

And that black/white paradigm was defining, it was embedded, it is continuing, it is also inadequate to be able to fully understand the status of everybody who is oppressed. But everybody who was oppressed is oppressed within the context of that paradigm. So we have to go back and study that history and understand that history. We can’t go forward without it. It’s essential. I know it is uncomfortable. I know it is hard to talk about race. I know that just by lifting up the black/white paradigm it raises a million questions: What about what happened with Indigenous People and continues to happen? What about what happens to people who are Latinx and Asian? What about what happens to people with disabilities, who are transgender, people who are white and poor, all of the people who you can think of oppressed? How can I ignore that and lift up the black/white paradigm? Because the protocols of oppression were developed in that unnatural relationship, and we’ve got to face it. We’ve got to understand it. We have to analyze it. We have to see how it goes forward. 

But the next thing we have to do is that we have to understand that addressing these wrongs, while it is the right thing to do, it is the moral thing to do, it is the only way to be able to go forward; that if we don’t develop a way to be able to tap into the assets that are the people who make up the country, who make up the world, the country and the world will not flourish. They will not survive. They will not tap the resources that are needed. 

The fate of the nation is dependent on the very people who have been left behind.

Host: Angela Glover Blackwell points to the seismic demographics. Since 2012, the majority of all babies born are of color. By 2030, the majority of young workers will be of color. By 2044, the US population will be majority people of color. 

The tables are turning, but will they turn toward a more perfect union that unleashes the promise in us all? 

More when we return. I’m Neil Harvey. You’re listening to The Bioneers…

You can visit bioneers.org to subscribe to our newsletters and podcasts, check out Deep Dives on the topics that matter to you most, and learn about our conferences. That’s bioneers.org

Although the media and political narrative is that the US is hopelessly polarized and divided, a majority of polls consistently show that a vast majority of Americans strongly support the same goals: Universal healthcare, access to free education, a living wage, paid family leave, climate action, environmental protection and other policies and programs that invest in people, communities and the public good.

Yet next to nothing gets done. Why? Greedlock. As the musician Wynton Marsalis puts it, when it comes to holding the people in power accountable, “Keep your eyes on the cash register, not the people staging the fight in the store.” Again, Angela Glover Blackwell.

Angela Glover Blackwell: Economic greed is just having a heyday while the media is focusing people on all of their divisions, and the more they focus on them, the more people buy into them and figure like they have to take sides and where are they on it. And all the time, greed is just taking advantage of the fact that we are not asking our government and our regulatory systems to be able to make sure that our economy is working in a way that is fair. So, a really interesting way to think about what’s going on, and it’s really disturbing when you think of the role that the media has played in distracting the American people from the real issues.

It reminds me of a story that my friend Saru Jayaraman told me with One Fair Wage that they were having a demonstration in Washington, D.C. in front of the capitol, trying to really promote the Fight for 15, increasing the minimum wage. And across the street, there was a Trump demonstration in favor of Trump and talking about “making American great again”. And a couple of people from the MAGA demonstration came over to ask the people for One Fair Wage what it was that they were there for, and they said we’re trying to make sure that low-income workers can make more money, and they said, Oh, we want that. And the MAGA people picked up a couple of the posters and marched with them. Classic example of when you stop distracting people around these, what they call cultural issues, and talk about the bread and butter issues, the American people are not that far apart, no matter what their political persuasion.

Host: One catastrophically successful part of the political narrative since the 1960s has been the relentless, reactionary drumbeat that government itself is the problem, and we need less of it. 

In reality, the economic elites pounding that drum are just fine with big government – as long as its policies serve them: tax cuts for the wealthy, business deregulation, the privatization of just about everything, and cutting or terminating Social Security and Medicare.

In fact, there have been two times in modern history where bold government intervention radically improved the rights and livelihoods of Americans: Roosevelt’s New Deal and Lyndon Johnson’s Great Society and War on Poverty. 

Angela Glover Blackwell reminds us that those smart, strategic government policies can be life-changing for the vast majority of the population. And what’s good for the most vulnerable and marginalized turns out to be good for just about everyone.

Angela Glover Blackwell: In 1950, 56% of black people in America lived below the official poverty level. I’m not saying were low income, lived below the poverty level. By 1980, 30% did. And it was because of programs. It was because of Head Start, it was because of increased minimum wage, it was because of investment in cities, it was because of the youth education program. All these programs that came into place, it was because of Medicaid. I mean, it was Medicare. All of these programs that came during the Great Society cut poverty vastly, not just for people who were black, for the elderly. Elder poverty was a huge problem. But, you know, we had Social Security, but it took Medicaid to really be able to make the progress that needed to be made around healthcare. Those programs made a difference and it was, I think, Ronald Reagan who said we fought a war on poverty and poverty won. Not true. Not true. We fought a war on poverty, we were making progress, and then we gave in. And we stopped. 

The Vietnam War had a lot to do with it, but changing the administration to Nixon and these are the things that actually killed it because greed, again, got control of government. And when greed gets control of government, the first thing it does is convince the people that government is not your friend, we need to cut back government, we need to give that money to rich people. And that’s exactly what you do.

When you do a tax cut, you take the money from poor people, you give it to rich people. And somehow these politicians can talk the American people, at least some of them, into believing that that’s a good thing. We have so much suffering and inequality not because we don’t know what to do, we just don’t have the political will to do it. 

Host: Once again, keep your eye on the cash register, not the fake fight being staged on aisle one.

When Covid paralyzed the US economy, the Covid relief package not only helped out working people with life-saving checks. In just one year, the child tax credit cut child poverty in half. Despite overwhelming public support to continue the policy, the political class refused to spend the money. Call it the democracy deficit.

But, says Angela Glover Blackwell, there’s a deeper question: the foundational distinction between equity and equality. 

Angela Glover Blackwell: I first became familiar with the terms when I was the senior vice president of the Rockefeller Foundation, and they used equity in talking about their international development work, and equality in talking about their domestic civil rights work. And so I pulled people together and said, well, why are we using different language and what does it mean? And from the series of discussions we had, it became clear to me that equality was an input conversation that was really trying to focus on making sure that we were providing the same things for people without regard to race, or religion or gender. But that equity was an outcomes discussion. 

So when I started PolicyLink, I said I think we need to focus on equity, that we need to really 1) create a big tent that lets everybody who’s working for justice, whether they’re doing litigation or community development or education or healthcare, to understand that they’re part of the same thing – equity. And we needed to have a conversation that moved away from inputs, because clearly equality is an interesting and worthy goal. We’ve never done it, but just doing equality now after decades upon decade of inequality will not get us where we want. And that’s most obvious in the education arena. 

Equality in education means making sure that teachers have the same amount of training, that the kids are using similar textbooks, that they’re going to school the same amount of time. Equity says: we want to make sure all children achieve at high levels, graduate and go on and reach their full potential. And once you set that out as your goal, the inputs are bound to be different, because some children in communities where their parents have resources, where the communities are well-resourced, really all you need is a school that’s providing good education. But if you have children who are in communities where there are no recreational activities, where it is not safe to play on the streets, where parents are not coming home until very late, many parents have not had the education themselves to be able to read and do other things, that that is a different requirement that we need to have supplemental education, we need to have things in the community, teachers might need to be trained in a different way. 

And so equity asks: What do you want? And backs into what it’s going to take in order to get there. Equality focuses on making sure that the inputs are the same.

Host: As the author and policy expert Heather McGhee has said, “When we underinvest because of prejudice, everybody suffers. We need a ‘we’ to survive.”

As the United States comes full circle to its aspirational founding ideals, will the “we” in “We, the people” become decisively more inclusive? Will our ancestors look back on this moment as the beginning of it all being lost, or the beginning of moving toward authentic transformation? 

Angela Glover Blackwell: Equity creates more, not less. It’s just like you all have talked so much about love. Love creates more. The more you love, the more you have; the more you give, the more you get; the more you spread it, the more it exists. Equity is like that. It’s not a zero sum game. You invest in the people who are going to be the future, and the economy does better, the democracy works better, our neighborhoods are better, we’re safer in the places that we live. 

We need a solidarity that actually builds on what I have been just saying, that our future collectively is dependent on all of us being able to reach our full potential. That is the definition of equity – just and fair inclusion into a society in which all can participate, thrive, and reach their full potential.

What we really have to understand is that this kind of solidarity, which I call transformative solidarity, doesn’t have you thinking that I’m going to be your ally, but it’s asking you to be mine. It’s not that I’m going to help you, you’re going to help me, we’re going to do it together, because my survival is dependent on it. 

The problem with racism is not a problem for black people, it is a problem for the world, it is a problem for the nation. And so when we develop the story that is based on our history, when we make a commitment to achieving a world in which all can reach their full potential, equity, we understand that we do that because it is the right thing to do, but it is the only thing to do to be able to go forward. 

And the process of doing it is one in which we join with others. We embrace their realities. We understand that our difference is our strength, it is our very best asset that we have, that by embracing it we then are in a different kind of coalition, not one that just is for the close in, but one is for the way out. 

This is our moment. Everything is on the table, and it’s up to us to take advantage of it, to join together and to move forward, because we cannot unlock the promise of the nation, we cannot unlock the promise of our highest ideals until we unleash the promise in us all. Thank you. Thank you.

Announcing the Release of Indigeneity Conversations Podcast Season 1

Bioneers is proud to announce the release of the first season of its groundbreaking new podcast, Indigeneity Conversations. In a series of six thought-provoking episodes, hosts Cara Romero (Chemehuevi) and Alexis Bunten (Unangan/Yup’ik) — Bioneers Indigeneity Program Directors — engage in conversations with Native culture bearers, scholars, movement leaders, and non-Native allies on important issues and solutions in Indian Country.


Produced by Bioneers’ award-winning media team, Indigeneity Conversations explores compelling issues such as Indigenous Land Return, Cultural Appropriation, Rights of Nature, and other essential conversations that exemplify the essential leadership role that Indigenous cultures are playing in the effort to reshape and transform society’s relationship with the natural world while highlighting the contemporary lives, work, and experiences of Native Americans. 

The series also features excerpts from the Bioneers Indigenous Forum, a sovereign space and touchstone for Native leaders and non-Native allies to come together and form strategic alliances at our annual Bioneers Conference.

Season one of Indigeneity Conversations features:

  • Crystal Echo Hawk (Pawnee), President and CEO of IllumiNative and of Echo Hawk Consulting, in a discussion around transforming Indigenous stereotypes and the power of art to do so.
  • Casey Camp-Horinek (Ponca), talking about the burgeoning indigenous-led Rights of Nature movement.
  • Corrina Gould (Lisjan Ohlone), Co-Founder and Co-Director of the Sogorea Te’ Land Trust, in conversation about the genocide of California Indians and the importance of addressing that historical trauma, which caused deep wounds that still affect Indigenous Peoples today.
  • Julian Brave Noisecat (Canim Lake Band Tsq’escen), in an exploration of the importance of connection and relationship, to family, to history, to place, and to culture

The beautiful collage artwork for the Indigeneity Conversations Podcast Series werecreated in collaboration with the artist, Mer Young, a descendant of Chichimeca and Apache Tribe (Ndé). She is an Indigenous published multidisciplinary artist who has created a body of artwork manifested in collages, drawings, paintings, and founder of Mausi Murals public artworks. Young aims to inspire, celebrate and elevate repressed indigenous, first nations and native cultures and women of color.

We invite you to join the conversation, where we encourage everyone to decolonize and re-indigenize their hearts, minds, and actions.

Working Toward an Indigenized Future

The White House officially proclaimed October 11 as Indigenous Peoples’ Day in 2021. This decision to change the title of Columbus Day was an incredibly important move to shift public consciousness and address the ongoing genocide and erasure of Indigenous Peoples whose lands and resources were taken to make the country we all share today.

Our staff in the Native-led Bioneers Indigeneity Program have been personally impacted by the intergenerational effects of forced boarding schools and assimilation, the introduction of preventable diseases, displacement, and the hardly told stories of forced labor of Native peoples across the country. The following is a note from our Indigeneity Program Staff to the Bioneers Community:

“We are living in a time of deep uncertainty, but also hope for an indigenized future that our elders have taught us. They didn’t refer to the future we are shaping together as “decolonized” per se, but they recalled through oral history a time before planetary destruction due to colonial capitalism. And, they could imagine a time after it for all plants and animals to thrive on Mother Earth. The acknowledgment and celebration of Indigenous Peoples’ Day call attention to our collective histories and futures to celebrate the survival and futures of Indigenous Peoples, and all peoples.

We encourage everyone to take local actions to honor Indigenous Peoples’ Day 2022. This year, our Bioneers Indigeneity staff are excited to honor this day with our broader San Francisco Bay Area Native community. We will be bringing elders and youth together at Alcatraz on October 10 to honor and recognize those who fought for American Indian rights, for the ongoing recognition of Natives who are still here today, as well as the silenced voices of Indigenous, marginalized and war-torn peoples across the world.”

This week, we’re proud to announce the release of season one of our Indigeneity Conversations podcast. Learn more below, where you’ll also find stories from Indigenous leaders and ways you can take action to support Indigenous rights campaigns.

Sincerely,

Alexis Bunten (Unangan/Yup’ik) and Cara Romero (Chemehuevi) 
Bioneers Indigeneity Program Directors 

Headshot artwork by Mer Young.


Bioneers is proud to announce the release of the entire first season of its groundbreaking new podcast, Indigeneity Conversations. In a series of six thought-provoking episodes, hosts Cara Romero and Alexis Bunten — Bioneers Indigeneity Program Directors — engage in conversations with Native culture bearers, scholars, movement leaders, and non-Native allies on important issues and solutions in Indian Country.

Produced by Bioneers’ award-winning media team, Indigeneity Conversations explores compelling issues such as Indigenous Land Return, Cultural Appropriation, Rights of Nature, and other essential conversations that exemplify the essential leadership role that Indigenous cultures are playing in the effort to reshape and transform society’s relationship with the natural world while highlighting the contemporary lives, work, and experiences of Native Americans.

Season 1 features:

  • Crystal Echo Hawk (Pawnee)
  • Casey Camp-Horinek (Ponca)
  • Corrina Gould (Lisjan Ohlone)
  • Julian Brave Noisecat (Canim Lake Band Tsq’escen)


Support Our Creation of Season 2! Help us continue to produce Indigeneity Conversations for another season by supporting Bioneers.


Indigenous Eco-Nomics: Ancestors of the Future with Nick Estes

In this episode of the Bioneers: Revolution From the Heart of Nature podcast, Indigenous scholar and organizer Nick Estes explores how Indigenous land-based and Earth-centered societies are advancing regenerative solutions and campaigns to transform capitalism. “Eco-nomics” puts Indigenous leadership at the forefront of assuring a habitable planet.

Listen here.


Indigenous Pathways to a Regenerative Future

Indigenous Peoples already do “green jobs,” integrate cultural values into business activities, and protect 80% of the world’s remaining biodiversity. In order to transform our economies through Indigenous-led solutions, we need to uplift movements and stories inspired by Indigenous resistance. To do this, we must change the culture of philanthropy and “impact investing,” which still largely circulates in privileged circles. In this panel, Sikowis (Plains Cree/Saulteaux), Nick Estes (Lower Brule Sioux Tribe), and Alexis Bunten (Unangan/Yupik) discuss colonial-capitalism and how Indigenous-led strategies can offer us a pathway toward an equitable and regenerative future.

Watch here.


The Rights of Nature Movement in Indian Country and Beyond: From Grassroots to Mainstream

The “Rights of Nature” movement seeks to protect rivers, mountains, and entire ecosystems and the life forms supported within them by recognizing and enshrining their rights in formal legal codes and constitutions. This legal framework offers a radically different worldview from current legal premises. Instead of being seen as property, nature as a whole and its various components would be formally recognized to have inherent rights to exist, persist, flourish and evolve, and these would be protected under the law. For over 15 years, the Rights of Nature movement has caught fire across the U.S. and the rest of the world in some of the most and least expected places, from tribal lands to “progressive” cities, to coal country, to Latin American nations. In this session, some of the activist attorneys leading the movement in Indian Country and beyond update us on their successes and the challenges ahead. With: Frank Bibeau; Thomas Linzey; Samantha Skenandore. Moderated by Alexis Bunten.

Watch here.


Keepunumuk: Weeâchumun’s Thanksgiving Story

In this Wampanoag story told in a Native tradition, two children from the Mashpee Wampanoag tribe learn the story of Weeâchumun (corn) and the first Thanksgiving.

The Thanksgiving story that most Americans know celebrates the Pilgrims. But without members of the Wampanoag tribe who already lived on the land where the Pilgrims settled, the Pilgrims would never have made it through their first winter. And without Weeâchumun (corn), the Native people wouldn’t have helped.

Written by Bioneers’ Alexis Bunten along with Danielle Greendeer and Anthony Perryn, with illustrations by Garry Meeches Sr., this important picture book honors both the history and tradition that surrounds the story of the first Thanksgiving.

Get it here.


Bioneers Decolonization Series: What Is Decolonization?

In recent years, decolonization has become a buzzword in community organizing work. However, the political power that it holds can easily be robbed of its importance if we are not intentional with how we use it. Fostering informed intentional use of the concept first requires that we understand colonialism and history. 

So, what is decolonization? Following an interview with Alexis Bunten, we explore the Indigenous history, settler-colonialism and the meaning of decolonization.

Read more here.


Take Action This Indigenous Peoples’ Day:

The Rights of Nature Movement in Indian Country and Beyond: From Grassroots to Mainstream

The “Rights of Nature” movement seeks to protect rivers, mountains, and entire ecosystems and the life forms supported within them by recognizing and enshrining their rights in formal legal codes and constitutions. This legal framework offers a radically different worldview from current legal premises. Instead of being seen as property, nature as a whole and its various components would be formally recognized to have inherent rights to exist, persist, flourish and evolve, and these would be protected under the law. For over 15 years, the Rights of Nature movement has caught fire across the U.S. and the rest of the world in some of the most and least expected places, from tribal lands to “progressive” cities, to coal country, to Latin American nations. In this session, activist attorneys leading the movement in Indian Country and beyond give an update on their successes and the challenges ahead. With: Frank BibeauThomas LinzeySamantha Skenandore. Moderated by Alexis Bunten.

This talk was delivered at the 2022 Bioneers Conference.

PANELISTS

Frank Bibeau, an enrolled member of the Minnesota Chippewa Tribe, is an activist and tribal attorney who works extensively on Chippewa treaty and civil rights, sovereignty and water protection, including by serving as Executive Director for the 1855 Treaty Authority, representing the White Earth Band of Ojibwe and Honor the Earth (a Native-led, nonprofit environmental protection group), and litigating to stop Enbridge’s notorious Line 3 crude oil pipeline in Minnesota.

Thomas Alan Linzey, Esq. is Senior Legal Counsel for the Center for Democratic and Environmental Rights (CDER), an organization committed to advancing the legal rights of nature and environmental rights globally. Co-founder of the Community Environmental Legal Defense Fund (CELDF), Linzey is widely recognized as the founder of the contemporary “Community Rights” and “Rights of Nature” movements. He co-founded the Daniel Pennock Democracy School, which has trained over 5,000 lawyers, activists, and municipal officials, and is the author or co-author of several books, including: Be The Change: How to Get What You Want in Your CommunityWe the People: Stories from the Community Rights Movement in the United States; and the forthcoming Modern American Democracy and Other Fairy Tales.

Samantha Skenandore (Ho-Chunk/Oneida), Attorney/Of-Counsel at Quarles & Brady LLP, has vast knowledge and experience in working on matters involving on both federal Indian law and tribal law. Her extensive previous experience includes serving as a Tribal Attorney for the Ho-Chunk Nation Department of Justice and clerking for the U.S. Department of Justice’s Indian Resources Section. She currently advises tribal and corporate clients in tribal governance, governmental affairs, corporate transactions, real estate, labor issues and litigation.  Samantha represents clients before members of Congress, congressional committees and agencies through federal lobbying services.

Alexis Bunten, Ph.D., (Aleut/Yup’ik), Co-Director of Bioneers’ Indigeneity Program, has been a researcher, media-maker, manager, consultant, and curriculum developer for organizations including the Sealaska Heritage Institute, Alaska Native Heritage Center, and the FrameWorks Institute. She has published widely about Indigenous and environmental issues, and is the author of So, how long have you been Native?: Life as an Alaska Native Tour Guide

Indigenous Pathways to a Regenerative Future

Indigenous Peoples already do “green jobs,” integrate cultural values into business activities, and protect 80% of the world’s remaining biodiversity. In order to transform our economies through Indigenous-led solutions, we need to uplift movements and stories inspired by Indigenous resistance. To do this, we must change the culture of philanthropy and “impact investing,” which still largely circulates in privileged circles. In this panel, Sikowis (Plains Cree/Saulteaux), Nick Estes (Lower Brule Sioux Tribe), and Alexis Bunten (Unangan/Yupik) discuss colonial-capitalism and how Indigenous-led strategies can offer us a pathway towards an equitable and regenerative future.

This talk was delivered at the 2022 Bioneers Conference.

PANELISTS

Sikowis (aka Christine Nobiss) (Plains Cree/Saulteaux, George Gordon First Nation) grew up in Winnipeg but has been living in Iowa City for 16 years. She is the founder of the Great Plains Action Society, “a collective of Indigenous organizers of the Great Plains working to resist and Indigenize colonial institutions, ideologies, and behaviors.” She speaks, writes and organizes extensively on Indigenous rights, the climate crisis, environmental collapse and colonial capitalism.

Nick Estes, Ph.D. (Kul Wicasa/Lower Brule Sioux), is Assistant Professor of American Studies at the University of New Mexico and a member of the Oak Lake Writers Society, a group of Dakota, Nakota and Lakota writers. In 2014, he was a co-founder of The Red Nation in Albuquerque, NM, an organization dedicated to the liberation of Native people from capitalism and colonialism. He serves on its editorial collective and writes its bi-weekly newsletter. Nick Estes is also the author of: Our History Is the Future: Standing Rock Versus the Dakota Access Pipeline, and the Long Tradition of Indigenous Resistance.

Alexis Bunten, Ph.D., (Aleut/Yup’ik), Co-Director of Bioneers’ Indigeneity Program, has been a researcher, media-maker, manager, consultant, and curriculum developer for organizations including the Sealaska Heritage Institute, Alaska Native Heritage Center, and the FrameWorks Institute. She has published widely about Indigenous and environmental issues, and is the author of So, how long have you been Native?: Life as an Alaska Native Tour Guide.

Discovering the Real Nature of Water

The artist, activist, and teacher Betsy Damon has focused on virtually every aspect of water during the past four decades, from the essence of water drops to whole water systems and their connections to life on earth. Over the years, she has borne witness to the decline in water quality around the world as a result of human activities.

In the book Water Talks, Damon writes about our interdependence with water in every aspect of life, discussing many of the technical, social, and ethical issues we face and our individual and communal responsibility for addressing the immanent crises we are facing. As she states, “Ignoring water’s essential role as the connective tissue of all life on Earth is widespread. Unfortunately, the response to each environmental problem tends to be piecemeal—addressing one threat rather than responding with complex solutions that will address the underlying problems.”

The following is an excerpt from Water Talks.


It can be nearly impossible to even consider being without water. The very act of noticing something that we depend on every minute of every day can be so overwhelming that the off switch of the brain says, “Not now.” To consider water’s vital role in all life and the impact on our lives is another step. We will begin to notice water together. 

Each and every one of us has a water story, for we all live in a watery world. Like every human, I developed while floating in warm water, in the womb. I have a sense of floating in a warm, relaxing, and protected place where I was well-nourished. To this day, my body loves warm baths, hot tubs, and warm springs. My earliest memories are of sitting on the edge of the ocean, where waves gently lapped against the sand.

As I share a few stories of my relationship with water, you may begin to recall and tell your own.

When I was four, toward the end of World War II, my mother, brother, and I joined my father in Turkey, where he worked a nonarmy job during the war. From 1945 to 1948, we lived high in the hills outside Istanbul in a village called Rumeli Hisari. The Bosphorus, a big ribbon of salty, dark blue water that connects the Mediterranean Sea and the Black Sea, was always in view. One could see the tides rush up toward the Black Sea and back out again to the Mediterranean. As a six-year-old, I swam in that cold, salty water on hot summer days. With nervous excitement, I avoided the barnacles clinging to the rocky shore. I loved that rocky shore, where water-carved stones, seaweed clung to rocks, and bits of shells washed up.

Colorful boats with large sails speckled the waters as they ferried people across from the European side to the Asian side. Perched atop chimneys, large nests built by storks dotted the skyline. The storks were considered good luck, a blessing on the home. Their wide wings swooping through the sky and over the waters became a signal that all was well.

From the hills where we lived, I could see the skyline of Istanbul: glistening domes and tall minarets of mosques. Five times a day, calls for prayer reverberated over the hills and water and everyone from the farmers to wandering vendors lowered themselves to pray. Before entering a mosque, those who were going to pray dipped their fingers in the water. On every fountain and wall were beautifully patterned tiles.

The outdoors was my play space, beneath the pine trees and wisteria arbors, or sitting among the daisies, astors, and thistles in the vast meadow just outside our garden gate. Like many young people, my cherished objects were shells, stones, nuts, feathers, flowers pressed into books. Later in life, my studio was always filled with objects that I recycled into performances and sculptures.

After each day in my one-room schoolhouse, I walked home on a small path that ran through the hills to our yard. There, climbing into a fig tree, I would swing on the supple branches and sing at the top of my lungs. From that high place, I could see the Bosphorus, and would imagine swimming across her and walking to China. In the summers, freshwater shortages left us without water for weeks. We adapted by capturing rainwater in every container, filling bathtubs, pots, and pans. I vividly remember those precious pots of water; we used only what we needed to cook with, and to wash our hands and feet.

We returned to the U.S. in 1948, first to visit my grandmother in Belmont, Massachusetts. Her property contained a natural pond where a duck family returned every year to nest. During one visit, there was a geomancer—someone practicing earth divination— walking around seeking water on her property. He handed me the V-shaped stick, encouraging me to try it out. We walked around, and as we passed over some underground water, the divining rod flew out of my hands! This experience was astonishing; my mouth dropped open as I took in this mysterious energy.

We settled near Washington, D.C. Across the street from our front yard was a stream that would swell and over ow in big rainstorms, and then recede into a trickle. In the spring, tadpoles emerged at the edges of the stream and we’d scoop them up, place them in a small container, and watch as they became frogs, before returning them to their creek. Several years later, we moved to a house built on the edge of a wooded area with a creek running in the woods behind it. “Come on, guys,” I called out to my friends. “Let’s dam the creek to make a small pond!” There, rolling up our pants and tossing off our shoes, we floated a poorly made raft of branches and twigs that rapidly sank under our weight.

Gathering groups to work together was second nature for me, whether it was to build a dam, or to find a way to make swings in the woods. In the summers, we would escape the Washington, D.C. heat by traveling north to my great-grandmother’s home in the coastal town of Plymouth, Massachusetts. Vast woods surrounded her farm and gardens. My cousins and I swam in the salt water and roamed the beaches. We canoed in the Eel River estuaries among the cat-o-nine-tails, trying to catch turtles. We counted our time on the river with the tides, which rushed in and out. Being caught in an outbound tide would have dumped us in the ocean. Whether on the beach or in the estuaries, the tides determine the rhythm of the days. I would walk for hours, fascinated by the tidal waters, which cast up treasures and sculpted the sands.

On family trips across the United States, we drank from public water sources all along the way, and swam in water holes and streams. Today, it is unthinkable to drink from a stream or dip into a creek that you do not know. From the age of eighteen, I was privileged to be able to spend time at Squam Lake, a glacial lake at the base of New Hampshire’s White Mountains. Every summer, I sat under towering pines listening to the lake and the forest humming with life. The loons’ cries echoed across the waters at dawn and dusk. Diving into its cool, sweet surface refreshed me as nothing else could. I swam with loons, counted the baby ducks, and admired the old blue heron, a sentinel of the wetlands in which he fished. From a canoe, I peered at the leftovers of otters’ dinners, empty shells underwater or on rocks along the shore. Big storms darkened the skies while we rushed off the lake to safety on the shore. Late in summer, mists rose in spirals every morning, shimmering as the sun bounced off the drops. In the chilly dawn, I often forced myself to climb out of my warm bed to photograph these vortices spiraling away as the sun rose higher.

Although this lake has enjoyed the protection of some conservation laws, its water quality has declined with the increase of pollutants from new developments. In particular, fire retardants entered the waters, baby loons are rarely spotted, and fewer birds sing in the early morning. I was astonished to learn that fire retardants are manufactured into everything from clothing, to new furniture to building supplies. The chemicals were entering primarily from the new housing projects where, over time, they washed out into the land and lake. These highly toxic carcinogens are used without consideration for their impact.

A seven-week camping trip across the United States with my children in the summer would turn out to be significant in ways I never imagined. Where were the running rivers that I remembered? We encountered something unfamiliar: dry riverbeds. I knew I had never seen this on my past trips. Where were those cold streams rushing from the mountains into the lush meadows? How did so many rivers suddenly dry up? Where is the water? Those stones in the riverbeds had been washed and shaped by water for thousands of years. They reminded me of dinosaur bones found resting under a hot desert sun. At the time, I had no idea that extensive damming had dried up so many of the rivers. I imagined doing something to remind city people of the rivers that they might have forgotten, to restore their connection to their waters.

On this road trip, we unexpectedly—we were not searching for this—found our way to the first Sun Dance on the Navajo-Hopi Reservation. For four days, we witnessed the power of focused intention and prayer. We sang and drummed under a burning sun when a cloud appeared, spilling rain for five minutes out of the blue sky as the medicine man talked about the suffering of his people. The Sun Dance was a powerful, transformative experience, a specific ritual to strengthen the people and to experience suffering to gain compassion for those who are suffering. There was no separation between the dancers, the sky, the eagle, the drums, and us who chanted with them. Looking back, I realized that my vision to invite people to know about rivers originated in that experience. I cannot exactly explain how, except that it invited me to be immersed in the energies of the earth.

After returning to my loft in New York, I woke up each morning missing the trees, the simplicity of living on the earth, hearing the wind, and waking up to the dawn. This new consciousness showed up in the work that I began.

But first, to back up for a moment: Painting on canvas was my art until 1972. The sources of my new inquiries were my early morning walks with my three-year-old daughter and the feminist art movement; these worked together in not-so-obvious ways to inspire a change. I stepped out of the canvas and into public spaces with performance pieces that progressed from the personal 7000 Year Old Woman (1976) to installations such as Shrine for Everywoman at UN conferences in 1980, ’85, and ’90.

Breathing with Stones was first performed on the streets of SoHo and then in front of the American Museum of Natural History. Breathing with Stones evolved into Meditation with Stones for the Survival of the Planet at the SOHO20 Gallery every month at the full moon. Everyone who attended an event was both healed, and a healer. Participants brought their favorite stones to a full moon performance held monthly in a SoHo gallery.

We set a large blue circular cloth in the center of the room, around which everyone stood. After a gathering of energies, a small portion of the participants were invited to lie down, heads in the center. Those standing placed stones on the bodies of those lying down on the blue circle. When finished, we intoned a vocal sound over those with the stones on their bodies. Interestingly enough, participants never told each other where to place the stones, yet inevitably they placed stones where there was tension or pain.

To complete the event, each person was invited to think about the earth: what they loved about it and what they could do to save it. We ended with an invitation to place a stone in the center of the room, while stating an intention to protect or heal something on earth. This revealed that stones are powerful vehicles for healing imbued with their own energies. The wife of the famous Nigerian drummer Babatunde Olatunji passed by the gallery and asked about the event, astonished to encounter in SoHo something she did regularly in Nigeria.

I traveled with my bags of rocks to universities and performance spaces to create these healing events. One day, the stones seemed tired, so I returned them to the earth. These stone-based performance pieces were the beginning of my exploration of the energy available to everyone, present in every detail of the earth.

In October 1983, I was invited to lead A Meditation With Stones at a conference in Canada for four hundred people. Many participants shed tears as they carried their rock to the center, along with a promise: “I will ensure that the whales, wolves, and bees survive.” While at the conference, I met a group of papermakers who invited me to join them on a road trip to Edmonton, Canada. As we sped down the highway, I asked them, “If you could do anything, and time and money were not obstacles, what would you do?” After answering, they asked me the same question. I answered, “I can’t do it, but . . . I imagine making a paper casting of a dry riverbed.” The car came screeching to a halt at the side of the road, the people in the front seat turned around and said, “You can do that, and we will help you.” At this moment, I resolved to start writing grants to secure the necessary funding. Breathing with Stones for the Survival of the Planet (1983) led me into water.

“Until one is committed, there is hesitancy, the chance to draw back, always ineffectiveness.. . . Whatever you can do, or dream you can, begin it. Boldness has genius, power, and magic in it.” 

Goethe

Thanks to the director of the Framingham Museum, I received a new works grant from the Massachusetts Council of the Arts to create a piece for the Framingham Museum. Now I needed an accessible dry riverbed with nearby housing for up to ten people. Robyn Stein enthusiastically agreed to be the project manager. Right after returning from the UN World Conference on Women in Nairobi, we flew to Denver, rented a car, and drove through Colorado and New Mexico looking at every accessible dry riverbed. The landscape was spectacular, but suitable dry riverbeds with housing nearby were rare. Robyn’s friend Lucy Wallingford recommended Castle Creek, Near Moab, Utah. Indeed, in Castle Valley, Utah, we found the perfect riverbed. Castle Creek was dry and the right size, with abundant stones carved by water.

I rented a large van and picked up the team—Coco Gordon, Robyn Stein, Denise Amses, Regina Corritore, and Helmut Becker—at the airport in Denver. With my hands trembling on the wheel, we set out and drove over the mountain and down into Moab and the 36 miles to Castle Valley. There, a local real estate man gave us a large empty house in which we slept on mats on the floor and cooked with a few pots and pans. Ray Tomasso brought his papermaking equipment from Denver. We got up early to go to the site, where Helmut began to identify the plants that would be good to gather for papermaking. Under Helmut’s guidance, we pounded these plants with rocks to the rhythm of a dance. We broke down the fiber for boiling and converted it to paper. Meanwhile, the pulp had to be reconstituted by Ray. Ceremoniously, everyone lined up to support me through the first pour of the pulp onto the riverbed.

We quickly became a team, as if breathing in unison. I led the way, choosing the colors. Coco mixed the colors and for ten to twelve hours every day, Denise Amses, Regina Corritore, Robyn Stein, and Lucy Wallingford poured and patted liquid paper on every rock, bone, pebble, and bit of detritus in the dry bed. Pat Switzer followed us with her camera. We were framed by tall red mesas and yellow poplar trees.

A Hopi filmmaker, Victor Masayesva, was to join us to capture the process. I had neglected to tell Victor exactly where to find us—only that we were in Castle Valley. But sure enough, he appeared one day. When I asked him how he found us, he cryptically replied, “Finding whites in the land is easy.” It seemed that despite our best efforts to not disturb the land, not move a rock, and to use only biodegradable materials, none of us knew how to tread lightly on the earth.

One day, after hours of crouching over the riverbed, I stood to stretch my back and looked up. The sky was turning deep indigo and the stars of the Milky Way were beginning to appear, forming a pattern that resembled the pattern of the stones in the riverbed below. I thought, “The whole world is patterned by water, yet I know nothing about water.” At this moment, I knew I had to continue along my path in learning more about water.

The next day, an elderly resident of the valley told me that the Indigenous people called the Milky Way “the river of stones.” That made perfect sense and prompted me to make many large drawings of stars and stones. I was surprised to discover that nearby camping sites had signs warning people not to drink the water. Earth First!, an organization active in the area, told us that the ground and surface water was highly contaminated from mining and agriculture. In response to this shocking information, I changed the name of the piece from A Tribute to Rivers to A Memory of Clean Water.

Working so intimately in that valley with the riverbed, the stones, and the air, the mesa awakened something in me, a longing so deep that when people assumed I would go on to cast more riverbeds or other natural environments, I thought, why would I do that? Would that teach me about water?

A Memory of Clean Water became a traveling installation. I would load the 250 feet of riverbed casting in a van and drive it around to show at museums. It sparked interest in water among viewers. It seemed that most people had not thought about where their water came from or went, and had never heard of aquifers or the relationships between mining and polluted waters. “Now what?” I asked myself when I returned home to New York. Although I was expected to continue casting rivers in paper, that would not have answered my questions: How does water create everything in my world? How important is water quality to life? Above all, what were the stars telling me?

The stars told me that the world is patterned by water.

Following through on my decision to know water led me to attend conferences on water. I was looking for any indication that water was more than the three stages in the hydrologic cycle, more than just wastewater to be treated, more than just a resource to be transported around and sold.

Quietly, my dad was following my work. He picked up Sensitive Chaos: The Creation of Flowing Forms in Water and Air at a garage sale. This book contains the research work of Theodor Schwenk, anthroposophist, engineer, and pioneering water researcher. Schwenk founded the Institute of Flow Sciences at the Max Planck Institute in Herrischried, Germany. Once I discovered Schwenk’s work, I was on my way to discovering more and more about the real nature of water.

Excerpted with permission from Water Talks by Betsy Damon, published by Steiner Books (2022).

“Remembering Who We Are and Our Relations” with Julian Brave NoiseCat

In this episode, we speak with Julian Brave NoiseCat, a proud member of the Canim Lake Band Tsq’escen and a descendant of the Lil’Wat Nation of Mount Currie.

Julian Brave NoiseCat explores the importance of connection and relationship, to family, to history, to place and to culture, threading his own story throughout a larger narrative about the deep trauma Indigenous people have experienced through colonization and the resilience and power that is emerging as individuals, tribes and nations work to reclaim their own stories and landscapes.

Julian is a fellow of New America and the Type Media Center, Vice President of Policy & Strategy at Data for Progress as well as one of the first visiting fellows of the Center for Racial Justice at the University of Michigan’s Ford School of Public Policy. In 2021, NoiseCat was named on the Time 100 list of emerging leaders.

We begin with Julian’s keynote address at the Bioneers 2020 conference and follow with a heartfelt conversation hosted by Cara Romero.

A prolific, widely published Indigenous journalist, writer, activist and policy analyst, Julian Brave NoiseCat has become a highly influential figure in the coverage and analysis of Environmental Justice and Indigenous issues as well as of national and global political and economic trends and policies.

You can follow Julian on Twitter @jnoisecat.

Photograph by Dante Garcia

Resources

Julian Brave NoiseCat – Apocalypse Then & Now – Julian Brave NoiseCat, an activist and one of this era’s most brilliant emerging progressive journalists and thinkers, lays out the case for the moral imperative to assure that Indigenous voices have a central role in humanity’s struggle to address the existential climate crisis.

Indigenous Activism NOW: Talking Story With Clayton Thomas-Muller and Julian NoiseCat – Clayton Thomas-Muller and Julian Brave NoiseCat are nationally and internationally acclaimed Indigenous leaders in the fights against climate change and the accelerating, human-induced destruction of our ecosystems. When they aren’t on the front lines organizing movements to protect the planet, Clayton and Julian work as accomplished writers penning penetrating analyses of the connections between settler colonial capitalism, broken social and political systems, trauma, and environmental disaster. They also happen to have a deep friendship. In this intimate conversation, these two exemplary leaders share the story behind the story about how their lives intersect with their activism and discuss their new projects and their hopes for the future. Moderated by Alexis Bunten (Unangan/Yup’ik), Co-Director of the Bioneers Indigeneity Program.

The Indigenous Renaissance | Julian Brave Noisecat – The brilliant young writer, journalist and activist Julian Noisecat offers his insights into how, around the world, Indigenous peoples are rising in a global renaissance that holds untapped promise for a world in peril.

This is an episode of Indigeneity Conversations, a podcast series that features deep and engaging conversations with Native culture bearers, scholars, movement leaders, and non-Native allies on the most important issues and solutions in Indian Country. Bringing Indigenous voices to global conversations. Visit the Indigeneity Conversations homepage to learn more.

Credits

Executive Producer: Kenny Ausubel

Co-Hosts and Producers: Cara Romero and Alexis Bunten

Senior Producer: Stephanie Welch

Associate Producer and Program Engineer: Emily Harris

Consulting Producer: Teo Grossman

Studio Engineers: Brandon Pinard and Theo Badashi

Tech Support: Tyson Russell

This episode’s artwork features photography by Dauwila Harrison. Mer Young creates the series collage artwork.

Additional music provided by Nagamo.ca, connecting producers and content creators with Indigenous composers.


Transcript

ALEXIS BUNTEN: Hi, Everyone. Welcome to Indigeneity Conversations. I’m Alexis Bunten, co-host and also co-director of the Bioneers Indigeneity Program along with Cara Romero.

CARA ROMERO: Hi Everyone. Today we’re honored to be sharing an intimate conversation I had with Julian Brave NoiseCat, a member of the Canim Lake Band and descendant of the Lil’Wat Nation. Julian is a world renowned journalist who recently won the American Mosaic Journalism Prize for outstanding long form work that fosters greater understanding of underreported stories.

AB: Julian is a prolific, and widely published 28-year-old writer, activist and policy analyst. He’s become a highly influential figure in the coverage of Environmental Justice, Indigenous issues as well as broader political and economic trends and policies.

Julian is really a tour de force. He’s currently working on a book titled We Survived the Night. The book weaves together reportage on Indigenous peoples in the United States and Canada along with a personal narrative about his journey as a young man and writer. He’s also making a documentary that explores the links between colonization, genocide and ecocide. It follows Julian as he searches for unmarked graves at the Canadian residential school that his relatives were sent to.

CR: Our conversation offers insight into Julian’s personal stories that have brought him to where he is today, his philosophies behind the work, and our shared experiences.

First you’ll hear Julian’s keynote address at the 2021 Bioneers Virtual Conference, and then we move right into our conversation.

Here’s Julian…


Julian Brave NoiseCat: Weyt-kp xwexwéytep.

Julian Brave NoiseCat ren skwekwst. Ren kiké7ce te skwest re Alexandra Roddy ell ren Qeqe7tsé te skwest re Ed Archie NoiseCat. Secwecwepmc-ken ell St’itlimx-ken. Te Tsq’escen re tst7ekwen. Te Oakland re tst7ekwen.

Le7 ren pupsmen ne7elye tek tmícw w7ec re Piscataway-ulucw. Qweqwlut-ken te Bioneers. Te Coast Miwok ell Ohlone-ulucw re qw7éles.

Me7 peqíqlc-ken te Secwepemc-ulucw.

Pyin te sitq’t lexexyem-ken te necwepepl’qs re qelmucwúy ell re tmícw.

Good afternoon. I thought it would be most appropriate to start my keynote in my language, Secwepemctsin, which I was lucky enough to learn from my Kyé7e, that’s my grandmother. She’s the oldest person on the Canim Lake Indian Reserve, and one of our last remaining fluent speakers. When she was a little girl, a government official called an Indian agent took her and a bunch of other kids from Canim Lake away from their families on the back of a cattle truck to an Indian residential school called St. Joseph’s Mission. There, they were brutalized for speaking their language and taught to hate themselves for being Indian.

Earlier this year, 215 unmarked graves of Native children, some as young as 3, were discovered at the site of the Kamloops Indian residential school. My Kyé7e earned her nursing degree there. Not long after, 182 hidden burials were identified at a residential school in Cranbrook, British Columbia, then 751 in Maryville, Saskatchewan, 160 in Penelakut, British Columbia.

Across the continent, First Peoples are now searching for the bones of our young ones at the schools that were supposed to civilize us. Over the last four years, I’ve been journeying back to St. Joseph’s—excuse me, over the last four months, I’ve been journeying back to St. Joseph’s Mission in my people’s homelands where they’re using ground penetrating radar to find my Kyé7e friends, cousins and classmates who never came home.

When I was there in August, I interviewed a former Kukpí7 or Chief. He had never publicly spoken about the residential school and his origins, but on camera he told me he was the illegitimate child of the priest, the product of kidnap and rape. Even though he was the child of a white father, he was taken to a residential school with all the other Native kids, and like all the other Native kids, he was abused. When I was there, he told me, “We all were.”

After he shared his story, which ran more than three hours, I stepped out of his front door on the Sugar Cane Indian Reserve, ash was falling from the sky. Western Canada, the western United States, and really the whole world seemed ablaze. This summer, the Northwestern part of North America was gripped by a heat dome that set all time temperature records from Portland, Oregon to Port Smith in the Northwest Territories. As of mid-August, heat, wind, lightning, and humans sparked over 1500 wildfires in British Columbia. One small town, Lytton, where I have friends and relations, burned complete to the ground. It’s now little more than a grid of concrete foundations and scorched chimneys. The province of British Columbia, like many other jurisdictions, declared a state of emergency.

Now I’m currently working on my first book and a documentary, and in both of those projects, I’m thinking through the convergence of these apocalypses – the genocide of colonization and the ecocide of climate change. I’m trying to understand how Indigenous Peoples have persisted in the face of existential threats, because I believe that our survival ought to matter to more people than just ourselves, that it ought to matter to you.

I chose to begin my keynote in my language tonight because I wanted to show you that in our words, and in our very being, Indigenous Peoples are refusing to be annihilated.

In Secwepemctsin, I said who I am in relation to my kin, to my community, and to the places I come from because those things matter, not just to Indians, but to all people. At this dire juncture, with a pandemic engulfing humanity, and the concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere climbing to levels not seen in 3.6 million years, we all need to remember who we are, how we are related, where we come from, and how the other-than-human world, to which we are also related, gives us life.

Allow me to demonstrate. When I introduced myself, I said, “My name is Julian Brave Noisecat.” And that meant something, because NoiseCat or Newísket as the name was originally pronounced before the missionaries messed it up, it nearly died out. You see, at St. Joseph’s, the missionaries baptized us with Christian names. Before then, our people carried ancestral names and earned names, what you might know as Indian names, and we could take on many in a lifetime.

But as they were taking control of our lands, the government of Canada and the Church said that that would not do. Us Indians could not be plural, we could only be individuals. They said you Indians need one name so we can keep track of you, so we can confine you on reservations, count your dwindling numbers, and mark our control of your lives. They gave us names in their faith so they could save us from our supposed savagery. When stealing and destroying are called civilizing and enlightening, they can be justified.

In fact, they were so good at taking away names, that when she died, my great grandmother, Alice NoiseCat, was the last person to carry her name. Alice raised my father when her own parents were all messed up from the residential school could not. She was a hard worker. He remembers her towing him out on the family trapline in a sled made from an old car hood. They’d check all the traps, pulling frozen beaver and muskrats out of the water so they could sell their fur and feed their family. They didn’t have much, and hunger was common. But Alice, Alice was generous.

One time, she found a fresh apple, a hard thing to come by on the rez, even today, and she saved it for my dad because she knew he loved them. And then one night, in 1966, he remembers when she went out looking for her husband, Jacob, who was out drinking in a blizzard, and she froze to death.

After Alice was gone, there were no NoiseCats in the whole world until my father married, reclaimed her name, and passed it onto me.

Remember who you are. Be true to who you are. There’s power in that. But also remember that the power of identity is not individual, it’s plural, it’s collective.

The next thing I did when I introduced myself in my language was I put myself in relation to my family and my people. And here, I should acknowledge that praising boomers probably isn’t the wisest decision given the general state of things. As young people, we have certainly inherited far too many problems from our elders, climate change included.

But that said, I think it’s important to remember that we are not alone, that we have relatives, that we are, in fact, all related, and not just us humans. The other-than-human world shares some of our DNA too. If we remember that, maybe we will recognize that our fates are also interrelated.

Over the last five years, my father and I have participated in the tribal canoe journey. It’s an annual indigenous gathering on the West Coast, where tribal people organized into what are called canoe families, get into their ocean-going vessels, and paddle for days and even weeks across the seas. At the end of those voyages, we converge on a single community for a week-long celebration of food, gifts, speeches, dances, and songs.

My father wasn’t around for most of my childhood. He was struggling with alcoholism and the demons inherited from St. Joseph’s and the cycles of poverty, dysfunction and abuse it unleashed on Canim Lake. But the canoe journeys have brought us back together, and they helped us recognize the importance of family. You see, the beautiful thing about the canoe is that it quickly teaches you that if you want to go anywhere, you need other people, you need a family, you need to go together.

The K’omoks First Nation received over 50 canoes en route to Campbell River in British Columbia on the annual Tribal Canoe Journey. Photo by Julian Brave NoiseCat

Pulling alongside dozens of members of canoe families that welcomed us into their vessels with open arms, my father and I have traveled across international borders and hundreds of miles of ocean. We’ve made countless friends, learned dozens of new songs, and visited many magical places. We’ve been inspired. And in 2019, we were inspired to bring the canoe journey to Alcatraz Island. That year marked the 50th anniversary of the Alcatraz occupation, a 19-month protest for indigenous self-determination, sovereignty, and treaty rights.

I need you to understand how important the Alcatraz occupation was to Indigenous Peoples. It’s like our version of the Montgomery bus boycott. It launched a social movement that changed the hearts and minds of Native and non-Native people across the country and around the world. Alcatraz made Indians proud to be Indian again, and it transformed federal policy.

During the occupation, President Nixon, the frickin’ Watergate guy, shifted the federal government’s policy from an officially stated goal of termination to one of self-determination.

Working with our own canoe family, which we called the Occupied Canoe Family, my mother, father, and group of friends that included a youth worker and an Alcatraz occupation veteran, organized a paddle around Alcatraz Island on Indigenous Peoples Day in 2019. Eighteen canoes, including some from as far north as Canada, participated. Dozens of media outlets covered the story. A local TV station broadcast the canoes, circumnavigating the island from its traffic helicopter. Our little all-volunteer effort even made it into The New York Times. And for a day, Alcatraz was not seen as the former federal prison, but instead as a symbol of indigenous freedom, the way Native Peoples see it.

We can do a lot together when we recognize the fact that we need relatives, that we need family. Every time my father and I got out into the water, we rekindled and deepened our connection to the seas and places that gave us our Salish culture.

And in my introduction, I also told you where I come from. Canim Lake, called Tsq’escen in our language, and Oakland, the town by the Bay that raised me. I also acknowledged that today I’m speaking to you from Washington, DC, the homeland of the Piscataway people, and that you all in Marin are on the territory of the Coast Miwok and Ohlone. It was a very cosmopolitan land acknowledgement, one that in its head-splitting multiplicity demonstrated how our synthetic, Zoom-connected internet reality can dislocate us from a meaningful relationship to the places where we are.

I think that’s dangerous. Because if we don’t stop to remember and honor the places we come from and rely upon, how can we possibly defend them?

Earlier this year, I was asked to write an essay for the Paris Review celebrating the Kiowa author N. Scott Momaday, who was the First Native American to win the Pulitzer prize for fiction. While reporting that piece, I discovered that Momaday actually taught one of the original student leaders of the Alcatraz occupation. Her name was LaNada War Jack, and in 1968, she became the first Native American student at UC Berkeley.

Now, although Momaday never got involved with the Alcatraz occupation or the Native Rights movement, War Jack told me that his lectures influenced her profoundly. So in my reading, reporting and writing, I set out to understand the ethic at the core of his work, the worldview it grew out of, and the movements it continues to influence. Rereading his books, I noted a brief postscript in my 2010 edition of the Pulitzer prize-winning House Made of Dawn. It read: Both consciously and subconsciously, my writing has been deeply informed by the land with a sense of place. In some important way, place determines who and what we are.

I am Tsq’escenemc, a person from Canim Lake, a place we call “Broken Rock” in our language, but I am also a son of Oakland, a visitor in Washington, DC, and now a virtual guest at Bioneers. My connection to those places and others is also an imperative. It demands that I remember, honor, and protect those patches of Earth.

Now that we are in dialogue and relation, I believe that you are asked to do the same. You might be thinking that I sound exceptionally proud of being Indian, and I’m certainly guilty of that. But this, this is not mere identity politics. What I’m saying, what I’m thinking through in the book I’m writing and the film I’m making is that a broader humanity facing the apocalypse of climate change might have a thing or two to learn from a people who’ve lived the near total loss of our own worlds, that Indigenous Peoples have something important to say if you’re willing to give us an audience like you have given me today; that there might be even ways that our humanity and our collective future can be brightened if you have it in your heart to believe that the civilizing mission was wrong, that the St. Joseph’s missions of the worlds had it all backwards, that in fact, in the long run, it’s all of you that have something to learn from all of us; that maybe America, Canada and the so-called civilized world should become just a little bit more indigenous rather than the other way around.

The United Nations says that climate change is nothing less than code red for humanity. It is already brutalizing many of the places we come from and rely upon. It is driving us apart, making us forget that we are not just interconnected but interrelated. We are all kin. And if we’re not careful, climate change is going to make us forget who we are – animals of remarkable intellect, capable of immense care and compassion, even when grave injustice has laid us low.

So my message for you today is simple: Remember who you are. Remember that you have many relatives, human and non-human. And remember that we all come from somewhere, and that those places, and the place called Earth, need us to fight for them.


CR: Julian, thank you so much. Your keynote delivery was stunning and heartbreaking, and I listened to every single word that fell from your mouth. So I just wanted to start our Q&A by saying thank you for your generosity and your many gifts that you share in this world.

I am interviewing you today from Oga Po’geh, from Santa Fe, the land of the Keres, Tewa, Tiwa, and Towa speaking peoples, also known as the Northern Pueblos. And in honor of your keynote, my bones are from the Mojave Desert. From the heart of the Mojave Desert along the California side of the Colorado River is where I’m from, and married into Cochiti Pueblo here, and like you, am a fierce defender of our cultural landscapes, and believe in the re-indigenization of people and the power of place.

I feel so grounded after your keynote, and loved the flow and the circular thinking. It really provided this comfortable feeling for me in the way that we speak of things and have an understanding of interconnectedness, an interconnectedness of kinship and of place and of where we come from.

I wanted to start out by asking you a little bit more, Julian, about where you’re from, about who your mom is. I have this deep sense that she must have been a very amazing person or that she is a very amazing person. Can you tell me a little bit about your mom?

JBNC: Yeah. Well, firstly, thank you for that really generous response to what I had to say and it’s very difficult for me to talk about my mom in part because I feel like I’m so close to her and have just been so lucky to be surrounded by her love my whole life, that it’s hard for me to have the kind of distanced lens, a certain kind of perspective. I find, as a writer, you can’t be so far away from something that you can’t see it, but when you’re so close to something in the way that I feel so close to my mom, I actually have a really hard time writing about and talking about her because like it’s—she’s just kind of everything to me.

Julian Brave NoiseCat with his mother Alexandra Roddy. Photo courtesy of Julian Brave NoiseCat

And I guess I should say that my father is Secwepemc and St’at’imc, like I said, from British Columbia, Canada. My mom is actually an Irish-Jewish New Yorker. They met in a bar called the Shadow Brook just outside of New York City. It’s like I’ve kind of dreamt this scene up as a—maybe a scene from a film or a novel before. Apparently my dad gave her the earrings out of his ears. It’s like, kind of how they got acquainted, and she was the bartender at the bar. So she gave him free drinks for the whole night.

And I guess what I would say is that my mother, even though she’s non-Native, made a lot of very instinctual and purposeful decisions to make sure that as a kid who looks the way I look and is connected to the community that I’m connected from, that I maintained that relationship. So she, from a very young age, before my parents actually split up, she would take me down to the Intertribal Friendship House, which is the third oldest urban Indian community center in the country. It’s on International Boulevard in Oakland, California. I’d go there for drum and dance practice every Thursday night.

And then very bravely, actually, she started taking me home to my family’s rez to visit my relatives, to visit my grandparents, my cousins, my aunts, my uncles which back in the day before Google maps and everything, like, it’s a really remote part of the world to get to from California, and she made that effort, despite the fact that she was not blood-related to them. But now she is sort of considered an auntie and a sister and a relative to my family, which reflects on the really loving decisions she made for me as a mom, but also I think on the ways that Native people can be very open and loving in the ways that we make and support relatives. She’s fully part of that family and community now, and I think that that’s a really incredible and beautiful thing, and has made it a lot easier for me coming from the kind of childhood situation and home where my dad was not in the picture for a lot of my upbringing to maintain something that at the end of the day has become incredibly important to me and sustaining to me in a way that sometimes it’s hard to find the words to capture.

CR: Well, thank you for your vulnerability. And I often find as I share and the more vulnerable we are with our upbringings, that you make me feel less alone and hopefully you connect with other young Native people. I hail from a very similar background with a single mom and absent Native father going through all of the things that you described. And I do know your father, and love him, and love the genius of his artwork. And in getting to know you, love to see the genius inherited and your art form being writing. And I have such a deep respect, as do so many of us, for your giftedness in writing, and was hoping that you would talk a little bit about learning that that was your gift and that that was your art growing up. Can you talk a little bit about your journey to becoming a writer, and maybe when you knew?

JBNC: I’m still not sure if I’m a writer. [LAUGHTER] Like I think I need to write at least one book before they let me call myself that.

So you brought up my dad, and I’ve had a complicated relationship with my father, but we’re good now, in part because of the canoe journeys, and I just think time can really heal some wounds. And I guess what I would say is that some of my earliest memories growing up were hanging out in his studio watching him carve, sitting in the back of his purple powwow van going to all sorts of Indian art shows, Indian Art Northwest in Portland and all sorts of different shows in random places across North America.

And I think my dad had designs on making me into like his apprentice. There’s a thing in the Native art world, especially with families that make art, and dads whose sons also go on to become artists, particularly among carvers. There’s carving families in the Northwest. And I think that that’s kind of maybe originally what he thought I was going to become, and then we obviously didn’t end up spending that much time together after I was a certain age.

And then the way that I guess I started to fill that void was by trying to read and learn and understand, through other people’s stories, through novels, through history, who my dad was; who this absence in my life was, and who our people were. I obviously knew that through him and through my relationship to my family, but there was a whole world of literature and artistic interpretation of what it means to be indigenous out there that opened up to me when I started reading people like Leslie Marmon Silko and Sherman Alexie, despite how complicated it is for me to say that now, Louise Erdrich, etc. I started sort of emulating the way that they wrote short stories.

And then I just kind of kept at it. The reality of the media industry did not seem to make writing and journalism to be a sensible economic decision for me, but I just kept doing it, and eventually I stumbled into an idea for a book, and I kept getting published, and eventually I was very fortunate to get a book contract.

And in the process of doing all that, I guess this is sort of a long story, but I started to think about my craft as a writer, my art as a writer, in relation to my father’s craft as a carver and as a sculptor. And I do non-fiction. And what’s interesting about non-fiction in relation to carving and sculpting is that essentially in both art forms, you go out into the world and you gather material. My dad carves wood. So he goes and gets his logs and things to carve into various pieces. And to a large extent you’re limited in both carving and non-fiction writing by the material that you go out and gather in the world.

As a non-fiction writer, I’m not at liberty to make things up as they come to me in my mind, I have to go out and report them and gather them up, and then I can shape them down into the art form of the piece that I want to make. And so what I’ve kind of found is that even though I never conceptualized myself as sort of following in my father’s footsteps to become the sculptor that he wanted me to become, in a certain way I actually did end up following him down that road, at least conceptually and in the form of art and writing that I produce, and that that actually has now started to bring us together.

So we are now, over 25 years later, in the situation where we hang out. I interview him quite a bit for the book I’m working on, and talk about our art. He talks about the things that he’s writing on and we sort of bat ideas back and forth about things that we could make together, and at the same time I get his input on the pieces that I’m writing. So in a way, writing and art has always been and is now becoming very clear to me sort of a way of reconnecting to and processing my relationship to my father, and ultimately has actually kind of made me an artist in a way that’s not that different from his life as an artist.

CR: Well, you are telling such a powerful story with your art. As a Native person to another Native person, the complexity and the difficulty with the things that we have and need to communicate, it’s just a joy to read your writing and to listen to you speak. So I can’t wait to read your book and know more about your movie that you’re making. Can you share a little bit more about both of those things?

JBNC: Yeah. For sure. So my book is called We Survived the Night. The title is derived from the traditional word for good morning in my people’s language. It’s Tsecwínucw-k and it doesn’t actually translate to good morning. If you literally translate what it means, it means you made it through the night, or you survived the night. So the book sort of is going to begin with a little bit of reflection on what it must have meant for my people, my ancestors to say that to each other in the mornings after the children were taken to the residential schools, and the mornings after.

We learned that our land had been settled and taken from us without any sort of treaty or recompense by colonists. The mornings after, people died in our pithouses by the dozens, which is something that happened in 1862 and 1863. And then it sort of—The way that I think about it is that it’s a – in our language we call it lexey’em, which is like a kind of story that is not about the spiritual beings in the spiritual world, which is to say that it’s an account of both my sort of family and personal history as well as of the things that I’ve gotten to go out and report on in Indian Country in the United States and Canada and a few other places, and essentially what the story of Indigenous Peoples in North America is today.

So it’s divided into three thematic parts. The first is called Apocalypse. It’s about Indigenous Peoples as post-apocalyptic peoples, as people who survived the loss and destruction of our worlds. The second section is called Odyssey, and it’s about Indigenous Peoples journeying to, return to, and reclaim and remake our home and homelands. And then the third section is called Trickster, and it’s about Indigenous Peoples navigating the seams and contradictions between indigenous worlds and communities and forms of governance, and colonial worlds and institutions and politics.

The film—it’s a documentary, and it’s following the search for unmarked graves at the residential school, St. Joseph’s Mission, that my family was sent to, which is an ongoing search. So I’m working on that at the same time as I’m writing the book.

Photo by Emily Kassie

CR: It’s such a powerful development, this uncovering of what we’ve known for so long that has happened at the residential boarding schools. And I really look forward to the telling from indigenous perspective in both the book and the film.

Just an aside, it was about 15 years ago, our tribe is known for our funeral rites, that they bring in the Chemehuevis and the Southern Paiutes to help the spirit go to the other side, as well as to help the bereaved. And we had several singers go along the Salt Song Trail and go and conduct ceremony at Carlisle and at Sherman, and at several of the schools here in the United States where we hold those stories, where we know that the children never came home, and the stories of desperation of parents looking for their children.

And so the Salt Singers gave the children ceremony so that their spirits could be released, and that we could have some sort of closure. You know, it’s going to be a very heartbreaking path as we learn and share these stories, and hopefully find closure and some sort of ceremony, and bring children home. So self-care is very important. And so I wish you and everyone that is part of this movement blessings and self-care along your journey. And what you’re doing is really important.

I wanted to talk a little bit about your work as the vice president of policy and strategy at Data for Progress. And can you talk a little bit about transitioning into this work and the importance of data? And a little bit more about your behind-the-scenes work in Washington, and being a citizen activist.

JBNC: Yeah. Well, first I just want to say thank you for sharing the story of the Salt Song Trail, and the bringing home of the—of your people’s children. I think that so many different nations and communities are doing that work right now, and it’s incredibly heavy, heavy work. Every time I come back from Williams Lake, I have trouble getting out of bed for like two or three days.

And yeah, so I just think that it’s important to acknowledge and think about, take care of ourselves and each other, and support all the people who are going through the process of telling the truth to a broader public who seems to be listening, maybe for the first time, to a lot of these stories, and seeking justice and accountability to the people who did this, and trying to restore a sense of dignity and wholeness and healing to so many families and people who were so deeply harmed and I mean, it’s just—it makes me sick and angry whenever I think about it.

So I never really worked full time as a writer until now, my primary career was in the sort of nonprofit, activist think tank kind of space. So a few years ago, a friend of mine named Sean McElwee invited me to become the first employee at a think tank he was creating called Data for Progress. And at that think tank I focused on and still am quite focused on climate change policy and public opinion research, as well as advocacy for more progressive climate solutions and legislative interventions and regulations and those sorts of things.

And essentially it was a start-up, and while I was there we grew from the two of us to now Data for Progress employs over 20 people, which was a really cool thing to be a part of. I also got to get pretty involved behind the scenes in a number of campaigns that actually did see, it seems, to have some real world policy impact. I think I was the first, for example, to put out the idea that Deb Haaland should be the Secretary of Interior, and through a sort of a public relations insider/outsider, online and sort of advocacy campaign, we ended up actually winning that push to make her the first ever Native American cabinet secretary. She’s obviously now the Secretary of the Interior. And the ability to do that was in large part because of my role and my freedom at the think tank Data for Progress. So I’m really, really grateful for that, and really grateful for everyone who I worked with who also played really important roles in helping make that happen.

You know, I think essentially data is both a way to understand what’s really going on out in the world. Right, like, there’s a lot of bad data, but if you have data that’s collected in ways that are sound social science, sound data science, you can get a more accurate representation of, for example, what people actually think about issues like climate change, and then you can use that to inform realistic and pragmatic strategies to actually act on and transform the world that exists, which is, I think, sort of the role of activism and advocacy.

But also I think it’s important to understand that data can be—itself can be used as a tool. Right? So if you have information about the views of voters of the public on a particular issue, that can then persuade an elected official, a politician, a political party to behave in different ways. That is one way in which you can make democracy actually more responsive and more progressive and active on issues related to climate change.

And so working in DC and working in this sort of think tank, activist/advocacy space the last four years, I’ve learned how all of that actually happens and works, and sometimes doesn’t work, and in a way I think it’s actually made me better at writing and understanding things like politics and policy and understanding the ways that political actors actually make decisions, and the ways that they might be persuaded to make different and better political decisions, which I think at the end of the day, if you care about a lot of these things, that is pretty important knowledge and information.

CR: I think, definitely, understanding as much as you can about how to affect change politically, and then you have that other really sound piece of being able to influence public opinion. And I think that that is a combination of what you’re talking about, that solid data.

And then art, you know. I mean, I’m just such a believer in the power of art. So to be able to combine your art form to influence people and public opinion is really important. And I think I’m saying that for the young Native people out there that are listening; that, I know I come from a platform of encouraging citizen activism, that no person is without power to affect change.

Do you want to speak to that a little bit, as well? Because I just think that you’re such a wonderful example of making big change as one person.

JBNC: I got the opportunity to learn from and work with lots of other people who understood and knew about things in ways that I did not yet, especially when I was younger, and earlier on in my career, and that, at the most basic level, working together collectively and collaboratively, that’s what politics and democracy are. It’s about groups of people with ideas and values, about how we should govern ourselves, trying to convince as many people in society that that’s actually the best, most just, most equitable, most prosperous way to arrange things for the greatest number of people.

That world, the political world, can be a very brutal one. It’s one where lots of hopes and dreams die in the sort of a meat grinder of Congress and electoral politics and those sorts of things. But that once in a while, the right people, the right ideas, and the right sort of, I don’t know, I think moral relationship to how we should be relating to each other as humans can come around and the right things can happen, and especially can happen when we find common ground and figure out ways to work together, and figure out ways to convince other people that we’ve got some good ideas and they ought to throw their lot in with us rather than the cynics and the bigots and the people who would rather see the world burn.

And in the context of climate change, which is essentially the largest collective action problem of them all, right, it implicates not just every American but every single person in the world, and every society in the world in the epic task of reducing emissions and adapting to a warmer planet. I think that that’s kind of our only option, is to figure out how to make these systems, these democratic systems – as long as they’re democratic, by the way, because they might not always be democratic, you know, work in our favor. And so I would encourage any young person who is interested in that part of how society works to just go for it and be willing to learn and to collaborate and work with other people, because we need as many people in this fight as we can get.

CR: And I would add to that that as we foster young leaders to listen to your keynote and listen to the messaging of understanding indigenous issues and the way that you beautifully illustrate the connection between the genocide of Indigenous Peoples, the First Peoples of place, and as that relates and correlates with ecocide. You have to look at that connection. We have to scream it from the hilltops so that people understand that in order to rebuild and find solutions, you’re not going to be able to do that without that spiritual interdependence that Native Peoples have with each other and with their landscapes, and with their bioregions.

Thank you, Julian, for sharing with us and for being so generous with me today during this Q&A.

JBNC: Well, I just want to say a big Kukwstsemc. Thank you very, very much.

It’s hard to grow up inheriting all the things that we inherit intergenerationally as Native Peoples, but I also think it’s really important to remember that there are incredibly powerful, beautiful and important things that we also inherit. It’s not just the shit that they did to us at the residential schools. There’s a lot more there that is worth learning and fighting for, and taking up.

I would especially encourage the young Native People who see this to be part of that long line of fighters and ancestors who are going to try to bring us back to who we were, because it was a beautiful way, I think.

CR: [words in her language], Julian. Thank you so much.


AB: That was a great conversation with Julian, Cara. Keep an eye out for the book and documentary coming out in the next year or so. Again, the book is titled, We Survived the Night. And you can follow Julian on Twitter for more details about the book and documentary, as well as his regular political analysis.

And to hear other episodes of Indigeneity Conversations, and hear and see more from Julian Brave NoiseCat, visit our podcast page at Bioneers.org.

CR: You can find other original Indigenous media content there, and learn about the Indigeneity program and our initiatives, including curricula and materials for students and life-long learners. Thank you so much for joining us for this episode of Indigeneity Conversations. It’s been a pleasure to share with you today. Many thanks and take care!


Sign up to stay connected for new episodes!

Great Lakes Bioneers Detroit Conference – October 14-15, 2022

Bioneers is excited to highlight an upcoming partner event, the Great Lakes Bioneers Detroit conference, which will be held on October 14-15, 2022 at University of Detroit Mercy. The 17th annual regional conference is a Pollinators event in partnership with the national Bioneers organization.

The Great Lakes Detroit Bioneers Conference has been a longtime feature of the progressive community in Detroit. This year the conference features twenty sponsors and partners organizations, suggesting a truly community supported event. The lead organizers have announced that the conference theme this year is: “Earth is our Mentor, Measure and Model.”

Nick Schroeck, Detroit Mercy associate dean of Experiential Education, associate professor of Law and conference co-chair, said that Earth, “is our model, measure and mentor as we work toward a sustainable, racially equitable, inclusive community that fosters life-giving relationships, nurtures connections, and celebrates solutions for restoring and healing. We hope this conference offers an opportunity for the community to share experiences and strategies to ensure that humans are a positive force in our earth community while addressing the critical issues of environmental degradation, systemic racism and health disparities.”

This year’s conference is particularly noteworthy, given the dramatic changes in the environment taking place throughout the world. Features and speakers of this year’s conference include leading figures from the region like Naim Edwards, the director of Michigan State University’s first urban agriculture center, the Detroit Partnership for Food, Learning and Innovation. Other speakers of note include Nina Ignaczak, the founder and editor of Planet Detroit, and Luther Keith, executive director of ARISE Detroit!, and former GLBD conference Co-Chair Sr. Gloria Rivera.

Sr. Gloria Rivera

“This conference is a great way for the University community to collaborate with community organizations in line with our Jesuit and Mercy mission to care for the Earth, our common home,” explained Gail Presbey, professor of Philosophy, director of the Carney Latin American Solidarity Archive and one of the conference co-chairs, “Thanks to generous grants from the Sisters of Mercy of the Americas, the Congregation of St. Joseph and the Fund for Equal Justice, we’re able to lower registration prices. Youth aged 12-18 can attend for a day for just $5 when accompanied by a parent or their teacher. Seniors and activists also receive discounts. No one is turned away, because volunteers can attend for free, if they offer two hours of service for each day of the conference,”

In addition to an opportunity to view the 2022 national Bioneers keynote addresses in community with other attendees, the conference offers extensive and inspiring tours, learnshops and panels. Tours cover community urban garden projects in southeast and northwest Detroit, wastewater recycling, solar projects, as well as an environmental justice tour of key sites of pollution and environmental regeneration in Detroit..

To learn more about Great Lakes Bioneers and to register for this local event please click here or download the conference program here.

We can (and MUST) protect the Amazon

The lungs of the planet, cycling one fifth of the world’s oxygen. Home to one in ten of the world’s known species of life, with hundreds of new species discovered annually. Host to half of the world’s tropical forests and twenty percent of the flowing freshwater on earth. Stewarded by an estimated 500+ Indigenous nations. One quarter of the world’s total forest carbon sink, storing more than 150 billion metric tons of carbon. Key driver of global hydrology, releasing twenty billion tons of moisture into the atmosphere daily.

Try as one might, it’s difficult to speak in hyperbole about the Amazon. Its incredible biodiversity and scale are truly hard to fathom, but, as we know all too well, these essential ecological systems and the human cultures in the Amazon are facing existential threats. We have been talking about “Saving the Amazon” for decades while the forest continues to be destroyed. Despite the dire circumstances, Indigenous leaders, with support from allies around the world, are making significant strides toward protecting their sacred lands and the threatened ecosystems upon which the entire planet’s climatic stability depends.

This week, we’re featuring ideas, research, and action steps you can take from world-renowned Amazon protectors, including Helena and Nina Gualinga, Atossa Soltani, and Nemonte Nenquimo.


Want more news like this? Sign up for the Bioneers Pulse newsletter to receive the latest stories from our community straight to your inbox.


Helena and Nina Gualinga – #EndAmazonCrude: A Call to Action with Amazonian Indigenous Forest Protectors

California is the world’s largest consumer of oil from the Amazon rainforest. This extraction contributes to climate change, causes deforestation, toxifies watersheds and  ecosystems, displaces the Indigenous peoples who are the best stewards of the Amazon Forest’s remaining biodiversity, and harms people at every end of the supply chain, including the marginalized communities living in the shadow of toxic refineries right here. Two leading Indigenous Amazonian forest-protectors, sisters Nina and Helena Gualinga, appeal to Californians (and all of us) to #EndAmazonCrude and demand corporate responsibility for people and planet.

Watch more here.


The Sacred Headwaters Initiative: Protecting the Amazon Region

The ecological systems of the Amazon have long been threatened by damaging industries. Oil and mining operations have caused massive deforestation within the incredibly diverse and vital Amazonian ecosystems that many refer to as “the lungs of the world.” On the frontlines of efforts to protect the Amazon are more than 20 Indigenous communities, fighting for their homes, lands, and the wellbeing of the entire planet.

Atossa Soltani is the Director of Global Strategy for the Amazon Sacred Headwaters Initiative, an alliance of 30 Indigenous nations in Ecuador and Peru working to permanently protect 86 million acres of rainforests in one of the most biologically diverse ecosystems on Earth. Here, Atossa discusses the fight for the conservation of the Amazon’s Sacred Headwaters.

Read more here.


TAKE ACTION: Earth Defenders Toolkit

The Earth Defenders Toolkit is a collaborative space for earth defenders and their allies. The Toolkit provides a growing collection of resources and training materials for communities on the frontlines of the struggle to defend critical ecosystems around the world, and community networks for users to connect and share their experiences.

The mission of the Earth Defenders Toolkit is to provide and promote approaches to using technology in a way that supports local autonomy and ownership over tools and data, and reduces reliance on outside support.

“We were inspired to co-create the Earth Defenders Toolkit by the work of our Indigenous partners in the Amazon, who have been leveraging tools for mapping & monitoring to win key victories to protect their lands,” says Emily Jacobi, Executive Director & Founder of Digital Democracy. “Since launching the Toolkit last year, we’ve been blown away by the interest from grassroots groups around the world, and the dozens of communities across five continents who‘ve let us know how they’re applying featured tools & tactics from the Toolkit in their work. While contexts might be different, I’ve been struck by the similarities of what local earth defenders are up against: From Brazil to Cambodia, Uganda to Vanuatu, local and Indigenous communities are putting their bodies on the line to protect their lands from desperate and often violent attempts to extract resources as part of the dying gasps of the fossil fuel economy.”

Learn more here.


Nemonte Nenquimo – Indigenous Guardianship is Key to Halting the Climate Crisis

For millennia Indigenous communities have been guardians of their environments, protecting flora and fauna, using their traditional knowledge and wisdom passed down over generations to live in balance within their ecosystems. Today Indigenous peoples safeguard 80% of the biodiversity left in the world, and protecting those lands and waters is crucial to mitigating the climate crisis, because those biodiverse areas are among the planet’s major carbon sinks. Indigenous peoples are the ancestral owners of nearly half of the intact forest left across the entire Amazon Basin.

Nemonte Nenquimo, a leader from the Waorani community in Ecuador, Goldman Prize Winner, and a founding member of the Indigenous-led Ceibo Alliance and its partner, Amazon Frontlines, discusses why respecting Indigenous people’s internationally recognized rights to decide the future of their territories, cultures and lives is critically urgent for the protection of our world’s most important rainforest, our climate, and life on our planet.

Watch more here.


Amazon Crude Update: Ecuador Declares Moratorium on New Oil, Mining Concessions

Encouraging news is coming out of Ecuador that could bolster Indigenous rights and keep fossil fuels destined for California permanently in the ground! On September 9th, Ecuador declared a temporary moratorium on new oil and mining concessions, which will remain in place for at least 12 months or until there is a law guaranteeing the right to free, prior and informed consent for Indigenous peoples before such activities can take place in their territories. 

Read more here.


Bioneers Must Watch Staff Pick – The Territory

The Territory is a heartbreaking and powerful testament to what can be achieved when people come together across cultural divides to protect the planet. Co-produced by a settler-descendant American and members of the Uru-eu-wau-wau community, The Territory immerses viewers in the rampant destruction of the Amazon rainforest from the eyes of its Indigenous inhabitants resisting the aggressions of settlers seeking to steal their land. 

Read more here.


Less Oil More Water in the Amazon

Learn more and support Amazon Frontlines.


Report: Amazonia Against the Clock

Amazonia for Life: 80% Protection by 2025 is led by the Coordinator of Indigenous Organizations of the Amazon River Basin (COICA). COICA is the umbrella organization of the Indigenous federations of the Amazon Basin countries. It advocates for Indigenous peoples’ rights of 511 nationalities and groups that live in the Basin, which include close to 100 uncontacted communities.

Read their new report.

Amazon Crude Update: Ecuador Declares Moratorium on New Oil, Mining Concessions

Encouraging news is coming out of Ecuador that could bolster Indigenous rights and keep fossil fuels destined for California permanently in the ground! On September 9th, Ecuador declared a temporary moratorium on new oil and mining concessions, which will remain in place for at least 12 months or until there is a law guaranteeing the right to free, prior and informed consent for Indigenous peoples before such activities can take place in their territories. The agreement between the Indigenous movement and the administration of President Guillermo Lasso halts any new contracts for 16 Amazonian oil blocks, putting government plans to auction the concessions in the next year on hold and creates a window of opportunity to permanently stop these potential projects before they start. 

“These exciting developments on the ground in Ecuador need to be met with action from the north to end California’s complicity in Amazon destruction and convert these positive advances for Indigenous rights and forest protection into permanent victories.”

Leila Salazar-Lopez, Executive Director of Amazon Watch.

The agreement comes on the heels of recent legal challenges that could also restrict oil extraction of Ecuador’s largest oil reserves – Ishpingo, Tambococha, Tiputini (ITT) – underneath Yasuní National Park. A recent decision by the country’s national electoral court revived a case that could put the question of whether to leave the ITT fields permanently in the ground before voters in a national referendum as early as February 2023. And a hearing that started in August by the Inter-American Court of Human Rights could give territorial rights to two Indigenous peoples living in isolation, expanding a “no-go” zone for them and restricting both new wells and some currently in production.

While the Indigenous movement is also calling for a moratorium on current oil and mining production and for all new concessions to be canceled, the agreement is a necessary first step towards avoiding the lock-in of concession contracts and projects without securing the consent of Indigenous peoples.

 #EndAmazonCrude

Learn more from Amazon Watch.

Returning to What Was Lost and Stolen with Corrina Gould

Defending land rights and preserving tribal culture is difficult for North American tribes, especially for those that do not have sovereign nation-to-nation status with the federal government. The lack of recognition of a tribe’s nationhood as a self-governing entity (as defined by the U.S. Constitution) has been explicitly used as a tool to continue to prevent Native peoples from living on the most desirable lands or protecting sacred lands that have been stolen. 

We talk about these issues with Corrina Gould, a celebrated leader and activist of the First Peoples of the Bay Area from the Lisjan/Ohlone tribe of Northern California.  She also co-founded the grassroots organization “Indian People Organizing for Change”, which works to defend and preserve sacred Ohlone shell mounds formed over generations.

To listen to the first part of this program, click here.

Corrina Gould (Lisjan/Ohlone) is the chair and spokesperson for the Confederated Villages of Lisjan, as well as the Co-Director for The Sogorea Te’ Land Trust, a women-led organization within the urban setting of her ancestral territory of the Bay Area that works to return Indigenous land to Indigenous people. Born and raised in her ancestral homeland, the territory of Huchiun, she is the mother of three and grandmother of four. Corrina has worked on preserving and protecting the sacred burial sites of her ancestors throughout the Bay Area for decades.

Corrina Gould

Resources

California Indian Genocide and Resilience | 2017 Bioneers panel in which four California Indian leaders share the stories of kidnappings, mass murders, and slavery that took place under Spanish, Mexican and American colonizations — and how today’s generation is dealing with the contemporary implications.

This is an episode of Indigeneity Conversations, a podcast series that features deep and engaging conversations with Native culture bearers, scholars, movement leaders, and non-Native allies on the most important issues and solutions in Indian Country. Bringing Indigenous voices to global conversations. Visit the Indigeneity Conversations homepage to learn more.

Credits

Executive Producer: Kenny Ausubel

Co-Hosts and Producers: Cara Romero and Alexis Bunten

Senior Producer: Stephanie Welch

Associate Producer and Program Engineer: Emily Harris

Consulting Producer: Teo Grossman

Studio Engineers: Brandon Pinard and Theo Badashi

Tech Support: Tyson Russell

This episode’s artwork features photography by Toby McLeod. Mer Young creates the series collage artwork.

Additional music provided by Nagamo.ca, connecting producers and content creators with Indigenous composers.


Transcript

ALEXIS BUNTEN: Hi, Everyone. Welcome to Indigeneity Conversations. I’m Alexis Bunten, co-host and also co-director of the Bioneers Indigeneity Program along with Cara Romero.

CARA ROMERO: Hi Everyone. Today we have part two of a wonderful conversation I had with Corrina Gould, a celebrated leader and activist of the First Peoples of the Bay Area from the Lisjan/Ohlone tribe of Northern California. Born and raised in her ancestral homeland, Corrina is the mother of three, and grandmother of four.

I talked with Corrina about the critical differences between federally recognized and non-federally recognized tribes. There are historical and contemporary inequities that those differences present when it comes to defending land rights, preserving culture, and having a sovereign nation-to-nation status with the federal government. 

I’m particularly delighted about this conversation between two California Native women. I’m an enrolled citizen of the Chemehuevi Indian tribe, a federally recognized tribe of Southern California. But like many tribes in California, the Confederated Villages of the Lisjhan do not have federal recognition.

AB: Corrina is the Co-Founder and Co-Director of the Sogorea Te’ Land Trust, a Native American land conservancy in the heart of an urban epi-center.

She also co-founded the grassroots organization “Indian People Organizing for Change” which works to defend and preserve sacred Ohlone shell mounds formed over generations. She’ll be talking today about the efforts to save those shell mounds from development.

CR: So now let’s go to my conversation with Corrina Gould…


CR: Corrina, what has it been like, because you are an activist in the Bay Area. First, can you tell the audience about the shell mounds of the Bay Area? And can you also talk about what it’s been like to try and protect what’s left of your land base without federal recognition?

CORRINA GOULD: So shell mounds are our traditional burial sites, our ceremonial places, our villages. It’s a part of a landscape. And what I like to say is that, you know, we are looking at this climate crisis right now, and everybody’s talking about leaving a smaller footprint on the Earth. Right? And so our ancestors did that. For thousands of years they left this small footprint. Our houses, our boats, our basket materials, almost everything we utilized was biodegradable, went back into the land. Right? My ancestors left few things behind – our mortars and pestles, our arrowheads, our shell beads, and our shell mounds, these monuments that my ancestors created burying our people in the land covered by soil and shell, and over thousands of years grew to be sometimes three story high. And they were devastated by the mass influx of people in the Bay Area, not just the Spanish or Mexican rancho period, but really around the time of the 49ers, and when the United States got here, the Bay Area became this booming place, and they began to level out our shell mounds and to build on top of them.

Partial destruction of the Emeryville shell mound for the building of an industrial plant in 1924

At that time, you have to remember, we had no laws protecting us. And we have still few laws that protect our sacred places. And so when I started working on this with Johnella LaRose we created Indian People Organizing for Change, but around 1998, when the Internet blew up in the Bay Area, it caused a huge wave of people to move out of the Bay Area, including Native people, because they couldn’t afford it anymore, because people that had made money with the Internet had started outbidding each other for houses and apartments here in the Bay Area, and it caused people to start building more.

And around that time, they started hitting many places that my ancestors were buried at because of that. And we realized that nobody in the Bay Area knew what shell mounds were. People still thought we didn’t exist, you know, Ohlone people were all dead. And it was at that time that Johnella and I started really fighting against the City of Emeryville and other places that were destroying our sacred sites, and really educating our intertribal Native people that lived in the Bay Area, and really getting people to come out and talk about protecting of the sacred and why it was important.

map of shell mounds in the Bay Area, 1909
Image courtesy of Sogorea Te’ Land Trust

In 1909, this man named Nels Nelson created a map, because back in 1909, before my mother was even born, this man knew that these shell mounds were important places to our ancestors, and he created a map of 425 of these shell mounds that were in the Bay Area, 425 places where there was villages and there were ceremonial places, places that we buried our ancestors at, beautiful landscapes that were being destroyed by development in 1909.

Today we find this development happening in the Bay Area again, this wave of people building and building, using the excuse that there’s not enough housing, knowing full well that the housing that they’re building will not be able to put the people that are on streets in them. The housing that they’re building is because of greed. There is more than enough housing here to house everybody. But in the meantime, they’re taking every inch that’s left of the Bay Area, and they’re destroying it.

Today, you know, I’ve been fighting the destruction of our shell mounds for over 20 years. The Bay Street Mall was built on the largest of all 425. I’ve been in battle with a developer for over four and a half years for our oldest shell mound, the West Berkeley shell mound on 4th and University, which looks like a parking lot today, but it’s the very first place our ancestors lived along the waters where freshwater met saltwater, along that marshy place where it aligns with our sacred Alcatraz Island and aligns with our Western Gate, where people think the Golden Gate Bridge is now. You know, these sacred places and landscapes you don’t see because of the asphalt and the buildings on top of it. We have responsibility and obligations to those sacred places.

And so it’s been a fight to try to do that. And it has been allies and accomplices that have been coming to the side of us to help us to really talk about stopping the desecration of these sacred places. And so it’s really been an education process for the last 20 years, first to tell the cities in the Bay Area that we still are alive, that Ohlone people are still here; second to educate people about what our sacred places is and why it’s their responsibility to help us to save them now that they live on our traditional territory, and as good guests, they should work with the host of whose land they’re on.

And then there’s the other side of it, also having the burden of having to know which development in which city is happening, answering to all of these different developers wanting to consult about it, and if you miss one, you could be in danger of losing something precious.

Prior to our tribe getting onto the Native American Heritage Commission list, there was a development that was approved. And so we didn’t have anything to do with it until they found a body.

And what happened to this grandma was that she was the first body that was found. And we thought she was the only one that was going to be found. And today, they’re literally unearthing anywhere between 50 and 100 of my relatives in order for them to put a development on top of it. So it’s not something that’s in the past. It’s continuing today that we are dealing with this historical trauma that creates issues with our health, that creates problems with our people that is devastating, not just to Ohlone people on this territory, but it should be devastating to everybody that now lives on our lands, that a Native cemetery that is thousands of years old, older than the pyramids of Egypt, can be destroyed so that they can put something impermanent on top of it.

Emeryville Shellmound Memorial (Emeryville, CA). Smerdis/Wikimedia Commons

CR: I think that that is the purpose of all of the erasure of our history in schools, our erasure of representation in the media, our dehumanization of California Native Peoples, the lack of federal recognition is all to continue genocide, to continue the great taking of landscape. 

And one of the things that we talk about in the South is that people need to be reminded that no matter the amount of development or the amount of time that’s passed since the sacred sites have been invigorated, that those places are not dead, that those places might be dormant but that they can be brought back to life. I would like to talk about the Sogorea Te’ Land Trust. Can you talk about the founding of the Sogorea Te’ Land Trust and what it is?

CG: I’d love to talk about the Sogorea Te’ Land Trust because it’s my ancestors’ dream come true, I believe.

There’s a story that I remember of our salmon run that was written in a diary by a Spanish soldier as they were chasing my ancestors. They got to the Carquinez Strait, and it was during a salmon run, and they wrote in their diary that they lost my ancestors but when they looked into the water, that there were so many salmon that they could practically walk across to the other side on their backs.

Now we’ve never seen a salmon run like that in our lifetimes, and wouldn’t it be beautiful and be blessed for us to do that, to have that salmon come home like that.

On the other side of that waterway is Sogorea Te’. It was one of the last strongholds of my ancestors. They didn’t get taken to missions until about 1810, and it was a place– always where a creek meets a saltwater body. And there’s a creek that runs through there, and there were two shell mounds that were there. And for months we had been trying to figure out how to stop the devastation from happening there. And in April of 2011, when the city filed bankruptcy, they gave the park district $30,000 worth of permits for free in order for them to destroy this sacred area. There was eight of us at that time that were on the committee to save Sogorea Te’ – four women, four men, four Native and four non-Native people. And we all looked at each other at the same time and said, “What do we do?” And then we all said, “We have to take it back.”

And we took back that sacred land for 109 days. We had a sacred fire that was lit there by Fred Short who was the Northern California American Indian movement spiritual advisor. And at the same time that that fire was lit, four other fires around the world was lit that stayed going as long as ours did.

On day 99 of that takeover, there was people from all walks of life that came and created a village site there. And of course there was Homeland Security and the Coast Guard off the water and the police department and the fire department all showing up, but people stayed there and we had ceremony together. And it changed us as human beings. We remembered what it was like to live together in a village again, to rely on each other for food and for water, for each person to have purpose and to create their own job that helped the rest of the community.

After 109 days, we left there because the first cultural easement between a city, a park, and two federally recognized tribes was created in the country. It was because we took that stand that that was able to happen. So the Patwin people paid into this cultural easement so that they have the same rights to that land as the park district and the city, and no one entity could ever change the land without the other two’s approval. And so that would save it forever. They had to sign some crazy document saying that no more than 10 Indians would ever gather there again, and that no big drums would be there. And we were angry about that until we realized that we didn’t sign the contract. And so every year, we show up with hundreds of people to do our traditional responsibilities and pray at that site, and pray back those salmon to come home, and working with another non-federally recognized leader in California, Caleen Sisk, who is the chief of the Winnemen Wintu, to do that salmon walk and that prayer run with her every year.

As a non-federally recognized tribe, we don’t have a land base. And so for years we had been praying in front of the Hearst Museum asking for those thousands of ancestral remains to come home. But what if they would come home? Where would they come home to? We have no place to put them back to rest. So this land trust was really about how do we get them home so we could do that. How do we build a place for my grandchildren, my nieces and nephews to come back to the song and the language?

And the Sogorea Te’ Land Trust was blessed a few years ago to get our first piece of land. This had been in the works for years. I had started the campaign to save the West Berkeley shell mound, Standing Rock was happening, and this man named Gavin and his wife Haleh run an organization, an organic nursery in East Oakland, in one of the most depressed parts of East Oakland, half a mile walk from my house, and it’s called Planting Justice. They work with formerly incarcerated men so that when they get out of prison they have a place to go and to have a job. On this two-acre nursery that they have, it runs along the Lisjan Creek, the waterway that we’re responsible to. And they offered us a quarter acre of land on that two-acre plot that was not being used by them at the time, that had transmissions on it and garbage, and we took that land. It was the first land returned to us in 250 years. Johnella worked on that land, and we hired someone else, and transformed that land to grow our medicinal plants and food. And we gathered together and found a place where we could cut down redwoods, and we brought them back to Oakland. And after praying for each of those redwood trees to give their lives so that we can create an arbor on our land.

After a year of working on those logs and then drying, and hundreds of people putting their hands on it, we put up that arbor, the first one in our territory in 250 years. When you walk into it, in the middle of the city to see an arbor standing there, it still takes away my breath.

Photo courtesy of Sogorea Te’ Land Trust

CR: I very much admire the work that you’ve done to create the Sogorea Te’ Land Trust, and I would implore people to find out more about the ancestral homelands that they live on, because throughout the United States, whether it seems that you’ve moved into an area that was empty, I guarantee you there is a rich indigenous history on the lands that you live on, and this is a beautiful way to get involved and help reinvigorate and wake up those sacred sites, and begin to live in reciprocity and re-indigenize, as all human beings in these areas, so that we can find balance. And Indigenous Peoples hold a sacred role to the health of the Earth and the people and the planet and these urban centers.

Protecting sacred sites and defending land rights is especially difficult when a tribe doesn’t have sovereign nation-to-nation status with the U.S. federal government. So Corrina and I shifted our conversation to talk about the kinds of complications that lack of recognition creates. I started by backtracking a bit to my own tribe’s federal recognition, and how that changed the course of not only my tribe’s history, but also our family history.

So our tribe had a very vast land base that was then condensed into a small reservation that wasn’t where the majority of our tribe was traditionally from. And then in addition to that, after the Great Depression, the United States government had what was called the Reformation Act, and they wanted to dam up all the rivers to create hydroelectric energy. And—So in addition to not having federal recognition and kind of trying to survive, the one, condensed land base that we received was then flooded in the name of hydroelectric energy to create energy jobs for the United States. And it took my ancestors many years to reorganize, but not after another suffering. You know, it was another great sadness. We lost our fertile valley. We lost an agricultural area, which to the Native Americans of that time, you know, a recreational lake did not make sense. The settlers had taken everything that was important in the name of development. They flooded the agricultural plains. They flooded out the basket materials. So all the riparian belt, the cottonwoods and the willows that grew in the wetlands along the river, the feeding areas for all of the wild game – the rabbits, the deer – was all gone, and now our reservation was this chunk of salty mesa, basically, out in the desert.

So our tribe didn’t really come back together to gain their federal recognition in the 1960s and ‘70s. There were some cousins that got together. Like I’m sure it was happening all over California, people trying to seek their federal recognition and have a land base.

I think one of the other things that many people don’t understand is this whole era, right, of relocation and termination. And we don’t have to go into all of that here, but I think it’s very important that there were 55 treaties for federal recognition that were not ratified in California. And I think it’s very important for people to understand that many of the tribes that were not federally recognized were in these geographic locations along the Western coast, the ocean-side tribes. I’m sure your tribe was one of those. Can you talk a little bit about the 1950s and how that affected your tribe’s federal recognition?

CG: You know, it kind of went before that, Cara, because we were affected by Dorrington, who was the head of the BIA in 1927. And in 1927, he was given an order by the United States government to provide the amount of money needed to purchase land for homeless Indians in the territories that he was in charge of. And he was an alcoholic. And he did not answer the correspondence coming from Washington, D.C. It was finally a telegram that was sent to him that told him that if he did not answer the correspondence that he would be required to go to D.C. and answer them there. And he quickly penned a letter and said that for all intents and purposes, the Native people from our territory didn’t exist anymore, and so there was no money needed to purchase land for the tribes in our territory.

And so with that, we stopped having government-to-government relationships. We were never terminated as a tribe. But we stopped having communications with—You know, the Bureau of Indian Affairs would not do anything for us anymore.

It was during—I think it was later on that some of my relatives – and they were always women that were doing this work, right, started doing this work of trying to get us on that Indian roll, it really was around trying to have that recognition as tribal people. The roll number was about that. It was about really trying to prove we have these connections to our tribal lands, we have connections to our communities and our elders.

There is maybe one tribe along the coast of California that is federally recognized. What happened? Why is it that these mission Indians are not recognized by the federal government?

The Bay land is the most, in terms of Western ideology, it is the richest land in the country. And so why would they want to have Native people have access to that land? So being non-federally recognized has stopped us from having a land base, not having federal recognition, does not put us at the table with the federal government about infrastructure and about creating programs around education and medical. So we have been homeless in our own homelands—since contact now.

CR: I think it’s very important for the audience to understand is with federal recognition comes not only the government-to-government status, this nation-to-nation status, this idea of inherent sovereignty of the tribes which provides protections for religious gathering, which provides land base, and which also provides environmental protections or is supposed to provide environmental protections for things like protecting sacred sites, things like protecting sacred sites from development and resource extraction.

And I hope for the audience, especially our audience members that live along the coast of California, that they can take away from this conversation both the importance of federal recognition and how tribes that are not federally recognized have been affected, and how they can continue to help be protectors of those landscapes, and to acknowledge the ancestral peoples of those homelands, and continue helping them protect their sacred sites and reinvigorate those sacred sites, because while they may not have federal recognition, they very much exist. They very much continue to fight for the rich histories of their landscapes and for the many people and ancestors that came before them, that gifted them the knowledge of the area. So I just implore the audience members that are there along the California coast to learn your true history of those urban epicenters of the California coast, and continue learning how to become good allies to California Native Peoples.

Corrina, thank you so much. 

CG: Thank you so much, Cara. I send a lot of love from our people to your people, from my heart to your heart.

AB: We’re so delighted to have been able to have such a wonderful conversation with Corrina Gould. If you didn’t hear part one yet, you can go to our website bioneers.org. And in addition to that episode, you can find other episodes of Indigeneity Conversations there to listen to as well as other original Indigenous media content. 

CR: You’ll also learn about the Indigeneity program and all of our initiatives, including curricula and learning materials for students and life-long learners.

Thank you for joining us for this episode of Indigeneity Conversations. It’s been a pleasure to share with all of you today. Many thanks and take care!


Sign up to stay connected for new episodes!

The Sacred Headwaters Initiative: Protecting the Amazon Region

The ecological systems of the Amazon have long been threatened by damaging industries. Oil and mining operations have caused massive deforestation within the rich, planet-healing Amazonian ecosystems that many refer to as “the lungs of the world.” On the frontlines of efforts to protect the Amazon are more than 20 Indigenous communities, fighting for their home, land, and the wellbeing of the planet at large.

Atossa Soltani is the Director of Global Strategy for the Amazon Sacred Headwaters Initiative, an alliance of 30 Indigenous nations in Ecuador and Peru working to permanently protect 86 million acres of rainforests in one of the most biologically diverse ecosystems on Earth. She founded and is board president of Amazon Watch, of which she was the first executive director from 1996-2014. Atossa has been documenting and publicizing forest destruction and human rights abuses caused by extractive industries and large-scale energy projects throughout the Amazon for decades, and she’s led successful campaigns to force oil companies and international financial institutions to adopt stronger environmental and social standards.

Here, Atossa discusses the fight for Amazonian conservation with the Amazon Sacred Headwaters Initiative.

ATOSSA SOLTANI:

Atossa Soltani

The mass extinction crisis is one of the biggest challenges of our time. In the Amazon Basin, there are ever more catastrophic summer fires, bringing that immense forest perilously close to a tipping point of ecological unraveling. Already somewhere between 17 and 20% of the Amazon rainforest, which encompasses parts of 9 countries, has been destroyed or degraded. Once we get to a deforestation rate somewhere around 25%, we can expect to see an unraveling of entire ecological systems of the Amazon, so it’s imperative that we work hard and quickly to safeguard the future of the largest forest on the planet. Some call the Amazon “the lungs of the world,” but Indigenous peoples there have always said it’s the “heart of the planet.”

An average tree in the Amazon lifts up about a thousand liters of water a day into the atmosphere, so an area larger than the continental United States lifts up a river larger than the Amazon River, every day, into the sky. And that atmospheric river generates rain throughout South America and into the rest of the world. It’s one of the key engines of the global weather system, and it makes South America much lusher and greener than other continents in the same latitude.

Just to give you a scale of the size of the Amazon River itself: the flow at its mouth is 209,000 cubic meters per second, equal to that of the next six largest rivers of the world, combined! And then imagine a river 20% bigger than that, being lifted out of the forest every day and propelled into the atmosphere.

Some economists have estimated that 70% of South America’s GDP is dependent in one way or another on that rain, but fires each summer now are burning ever more millions of hectares of forest. One recent summer, Bolivia lost 40% of its forests. And to be clear, those are predominantly intentionally set, man-made fires set to expand cattle ranching and agriculture.

But there are, in some places, exciting initiatives bringing hope for change. I returned from Ecuador recently, and a really powerful, grassroots Indigenous peoples’ movement there was able to mobilize and force the government to listen to many of their demands to protect their territories.

It is especially crucial to save the most biodiverse parts of the region, and most of the plant species there haven’t yet been cataloged. There is so much we don’t know, and much of it could be lost forever if we don’t act now. Amazon Watch, the Pachamama Alliance, and many of our other colleagues have been working for the last 20-plus years in the Napo and Pastaza river basins, an area that has among the planet’s greatest bio and cultural diversity, as some 20 plus Indigenous nations live in this area, and they have been the best protectors of that biodiversity. In fact, globally, 80% of the world’s biodiversity is on Indigenous territories, and very often, the traditional stewardship of Indigenous cultures has produced the most exceptional results in protecting ecosystems.

These river basins begin high in the Ecuadorian Andes in the glaciers of sacred mountains. Many consider this area, which is larger than Oregon, the sacred headwaters of the Amazon. If business as usual is allowed to go on, most of this land will be converted to oil and mining operations. There are over 2,000 oil and mining concessions. In this region, oil is a huge driver of deforestation, whereas in other parts of the Amazon, such as in much of Brazil, it’s cattle ranching or agribusiness. Half of the oil extracted from the Ecuadorian Amazon ends up in refineries in California, so the protection of the Amazon is directly related to our energy consumption here in California.

The Sacred Headwaters Initiative that we’re working on is an unparalleled collaboration between Indigenous peoples and allied organizations. We’re working on trying to create a 74-million-acre bi-national Ecuador/Peru protected region, but an unusual one, because in this case, the region would be protected by Indigenous people with full rights to self-determination and stewardship, rather than just by governments. In fact, sometimes the land has to be protected from corrupt governments. Empowered Indigenous groups are far better protectors than just governments.

The climate contribution of preserving this forest would be enormous, somewhere around six billion tons of carbon that would not go into the atmosphere. But what do we need to do to protect this incredibly important forest? The first thing that the Indigenous folks have been demanding is that there be no further major resource extraction initiatives: no industrial-scale mining, oil drilling, agriculture, and no more dams and roads—nothing that is at odds with the fabric of life.

Secondly, these territories need to be governed based on a life-centric worldview. Indigenous inhabitants of this place have had that philosophical orientation for millennia, but for the last 20 years or so, they’ve been developing a vision and putting it on paper. They’ve been working on producing a community collective vision developed through many, many participatory activities seeking to build a consensus about a desirable future for their territories based on their cosmologies and values. They are talking about maintaining the tree cover and keeping their forest clean, abundant, and full of life so they can continue to live off the land and practice their traditional ways of being. They want to maintain their cultures while working on incorporating such positive modern additions as clean energy and scientific expertise in some areas. All of us might do well to emulate that sort of collective visioning process for our own communities.

The Sacred Headwaters Initiative is working to help the various local Indigenous people articulate and then combine their various “life plans” into an overarching bioregional plan for the protection of the whole area. There are many dimensions to it. One component is that we have also created a global commission of experts to help us find the best examples of ecosystem protection from around the world that can be drawn from to successfully protect this area.

This requires a radically different way of viewing land management. We have to shift the goals of the entire economic system to a holistic model that sees human prosperity as inseparable from regeneration and the flourishing of life. And this raises big challenges because Peru and Ecuador’s economies are largely based on income from resource extraction, and that’s true in most of the 17 most biodiverse countries in the world, mostly in the tropics. Getting those governments to keep fossil fuels in the ground and to stop mining in protected regions is a top global priority both for biodiversity conservation and climate stabilization, but it’s a very tough sell.

We are working globally on ideas around how to find funding to pay these governments of mega-biodiverse countries to transition their economies and get beyond fossil fuels. It was tried before in Ecuador before the Paris Climate Accord, and it failed, but we have to get creative and keep trying because these countries will need strong incentives to make those difficult transitions. And eventually, we need a deeper cure: We have to get away from the current economic model that’s at war with nature, that’s seeking to consume nature to convert it into cash.

My personal evolution of working on these issues came from the realization at a young age of the validity of the Gaia Hypothesis. I firmly believe that the Earth is a living system, a super-organism that seeks to perpetuate conditions conducive to life, and that we, the humans on this Earth, have to align ourselves with this larger super-organism and be productive cells in the body of that living Earth. I think that seeing the Earth as a living system of which we are productive members can bring a shift in identity and perspective that will help us find solutions.

Note: This is an edited/excerpted version of a presentation given at the Bioneers Conference.